Resource Season 40 Rules and Tribunal Thread

[Jabba73]

Do you have a charge to make or is this another fishing trip

Irrelevent.

If there is a charge, one cannot currently be brought to the Admin if the Admin is the subject of the charge. It is really not that hard to understand, the question is ... what happens in that situation?

 

[The Half Back]

Do you have a charge to make or is this another fishing trip

Yeh, the sim constantly ****ing the Warriors over every week. I want the sim to cop a 4 week suspension and a $20k ClarkeMonies fine.

 

[ClarkeM]

Irrelevent.

If there is a charge, one cannot currently be brought to the Admin if the Admin is the subject of the charge. It is really not that hard to understand, the question is ... what happens in that situation?

Well if it was the admin bringing the game into disrepute then this rule would probably come after the other rule about their capacity to fulfill the role as admin, and the whole committee vote and that shit that I can’t be bothered going back to reference.

So my view is that you can’t charge the admin with BTGID without first removing them from the role and THEN you could do that. Right?

 

[Kilroy]

Well if it was the admin bringing the game into disrepute then this rule would probably come after the other rule about their capacity to fulfill the role as admin, and the whole committee vote and that shit that I can’t be bothered going back to reference.

So my view is that you can’t charge the admin with BTGID without first removing them from the role and THEN you could do that. Right?

I think what you’re suggesting ClarkeM is he/she would need to not be a Captain for the process to be legit.

It’s definitely possible that their home team might show support, that’s understandable and certainly fair.

 

[Jabba73]

Yeh, the sim constantly ****ing the Warriors over every week. I want the sim to cop a 4 week suspension and a $20k ClarkeMonies fine.

Another slap with a wet lettuce leaf.

Inflation killed off what little value ClarkeMonies had back in Season 26

 

[Callums_Guns]

Do you have a charge to make or is this another fishing trip

bring back pantskyle

Jabba73 before you go on your Mad Monday fishing trip can you confirm that pantskyle is currently the acting Admin

 

[pantskyle]

Jabba73 before you go on your Mad Monday fishing trip can you confirm that pantskyle is currently the acting Admin

Yes please let me know.

 

[Jabba73]

Jabba73 before you go on your Mad Monday fishing trip can you confirm that pantskyle is currently the acting Admin

You mean pantskyle has been in charge all this time and didn't know?

 

[T2B_]

I don't think the admin has been this hated by the Bombers since NaturalDisaster .

Gralin you're doing something right I think

 

[Jabba73]

I don't think the admin has been this hated by the Bombers since NaturalDisaster .

Please. We loved NaturalDisaster as the Admin. While we didn't always see eye to eye, at least we could have adult conversations and inject humour into discussions to keep it civil. The faux outrage over the Admin bid fiasco was some of the best theatre this place has had in years.



There is no evidence of hate towards Gralin in asking how a rule can be applied when current circumstances do not permit the process to play out as it is written. That is simply due diligence and provides a path forward for if and when the rule might need to be invoked.

Do you honestly believe there will never be an Admin that would take advantage of the current rules not applying to them?

Gralin you're doing something right I think

No.

He refuses to answer even the simplest of questions and resorts to threats, insults and temper tantrums to avoid dealing with issues.

We are still none the wiser as to how the Admin proposes to move forward in fixing the issues with the rules because he is pretending that they should never apply to him. Sadly, he doesn't realise this is not about him, rather fixing the rules in the event they are ever needed to be enforced, now or in the future.


Ironically, this is drifting dangerously close to abrogating his responsibilities which would then be just cause for invoking the rules.

 

[DemurePrincess]

Please. We loved NaturalDisaster as the Admin. While we didn't always see eye to eye, at least we could have adult conversations and inject humour into discussions to keep it civil. The faux outrage over the Admin bid fiasco was some of the best theatre this place has had in years.



There is no evidence of hate towards Gralin in asking how a rule can be applied when current circumstances do not permit the process to play out as it is written. That is simply due diligence and provides a path forward for if and when the rule might need to be invoked.

Do you honestly believe there will never be an Admin that would take advantage of the current rules not applying to them?


No.

He refuses to answer even the simplest of questions and resorts to threats, insults and temper tantrums to avoid dealing with issues.

We are still none the wiser as to how the Admin proposes to move forward in fixing the issues with the rules because he is pretending that they should never apply to him. Sadly, he doesn't realise this is not about him, rather fixing the rules in the event they are ever needed to be enforced, now or in the future.


Ironically, this is drifting dangerously close to abrogating his responsibilities which would then be just cause for invoking the rules.

Hey Boss, you reckon season 41 spoon lickers will look good on us

 

[Jabba73]

Hey Boss, you reckon season 41 spoon lickers will look good on us

You honestly think we will win another award of any sort?

Yeah, me either. Second last will be close enough.

 

[DemurePrincess]

You honestly think we will win another award of any sort?

Yeah, me either. Second last will be close enough.

Oh! You missed the sarcasm completely!

 

[Kilroy]

I don't think the admin has been this hated by the Bombers since NaturalDisaster .

Gralin you're doing something right I think

No-one hated NaturalDisaster more than serial_thrilla surely?

 

[T2B_]

Please. We loved NaturalDisaster as the Admin. While we didn't always see eye to eye, at least we could have adult conversations and inject humour into discussions to keep it civil. The faux outrage over the Admin bid fiasco was some of the best theatre this place has had in years.



There is no evidence of hate towards Gralin in asking how a rule can be applied when current circumstances do not permit the process to play out as it is written. That is simply due diligence and provides a path forward for if and when the rule might need to be invoked.

Do you honestly believe there will never be an Admin that would take advantage of the current rules not applying to them?


No.

He refuses to answer even the simplest of questions and resorts to threats, insults and temper tantrums to avoid dealing with issues.

We are still none the wiser as to how the Admin proposes to move forward in fixing the issues with the rules because he is pretending that they should never apply to him. Sadly, he doesn't realise this is not about him, rather fixing the rules in the event they are ever needed to be enforced, now or in the future.


Ironically, this is drifting dangerously close to abrogating his responsibilities which would then be just cause for invoking the rules.

And what is the original issue with his admining exactly?

 

[Jabba73]

And what is the original issue with his admining exactly?

Where did anyone claim there was an issue?

 

[T2B_]

Where did anyone claim there was an issue?

I assumed there had to be a reason for all the kerfuffle

 

[Jabba73]

I assumed there had to be a reason for all the kerfuffle

I asked a question in the Rules thread about what the correct process is to follow for invoking Rule 3(d) in the event that the Admin is also a captain, citing the current set up of the league as an example of how the process cannot work when this is the case due to conflict of interest.

The meltdown is completely of Gralin's own making for reasons he will need to explain.

 

[serial_thrilla]

No-one hated NaturalDisaster more than serial_thrilla surely?

This could be taken two ways. Given how I am so lovable, I assume you mistakenly think I hated NaturalDisaster more than anyone.

 

[Kilroy]

This could be taken two ways. Given how I am so lovable, I assume you mistakenly think I hated NaturalDisaster more than anyone.

 

[NaturalDisaster]

No-one hated NaturalDisaster more than serial_thrilla surely?

Other way around.

 

[Kilroy]

Other way around.

#neverstopcampaigning

 

[ClarkeM]

"Please remember to include something that identifies your team (eg club logo) and correct Round number."

Given finals aren't prescribed as "round numbers", it would be worth a provision to make sure team sheets contain the necessary information for the match in which the game it is for.

Perhaps "Please remember to include something that identifies your team (eg club logo) and correct round number or final."

 

[BallaratBulldog]

Since it starts off with Please, end with Thank you. That way the reader feels good.

 

[ClarkeM]

Can we please introduce rules around match thread title formatting? Sheesh