Preview Selection Table R20 v Richmond

[Some Idiot]

I think you'll get your first win over us in what is it? 5 years this week.

7 Years, really don't want the streak to end.

Out: Libba, Tutt, Skinner
In: Sherman, Williams, Wood

 

[Libba39]

Out: Libba, Tutt, Skinner, Campbell
In: Panos (pleeeease), Sherman, Wood, Gilbee

B: Wood Lake Roughead
HB Pearce Talia Murphy
C Johanissen Wallis Griffen
HF Addison Grant Smith
FF Gia Panos Dickson

Foll: Minson Boyd Picken
Int: Sherman, Howard, Gilbee, Djerrkura (sub)

-Talia's one-on-one and reading of the play already puts him ahead of Williams imo
-Sherman in for one last crack before a possible delisting
-Panos - play the guy, at least we'll see if he might be good enough!

 

[acker]

If they are good enough I trust they will get a go

Lets be honest the performances Panos don't seem to be as deserving of a game this year as they were last year

If Panos has rested back on his laurels after being upgraded from the rookie list last year

Welcome to the food chain of AFL de-listing son - non performers like yourself + perhaps Hooper, Moles and only perform when the blowtorch is on me Sherman will be on the scrap heap.

 

[Rookie]

Out: Libba, Tutt, Skinner, DJ
In: Sherman, Williams, Wood, Vez / Panos

I guess the silver lining of Dahl and Tommy missing the rest of the year is that we'll get a closer look at JJ, Talia, Pearce etc and some of the guys like Sherman who are close to the edge.

Hope Tutt doesn't miss many weeks, I feel he has promise.

 

[Spiritsof82]

If they are good enough I trust they will get a go

Lets be honest the performances Panos don't seem to be as deserving of a game this year as they were last year

If Panos has rested back on his laurels after being upgraded from the rookie list last year

Welcome to the food chain of AFL de-listing son - non performers like yourself + perhaps Hooper, Moles and only perform when the blowtorch is on me Sherman will be on the scrap heap.

And Skinner has been deserving of a game?

 

[boydsno1]

well we have 3 def outs so far.

Out: Tutt(inj), Dahl(Inj) Libba(suspended)
In: Sherman, Williams, Wood

 

[TedDougChris]

And Skinner has been deserving of a game?

Certainly not yet, but I saw signs of improvement on the weekend. Only little things, and possibly not enough to save him, but improvement....

 

[dogwatch]

well we have 3 def outs so far.

Out: Tutt(inj), Dahl(Inj) Libba(suspended)
In: Sherman, Williams, Wood

No, Dahl didn't play (late withdrawal) so only two definite outs.

 

[d0gs]

Certainly not yet, but I saw signs of improvement on the weekend. Only little things, and possibly not enough to save him, but improvement....

Improvement? May I ask where?

 

[THE_GUN]

Whats the Deal with sherman guys , Richmond were after him big time when we got Houli & Grigg but the doggies got in before the tigers with a better offer. What has gone wrong for him & Why doesnt he get a go at the kennel

Also what would be his contract status is there a chance he may be delisted as 1 post implied ?
Good luck this week guys but hope we finally get 1 over you blokes

 

[TempleKelvington]

Well.....Cooney and Gilbee might be in the mix and Wood of course. Not surprised about Tutt he played like he was injured last week. Time to spell him for the year now and get those hammies right.

I'm hoping for Panos. Talia will more than likely stay in Macca usually likes players to get a couple of games if not more.

 

[stefoid]

For mine I would rather have Cambell, JJ or Austin on the main list than Skinner. Maybe rookie him with our last rookie pick if there isnt a rookie with better prospects available. But for now (out).

Out: Libba, Skinner, Tutt
In: Sherman, Williams, Wood.

And is Ayce rested or injured? If he is ready to play, play him and drop Cambell. Give Ayce as many games as we can.

 

[TedDougChris]

Improvement? May I ask where?

I saw signs that he is becoming more comfortable with putting physical pressure on, more recognition of the need to make second efforts, more chasing, bumping, tackling. He seemed to be more aware of the these parts of the role. You could almost see the light go on 'I need to chase this guy, I need to put pressure on', as he approached contests.

He still seems very far away from the endurance, strength and speed needed to play the game and I'm yet to see signs of the skill level that had people raving about him.

 

[Igloo]

Whats the Deal with sherman guys , Richmond were after him big time when we got Houli & Grigg but the doggies got in before the tigers with a better offer. What has gone wrong for him & Why doesnt he get a go at the kennel

Also what would be his contract status is there a chance he may be delisted as 1 post implied ?
Good luck this week guys but hope we finally get 1 over you blokes

He was just in terrible form really. Wasn't doing anything in the seniors, so he got dropped. 2 weeks ago he had an amazing game in the VFL, so he got the call up. Was a late withdrawal with an illness though.

I don't think he'll be delisted or traded. He'll get another year to prove himself.

 

[Ant_]

7 Years, really don't want the streak to end.

Out: Libba, Tutt, Skinner
In: Sherman, Williams, Wood

Yeah I've enjoyed smashing Richmond year after year. It will be a shame for that to end.

 

[Interloper]

In: ?????
Out/unavailable: Tutt (sore hammy), Higgins (sore hammy), Austin (sore wrist), Dahlhaus (sore ankle) and Liber (sore arse).
They’ll be sorely missed.

 

[Doggies_13]

Out: Libba (Susp) Tutt(Inj) Skinner Dj
In: Wood Sherman Williams Vesz

Line Up
B:Talia Lake Wood
HB: Murphy Roughead JJ
C: Howard Griffen Pearce
HF: Addison Williams Dickson
F: Gia Grant Campbell
FOLL: Minson Boyd Picken
INT: Sherman Smith Wallis SUB: Vesz

 

[fred cook]

In: Wood Sherman Williams Vesz

More downhill skiers there then Swedish 2012 Winter Olympic team

 

[dogzrule]

Out: Libba (Susp) Tutt(Inj) Skinner Dj
In: Wood Sherman Williams Vesz

Line Up
B:Talia Lake Wood
HB: Murphy Roughead JJ
C: Howard Griffen Pearce
HF: Addison Williams Dickson
F: Gia Grant Campbell
FOLL: Minson Boyd Picken
INT: Sherman Smith Wallis SUB: Vesz

I thought Vez played last week ?

Out: Libba (Susp) Tutt(Inj) Skinner Dj
In Sherman, Williams, Wood, Panos (wont happen)

 

[Doggies_13]

In: Wood Sherman Williams Vesz

More downhill skiers there then Swedish 2012 Winter Olympic team

Do you ever offer an opinion or just criticise everyone elses.

we lose 2 runners definately in libba and tutt, so we need to replace them with runners let me guess you would bring in cordy and maybe try and live in the glory days and bring gilbee back in. We need to give Vesz and Sherman a last chance to perform or be outed at the end of the year.

pretty funny when you just crictise and don't produce an opinion of your own for anyone else to critcise

 

[Igloo]

Changes and discussion are over in the FaceOff thread. Closed.