Selwood or Dangerfield?

[yoodooright]

Based purely on this year, who would you rather have in your side? I think last year this was a no contest in Dangers favour but Selwood has lifted to another level (again) this year and adds not only his individual contribution, but also his leadership. thusly: Selwood for mine. I think if you slotted Selwood into the crows midfield we would be all out flag favorites, I am not so sure that the same could be said of Dangerfield. Thoughts? The guy who is leading the AFLCA votes, or the reigning brownlow medalist?

 

[doona]

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

danger wins the ball quick and kicks goals

 

[Jim Prideaux]

Danger as a player, Selwood as a Captain. Currently my team needs Danger more.

 

[yoodooright]

Danger as a player, Selwood as a Captain. Currently my team needs Danger more.

You have Hodge, who fulfills the leadership role admirably - whether or not he is Captain. I think Adelaide, Richmond, and GWS would all benefit more from Selwood than Danger. Perhaps Melbourne & Carlton also?

 

[Podsnap]

Selwood. Extraordinary player and captain. Drags the team across the line time and time again. I'm privileged to be able to watch him every week.

 

[Jim Prideaux]

You have Hodge, who fulfills the leadership role admirably - whether or not he is Captain. I think Adelaide, Richmond, and GWS would all benefit more from Selwood than Danger. Perhaps Melbourne & Carlton also?

Not to pot any captains, but Brisbane, Port and Collingwood come to mind also. All three have decent to strong midfields, but could do with a bit more mongrel/ leadership.

 

[vide0n]

Selwood

 

[yoodooright]

danger wins the ball quick and kicks goals

I think Richmond would be far better off with Selwood. Adds exactly what you are missing, IMO

 

[Catsnlakers]

Danger is a champion....But Selwood's arrival in 2007 was one of the biggest things in the history of our club, it is no coincidence we become a force once he arrived, Selwood for me.

 

[Wojcinski]

Selwood for his leadership and courage

 

[Slats]

DangerWood.

 

[The Swert]

Selwood clearly, there's two of them.

 

[yoodooright]

Not to pot any captains, but Brisbane, Port and Collingwood come to mind also. All three have decent to strong midfields, but could do with a bit more mongrel/ leadership.

Good game. We lack leadership. I feel we would have won tonight with Selwood in the mix - results like this are so indicative in that regard.

 

[Jim Prideaux]

Good game. We lack leadership. I feel we would have won tonight with Selwood in the mix - results like this are so indicative in that regard.

Completely agree, you guys have had a good season so far, but have struggled in tight games. That's where Selwood would help so much. Condolences, you'll be thereabouts come seasons end.

 

[Power Raid]

danger any day of the week

 

[BF Tiger]

Selwood for me.

 

[sobrave]

Something something ducking, something something throwing the head back and flopping

Good players though.

 

[Jakksynn]

Danger. I'd be ashamed to support a team that has that ducking flog Selwood. Absolutely no respect for him as a player.

 

[citizen-erased]

Dangerfield.

Danger. I'd be ashamed to support a team that has that ducking flog Selwood. Absolutely no respect for him as a player.

this is why.

Can't watch Selwood anymore.
champion player, but f**k i hate his antics

 

[yoodooright]

Danger. I'd be ashamed to support a team that has that ducking flog Selwood. Absolutely no respect for him as a player.

Wow, that seems a hysterical response. Im sure that you are of your word though - if port somehow wrangled to trade for Selwood you would duly no longer support them. Its absurdities like this that make it hard to have a serious discussion on Bigfooty

 

[Sttew]

Wow, that seems a hysterical response. Im sure that you are of your word though - if port somehow wrangled to trade for Selwood you would duly no longer support them. Its absurdities like this that make it hard to have a serious discussion on Bigfooty

Spot on.

 

[The Falcon Strike]

dangerfield for mine - a more damaging player

 

[Jakksynn]

Wow, that seems a hysterical response. Im sure that you are of your word though - if port somehow wrangled to trade for Selwood you would duly no longer support them. Its absurdities like this that make it hard to have a serious discussion on Bigfooty

Didn't say I wouldn't support them, it would just make it much harder to do so.

 

[yoodooright]

Didn't say I wouldn't support them, it would just make it much harder to do so.

If your club could straight swap say Sam Gray for Joel Selwood - as a supporter, would you condone that? I mean, I know we are all parochial, love our own & loathe the enemy, but there reaches a point where it is just absurd, surely?