I'd have put the pass mark as winning a final or transitioning the side by getting bulk games into the kids. We had a season in which we were pretty fortunate with injury, and of or last 3 drafts only consistently played 2 young players. We didn't get the finals win so we fell just short of a pass for mine.
Worsfold needs to show signs that the club is improving on field before we can offer him an extension. Next year we must have a good reason for not advancing to the second week if it's to be a pass - 8+ games into guys that didn't play this year, a joe ACL or bulk injuries etc
To start by picking up on a theme in one of your earlier posts, this team is very different to that which last played in the finals. I don't think that it's accurate to say that the team hasn't changed or that we are still relying on the same players. I think what has happened is that the improvements made in the forward line and other really positive changes have been offset by the degeneration of the midfield and the reality that the kids who have replaced high quality players we lost are still growing into their roles.
I'm critical of the way we managed this year but I don't believe that it was Worsfold's decision (there were other non-football issues at play). When I think about it, the integration of McKenna, Gleeson and Stewart was a big part of salvaging some of this year as a development year.
The reality of our situation is that with a midfielder loaded with ?s and a list which now becomes significantly younger we need to manage ourselves accordingly.
I've just said that I'd wait to see what next year looks like before making a decision but having thought about itmore, I now think that we should give him an extra year. Take the pressure off and allow the list to grow. I don't expect the team to go backwards but it might.
We don't need another 12 months of selecting sides to play finals. It seems that every other club trusts it's kids. It's time we do too.