Sorry but Rubbish. Carltons problem wasnt the fact Malthouse couldnt coach, Carltons issue was over exaggerating where its list was at and making bad drafting/recruiting decisions which happened before and during Malthouse reign.
As i have said before Leigh Matthews at lions, Blight at Crowes, Roos at Swans, Choco at Port didnt go through processes and ended up ok, even Ross Lyon was head hunted by Freo.
on the other hand Mark Neeld, Scott Watters, went through club processes????