-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
SFL Division 1 Only
- Thread starter chaddles
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Status
superfreak
Premiership Player
Anyone hear the interview with him on SEN last night (with OX and Francis)? Was very one sided and sympathetic until a St Pauls player rang in and set the record straight that he wasnt up just as a witness.........wonder what will happen next.
Not sure if the league were too happy with the AFL Vic decision either. But good luck to Jonny Mac and City. will make for a good forwardline with Cass returns
Not sure if the league were too happy with the AFL Vic decision either. But good luck to Jonny Mac and City. will make for a good forwardline with Cass returns
- Thread starter
- #1,003
I think it is very disappointing - especially considering Rob Lemon (even though he is a crazy bitch) got deregistered for the over 16 games law. But what else do you expect from St Kilda... they would appeal if a water runner got caught in the 50 and a free kick was awarded to them.
backtoback08
Team Captain
City are rapt and good on them for exhausting all avenues, the facts are the league only pulled his permit when they found his record breached 16 weeks, they didnt have to do anything but warn him but went one step further, he was not found guilty on any count or incident at stpauls. We all know lemon was a nutcase he decked 3 blokes behind play before getting his 1st report , very dangerous character.
The only reason the half time incident was mentioned at the league was a 2nd division president who was at the game whinged to the league about how it affected the image of the game, what a tosser.
Also St Pauls might be in a bit of strife for playing an ineligible player this year, any one heard this whisper,has something to do an overqualified VFL player ????? If true, We will see whether the league takes them to task over it. Do you lose points for ineligble players? Sounds like cheating to me, it will be a classic if the leagues love children get nailed!
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
has he even played enough games to qualify considering he has missed these past games..
what did happen with him trying to charge the rooms at half time, if that was the case he must feel pretty embarresed if he wants to be a boxer get in the ring not the footy field..
what did happen with him trying to charge the rooms at half time, if that was the case he must feel pretty embarresed if he wants to be a boxer get in the ring not the footy field..
benchman
Senior List
he's already plyaed 7 games, so yes he has qualified
Whippet
Debutant
The rule for deregistering a player after 16 weeks of suspensions over a career is silly anyhow. Especially for a guy that has played for about 17 seasons. I'm of the belief that if this rule applied to the AFL, then Shane Crawford would be deregistered. Hardly a thug!!! Surely it needs to be done in a similar manner to a car licence, where over a time, your lost demerit points lapse, and you get them back. If its someone getting 16 weeks over 5 years, then it definately has to be looked at.
BFAMB
Draftee
The leagues love children? who are you talking about you idiot, St kilda city, you must be, they are the leagues love children.
- Banned
- #1,009
its pretty hard to actually get reported at all at this standard. someone who gets that many weeks even if its over a long time is probably a d!ck head as is.
i think you may find a few of them were at vfl level. it will be interesting to see if rogerson wants to lead with the headbutt again in the first final? it is a funny sight when rogerson gets forced to put boot to ball has he had the same kicking coach as mackenzie someone should put a bell in the ball for these two
- Banned
- #1,011
i think you may find a few of them were at vfl level. it will be interesting to see if rogerson wants to lead with the headbutt again in the first final? it is a funny sight when rogerson gets forced to put boot to ball has he had the same kicking coach as mackenzie someone should put a bell in the ball for these two
how much you selling 10 packs for now spiros?
did the recent bust hurt your family business?
cuttingedge
Team Captain
Did they lose the points for the games they cheated?
stinky wingman
Senior List
i think you may find a few of them were at vfl level. it will be interesting to see if rogerson wants to lead with the headbutt again in the first final? it is a funny sight when rogerson gets forced to put boot to ball has he had the same kicking coach as mackenzie someone should put a bell in the ball for these two
yet.....they are playing senior football, and your posting on bigfooty with the rest of us ?! Perspective.
cuttingedge
Team Captain
So playing inelgible players is not cheating,?trying to qualify players for finals by being shifty and getting caught is not cheating?
Your club should be ashamed of yourselves and get your act together!!!!!!
Jonah Lomu
Debutant
So playing inelgible players is not cheating,?trying to qualify players for finals by being shifty and getting caught is not cheating?
Your club should be ashamed of yourselves and get your act together!!!!!!
Why don't you name the player and why he is ineligible?
backtoback08
Team Captain
Pretty sure its Peter Mercoulia and and something to do with 10 game VFL rule , apparently played aginst CHelt ones and a couple of twos game after being over the threshold, so I would think that is shithouse by st pauls, if I was one of the clubs they cheated against I would going for the points. This info came form a St Paulks official so there is somehting going on
cuttingedge
Team Captain
Will not matter The league will not do anything to St Pauls that could interupt there finals ,they should lose the points but I doubt it, there is only 1 club that the league nails and have done 3 times this year .
Jonah Lomu
Debutant
Doesn't that rule only effect eligibility for finals?
- Thread starter
- #1,019
You can't complain that the league was picking on you for having 19 on the field, that was a blatant breach of the games rules. I can't comment on the JMac being deregistered as I don't know the full circumstances. But the league followed the rules and accordingly players can be reregistered upon a successful appeal with AFL Victoria so I don't think there is a big issue there.
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- Thread starter
- #1,020
Someone at work said there was an article in the Hun about him, players giving him a rap about being a top bloke or something like that....
I got no doubt that he would of performed some thuggish things in his time playing football, you can tell by the way he plays - I don't know his detailed history but I am sure he would of deserved every suspension he received.
superfreak
Premiership Player
Dont think there is anything in it cuttingedge.
I do find it strange that the same player has been released this week to play with st pauls even when both casey seniors and reserves are playing.
He has played two VFL seniors games this year (plus 12 ressies) and whilst their twos arent a great side surely he would get a game in either side...or has he given VFL footy the arse?
I do find it strange that the same player has been released this week to play with st pauls even when both casey seniors and reserves are playing.
He has played two VFL seniors games this year (plus 12 ressies) and whilst their twos arent a great side surely he would get a game in either side...or has he given VFL footy the arse?
cuttingedge
Team Captain
Mate, to be honest with you we copped what we deserved , tried to appeal lost and moved on, samre as McNamara but we won, with st Pauls
he played footy in this comp whilst having played more than 10 vfl games ruling him ineligible, which in most cases means points lost, the feedback I get is the league picked it up this week after St Pauls and Casey were doing a shifty and picking him on a Saturday in the twos team sheet
then playing with Casey on Sundays, ring the league they will confirm it, to me thats cheating and should be punished.
cuttingedge
Team Captain
Check your reserves teamsheet for the last two weeks? Its all on the sfl website, pretty embarassing for st pauls who reagrd the admin as spot on , pretty big stuff up, what would have happened if he played finals and they found out then, might have been another way for the doggies to lose a granny
superfreak
Premiership Player
Sorry edge didn't realise that..i knew that he had played over 10 VFL games but didn't know that they were putting him on teamsheets in the ressies.
He played in the seniors against us after he had played 10 VFL games, booted three goals and arguably won them the game. But them losing points wouldnt really make any difference.
I put it down to someone making an honest mistake. But not sure why they would do that. If your play over 10 VFL games u are ineligible for SFL finals anyway so what did they have to gain out of it?? As i said i think they might have made an honest mistake.
He played in the seniors against us after he had played 10 VFL games, booted three goals and arguably won them the game. But them losing points wouldnt really make any difference.
I put it down to someone making an honest mistake. But not sure why they would do that. If your play over 10 VFL games u are ineligible for SFL finals anyway so what did they have to gain out of it?? As i said i think they might have made an honest mistake.
i think you may find a few of them were at vfl level. it will be interesting to see if rogerson wants to lead with the headbutt again in the first final? it is a funny sight when rogerson gets forced to put boot to ball has he had the same kicking coach as mackenzie someone should put a bell in the ball for these two
i doubt very much if rogerson would be worried about j mac from watching that game think j mac came off second best. i think he picked the wrong bloke on the field to intimerdate, and knowing a little bit about him from years ago he would be one of the best street fighters ive seen.
maybe u should bring it up with him spiro..
- Status