Should Chris Scott be sanctioned?

[ThatsjustDappa]

Chris Scott having another sook at the umps after the game today.

Haha big cox, just keep weeping in the coaches box

 

[Jimmy Yamazaki]

It wasn't the umps. It was the Matchday manager and Scott was seeking clarification because Swans went over the rotation limit.

 

[Holy Rioli]

It wasn't the umps. It was the Matchday manager and Scott was seeking clarification because Swans went over the rotation limit.

but they actually didn't - guy complains about rules not being followed (even when he's wrong) but he can't ******* follow them himself.

 

[Jimmy Yamazaki]

but they actually didn't - guy complains about rules not being followed (even when he's wrong) but he can't ******* follow them himself.

Swans got given an extra rotation because of concussion which was allowed, Scott was clarifying what it was for. It was said by the commentators as well.

 

[Holy Rioli]

Swans got given an extra rotation because of concussion which was allowed, Scott was clarifying what it was for. It was said by the commentators as well.

is it in the rules to approach an umpire during a quarter time break and have a go at them for what the coach perceived (and was incorrect about) a bad call?

 

[Jimmy Yamazaki]

is it in the rules to approach an umpire during a quarter time break and have a go at them for what the coach perceived (and was incorrect about) a bad call?

The one that BigCox88 and I are talking about happened after the game today, not last weeks one.

To answer your question I honestly don't know if it is or not.

 

[Tiger2709]

Keep saying a really good new Underbelly series should be based on the AFL and the dodgy stuff thats gone on through the decades.

It would be right up there for that style of tv drama. Sex, drugs, corruption, big money, violence, affairs, powerful people and a play ground for some massive egos.

So so funny!

Don't forget Gills Au Pair girls.

 

[Tiger2709]

And yet geelong plays home games against richmond at richmonds home ground in richmonds home city.

Maybe even Hocking realises what a s**t box KP is?

 

[Tiger2709]

It wasn't the umps. It was the Matchday manager and Scott was seeking clarification because Swans went over the rotation limit.

As Scott admitted they didnt go over, Scott f@cked up again, they had a concussion so nothing to see here.

 

[Max Caddy]

As Scott admitted they didnt go over, Scott f@cked up again, they had a concussion so nothing to see here.

Scott is well within his rights to ask about the extra rotation.

 

[PhatBoy]

Nothing will happen while the Geelong mafia is running city hall. Gil doesn’t give a fu** anymore, doubt he ever comes into the office and if he does he’s sauced and asleep under his desk by 11 am.

Hocking just drives a truck through the joint and no one bats an eyelid. Gives his old Geelong chums the green light to do whatever. As for the commissioners they are ******* useless

Yeah like hosting finals. We just have a free ride

 

[Tiger2709]

Scott is well within his rights to ask about the extra rotation.

Well not sure whether he is within his rights or not to be honest.

Could be considered an attempt to influence the umpires, although I understand he wasn't doing that.

 

[Sir_Loin]

Yeah like hosting finals. We just have a free ride

Yeah you’re not hosting finals. This isn’t amateur hour. Although with Hocking in at AFL house you’d be more likely.

 

[Max Caddy]

Well not sure whether he is within his rights or not to be honest.

Could be considered an attempt to influence the umpires, although I understand he wasn't doing that.

This was post game. What would he influence?

 

[PhatBoy]

Yeah you’re not hosting finals. This isn’t amateur hour. Although with Hocking in at AFL house you’d be more likely.

So every other official in the game, their sides get a free ride too. Because as everyone knows, if you’ve ever played for anyone, you automatically help those teams out in your later career

 

[Tiger2709]

This was post game. What would he influence?

Why bother asking about it at all, just send a letter to the AFL during the week?

 

[PhatBoy]

Why bother asking about it at all, just send a letter to the AFL during the week?

That’s like saying why question any decision during the game that’s already been made

 

[Tiger2709]

That’s like saying why question any decision during the game that’s already been made

No its not, he is a coach not a player, when do coaches go on the field and question the umpires decisions during a game, they wait and send a letter to the AFL, or have a coffee with Gill.

Scott is embarrassing with his constant complaining and not so subtle whinges on every football show he goes on

 

[Sir_Loin]

So every other official in the game, their sides get a free ride too. Because as everyone knows, if you’ve ever played for anyone, you automatically help those teams out in your later career

Now you’re getting the hang of it

 

[GeneticCat]

Hawks only get half as many home games as Geelong. And the AFL have spent years trying to make it 0.

I thought you wanted to be the “Tassie Hawks”.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[HairyO]

I thought you wanted to be the “Tassie Hawks”.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

We do. The AFL wants Hawthorn out of Tasmania because we are too successful at everything.

 

[GeneticCat]

We do. The AFL wants Hawthorn out of Tasmania because we are too successful at everything.

You do know the G isn’t in Tassie right? So many really successful people are homeless...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[PhatBoy]

No its not, he is a coach not a player, when do coaches go on the field and question the umpires decisions during a game, they wait and send a letter to the AFL, or have a coffee with Gill.

Scott is embarrassing with his constant complaining and not so subtle whinges on every football show he goes on

Is that what Hardwick did when he publicly questioned the umpires treatment of jack Riewoldt?

That was tough to find by the way. First search result for ‘Hardwick questions umpires.’

Was his press conference delivered via a letter to Gil?

Because I don’t think it was.

Or this year when he had a whinge about De Boer’s shut down of Dustin Martin?

Was the presser held at a cafe over a coffee with Gil? (Third search result, by the way)

Seems to me when someone from a club you dislike questions umpiring in a way you don’t like, you’re fine to call it out, but you’re pretty keen to ignore someone doing it on a public platform and making a stink.


Or hey, maybe we could bring up the time Hardwick was fined for.....

Abusing an umpire during a game.

Hardwick fined for abusing umpire

www.google.com.au

Now unless that third quarter confrontation was actually held during a meeting with Gil, it seems like you’ve kind of forgotten to use lube on your own argument.

F***ing self righteous Richmond fans

 

[Tiger2709]

Is that what Hardwick did when he publicly questioned the umpires treatment of jack Riewoldt?

That was tough to find by the way. First search result for ‘Hardwick questions umpires.’

Was his press conference delivered via a letter to Gil?

Because I don’t think it was.

Or this year when he had a whinge about De Boer’s shut down of Dustin Martin?

Was the presser held at a cafe over a coffee with Gil? (Third search result, by the way)

Seems to me when someone from a club you dislike questions umpiring in a way you don’t like, you’re fine to call it out, but you’re pretty keen to ignore someone doing it on a public platform and making a stink.


Or hey, maybe we could bring up the time Hardwick was fined for.....

Abusing an umpire during a game.

Hardwick fined for abusing umpire

www.google.com.au

Now unless that third quarter confrontation was actually held during a meeting with Gil, it seems like you’ve kind of forgotten to use lube on your own argument.

F***ing self righteous Richmond fans

So we agree that Scott should be fined and as it is a second offence he should be suspended from games.

Good work finding the precedent.

 

[PhatBoy]

So we agree that Scott should be fined and as it is a second offence he should be suspended from games.

Good work finding the precedent.

Translation:

‘I had completely forgotten about this incident as well as the public whinges my coach had and am trying as hard as I can to find a comeback but I can’t.’

I don’t think either coach should be fined if it’s an enquiry or a fairly level headed approach to an umpire, for what it’s worth. Hardwick would have been fine if he didn’t actually abuse one of them.