Should Judd get a week for his elbow to Leon Davis?

[DidakDelight]

Should Judd get a week for his elbow to Leon Davis?
If Cyril copped a week then Judd should surely cop 1 or 2.

Watch at the 10min 35sec mark of the last quarter.

Anyone got a youtube link?

 

[Dan26]

I didn't see the incident.

But yes, Chris Judd should get exactly one week.

 

[Adelaide Hawk]

Are you kidding? He can do whatever he likes, eye gouge, elbow, you name it, and all he gets is medal votes.

 

[topdon]

Didn't see the incident...

But yes ... he has got to go!

 

[Bennett.]

Yeah, but he SHOULD get votes for elbowing Davis.

 

[DidakDelight]

If anyone has any PC /Youtube skills go to the last quarter centre bounce at the 10-min 36second mark.

Clear elbow to the head off the ball.
They pushed and shoved for a good 2 minutes afterwards

Dirty act no doubt about it


(queue Carlton mod to accuse this of being a troll and delete thread..)

 

[The New Breid]

Haven't seen the replay. But live I thought it seemed as bad as Rioli's, was pretty cheap too. Doubt it will even be looked at though.

 

[SA HAWK]

No weeks just 3 brownlow votes.

 

[Mr.Kennedy]

Yeah, but he SHOULD get votes for elbowing Davis.

 

[maryjames]

When he smashed Pav last year he got 2 votes.. was well beaten that day with poor kicking that missed targets. So on that note 3 votes Judd and Davis reported for his head hitting Judds elbow..

 

[liam_13]

No weeks just 3 brownlow votes.

Ok, since you are clearly of the opinion the umpires are biased towards Judd, could you kindly prove yourself right and go through the games last year Judd didn't deserve votes, but got them.

Thanks.

And I didn't see the elbow, so wouldn't know.

 

[BlackHat]

Ok, since you are clearly of the opinion the umpires are biased towards Judd, could you kindly prove yourself right and go through the games last year Judd didn't deserve votes, but got them.

Pretty sure he got torn a new one by McFlea in the Freo game and still managed to collect at least 2 votes.

 

[slangman]

Ok, since you are clearly of the opinion the umpires are biased towards Judd, could you kindly prove yourself right and go through the games last year Judd didn't deserve votes, but got them.

Thanks.

And I didn't see the elbow, so wouldn't know.

When Collingwood smashed Carlton by 9 goals....Swan had over 30 possessions in a team that won by heaps.

You cannot be BOG if your team loses by 9 goals....maybe 1 vote for battling away but not 3 votes.

 

[Higs]

Pretty sure he got torn a new one by McFlea in the Freo game and still managed to collect at least 2 votes.

Correction, he got torn a new one by McPhee in 2x Freo games and collected 2 votes in one, 1 in the other. Both Freo wins too, fyi

 

[blues4flag]

When Collingwood smashed Carlton by 9 goals....Swan had over 30 possessions in a team that won by heaps.

You cannot be BOG if your team loses by 9 goals....maybe 1 vote for battling away but not 3 votes.

The coaches obviously disagreed as they voted him equal BOG alongside Ball with 8 votes.

 

[Rustin Cohle]

Back to the actual point of the thread, I just watched the incident having missed it in the coverage last night and he should at the very least have a case to answer.

I highly doubt any media outlet will point the incident out, though.

 

[Poseidon]

provide footage of the incident or STFU, I don't recall seeing any incident.

 

[slangman]

Equal BOG with Luke Ball?

Ball's team WON by 9 goals. in a 50/50 they give it to a bloke who's team lost by a big margin.

BTW how many times did Swan get BOG from the coaches but failed to recieve many/any Brownlow votes?

 

[Rustin Cohle]

[youtube]FDWmexaGt7o[/youtube]

 

[stacy25]

He will never get suspended for anything again. EVER.

 

[Sam The Doc]

Suspended for that?????haha how soft do you people want this game to get?

 

[mediumsizered]

The sooky sooky la las are at it again. Some football supporters talk about the AFL making the game soft. The reality is some supporters of the game are the ones trying to make the game soft. It was a damn shepherd, for goodness sake. Cry me a river.

 

[TerryWallet]

Cmon Pies, can't Swanny win a Brownlow without you trying to get The Great Man Judd rubbed out?

 

[Rustin Cohle]

The sooky sooky la las are at it again. Some football supporters talk about the AFL making the game soft. The reality is some supporters of the game are the ones trying to make the game soft. It was a damn shepherd, for goodness sake. Cry me a river.

BS that was a shepherd. Luke Ball was in possession of the ball ten metres away. You don't shepherd with your elbow/forarm either. If it was Campbell Brown in that position you would be saying he tried to go for a cheap shot because Davis bumped him ten seconds earlier.

 

[DidakDelight]

high impact, off the ball - should definitely be looked at