Should there be a VAR type review in the lead up to a goal?

[longsuffreosupp]

Just seeing the supposed siren before mark in the GWS/GC game.

In the A-league there is a review in the lead up play to a goal. If someone in the continuous play is offside, or there's a foul (and maybe other things), then the goal can be cancelled.

From my own team this year I can remember a ball that clearly went out (but wasn't called) against GWS that turned into a mark and goal. Also an important goal that North Melbourne kicked though Joel Hamling was illegally held from being able to tackle the eventual goal kicker.

Is this a next stage of the review system and would you be supportive of it, if it shows conclusively that the goal shouldn't have happened because something happened in the lead up?

 

[falcons2]

No. Get rid of it.
At what point does the lead up to a goal start?

 

[benneth]

There'd be that many goals recalled if they were being fair dinkum in the reviews.

Umpiring has a lot more room for improvement before something like this needs to be brought in.

 

[longsuffreosupp]

No. Get rid of it.
At what point does the lead up to a goal start?

The lead up resets once the ball crosses half way or there's a ball up/throw in.

 

[Wallaby]

God, no. VAR, DRS, etc only work if there is an actual line. Trying to adjudicate on every single action during a lead-up (while watching in slow motion) is a recipe for disaster. Refer the NRL Bunker for dozens of examples.

Use reviews purely for unarguable decisions - ie, lines.

 

[D-N-R]

The lead up resets once the ball crosses half way or there's a ball up/throw in.

They might be reviewing a couple of minutes of footage in that case. The current system they have is enough although flawed through lack of decent cameras etc.

 

[Sterge]

Game would be super fun if we had to sit for 5 minutes after every goal waiting to be given the all clear. They can barely get it correct now and they only review the actual goal.

Channel 7 might love it though since they could cram tons of extra ads in

 

[kickazz]

Nah.

And get rid of goal review for touched off the boot as the footage is always s**t.