Should we trade McCartin?

[VDS66]

Has 2 metre Peter done enough to have people so keen to have him ? Yes he's tall but he still gets beaten by players a lot smaller . I wouldn't be trading a player or a pick for him until he shows he is going to play more than just cameo roles every now and again .


Sent via Imagination, HAL traded.

I prefer 200cm Peter.

 

[dewah07]

Would be trout and Bains admit they stuffed up and lose their jobs.

Would be the all time dumbest thing ever for their career thus never happening.

End of

 

[Moral Decay]

Has 2 metre Peter done enough to have people so keen to have him ? Yes he's tall but he still gets beaten by players a lot smaller . I wouldn't be trading a player or a pick for him until he shows he is going to play more than just cameo roles every now and again .


Sent via Imagination, HAL traded.

At this point I couldn't make a functional comparison between the two, all I can say Paddy looks better when he is going but Peter is getting on the park and getting games in, too early to say any more.

 

[plugger66]

Good positive thread.

 

[soups1982]

agreed - lets shut this smoldering heap of s**t thread down..

 

[JG22]

Yes and then trade Billings aswell

 

[boydie]

People seem to forget we have a 34 bloke (a club legend) running around taking Paddy spot at present.
Just chilax, Paddy will slot into the forward line nicely post Rooey, just need to watch the eagles game from earlier in the year to see that a Paddy, Baroose, members fwd line can and will work!

 

[Impatient Saint]

I would like us to recruit another key forward (just in case) Paddy doesnt work out. James Stewart now at Essendon would have been perfect last year.

 

[DarkSaint]

Needs to be persisted with and given game time. We need to find a way to give him games because he is isn't playing any worse and dare i say it actually better than all of Moore,Boyd,Wright,Curnow,Schache, Weideman etc

 

[JG22]

I would like us to recruit another key forward (just in case) Paddy doesnt work out. James Stewart now at Essendon would have been perfect last year.

We just recruited Josh Battle and Rowan Marshall, perfect bargain back up.

We will be fine

 

[VDS66]

If anyone needs proof how important a good midfield is to kpf, have a look at the Hawks without Lewis and Mitchell.
We are lacking those types. Once we gave them, Paddy will look like Rolls Royce.

 

[STK2020]

Why just why ?
Even if we did trade him , it wouldnt be for pick 1 so we are going backwards .
The Club , our development staff owes it to Paddy to bring out his best . He turned up to us loaded with potential, with a great attitude from him , support from us we need to bring it out .

 

[bisazc887]

Paddy, Bruce, members, Marshall and battle not to mention a couple of others think our forward line is fine. If Goddard comes up can even push Carlisle up occasionally. Just need Kelly or dusty, Rockliff and a bit more pace