-
LIVE: Richmond v Melbourne - 7:25PM Wed
Squiggle tips Demons at 77% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
MRP / Trib. Shuey offered 1 match
- Thread starter Evelyn208
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Carbine Chaos
The Gaff-er
- Apr 1, 2009
- 63,931
- 94,228
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Perth FC, Everton, Delhi
Was it really enough to warrant being adjudged medium contact?
So it must have just been a typo.
EDIT: Medium impact my arse. For one I don't reckon the replay is clear enough, it sorta pans in half way through.
The real point here is that the MRP is a shambles in every way possible.
EDIT: Medium impact my arse. For one I don't reckon the replay is clear enough, it sorta pans in half way through.
The real point here is that the MRP is a shambles in every way possible.
The Falcon Strike
Hall of Famer
Must have got Duffield right on the point of his vagina unfortunately.
It's the only way the weak pr1ck could have needed 2 trainers to carry him off after a little love tap.
It was stupid and unnecessary, but a reprimand of 93.75 points is sufficient. No way this is as bad as Schofield's or Ballantyne's who got the same assessment
It's the only way the weak pr1ck could have needed 2 trainers to carry him off after a little love tap.
It was stupid and unnecessary, but a reprimand of 93.75 points is sufficient. No way this is as bad as Schofield's or Ballantyne's who got the same assessment
Take the 1 week and run, I was scared he would get 2 weeks similar to Schofield but thankfully he has a good record, was a stupid thing to do off the ball and it was in the last quarter so the game was over and there was no need to do it, he will benefit for the extra week off so he can reload against Carlton after the Bye
Karnezis_13
Norm Smith Medallist
Yea, shocking mistake, one way or another. 
The Falcon Strike
Hall of Famer
He got the exact same assessment as Schofield. Schoey only got two weeks due to carryover points from tripping Marc Murphy last year
Public Enemy No1
Premiership Player
- Banned
- #36
Medium impact 
Should of pinned Duffields arms then rammed his head in the turf instead of giving him a 'luv tap'
Should of pinned Duffields arms then rammed his head in the turf instead of giving him a 'luv tap'
Ochre
Stop the Steal!
bugger, at least this clears the way for Swifty
Smeg Head
Just take a bite
Typical that we get bent over by the joke of a MRP. Medical report getting it classified as medium is code that the Freo player/doctor had a sook and a squeal about it. Especially when that ******** B Harvey only got one week for a punch to the face.
What will happen though is that we will accept it and move on no matter i bet. Don't think we've had the balls to challenge anything that's come up at the tribunal for a good 5 years say.
What will happen though is that we will accept it and move on no matter i bet. Don't think we've had the balls to challenge anything that's come up at the tribunal for a good 5 years say.
The Falcon Strike
Hall of Famer
We challenged Lynch last year and had a small victory.
Though listening to Woosha talk about Water's reprimand earlier in the year, he made it clear it was the club's view that there was no high contact but the risk wasn't worth it.
Similarly, given Brisbane is our next game and Carlton thereafter, I doubt we'd risk him for the Carlton game - just to have him in for Brisbane.
Had it been the other way around, i daresay we'd take it to the tribunal
Smeg Head
Just take a bite
What did Lynch get booked for?
But yeah that whole risk part of it seems to put us off big time, even when the gradings seems fundamentally over the top.
But yeah that whole risk part of it seems to put us off big time, even when the gradings seems fundamentally over the top.
You can sling off at the MRP if it makes you feel better, but since I proclaimed "Schofield was ripped off," I've been keeping an eye on it and they've actually been very consistent with the off-the-ball punches to the guts.
I said to my mate as soon as it happened that Shuey would get 2 down to 1 and so he has. Whether you feel that's a tough penalty for a fairly soft incident is debatable, but at least it's consistent, which is a bloody good start.
Have an enjoyable fortnight Shuey and pull your head in after the break, particularly coming into finals.
I said to my mate as soon as it happened that Shuey would get 2 down to 1 and so he has. Whether you feel that's a tough penalty for a fairly soft incident is debatable, but at least it's consistent, which is a bloody good start.
Have an enjoyable fortnight Shuey and pull your head in after the break, particularly coming into finals.
- Aug 22, 2009
- 24,445
- 28,080
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Oh yeah you're right.
Rats.
Shuey BOG v Carlton.
Send him to Bluff Knoll for altitude training.
swannies
Brownlow Medallist
10k Posts
Armchair Endzone Minor Comp Winner
Armchair Endzone Participant
Don't think it's anything to do with having the balls. I think the attitude may be you've done the crime, we'll make do without you. Gives someone else, a la Stevens, Swift, Hams a chance to shine for the week.
Offered 1 match? Hmm...
...does it have to be one of ours? We can send him to bed before the Friday night game on the bye week!
...does it have to be one of ours? We can send him to bed before the Friday night game on the bye week!
Medium impact
Should of pinned Duffields arms then rammed his head in the turf instead of giving him a 'luv tap'
That's right. Thus forcing him from the ground and making him miss the following week with a concussion. And no penalty to be served.
Have to agree. Intentional hits like that... too bad mate, you sit out and someone else has a chance to take your spot. Hams didn't play this week after missing two matches with suspension.
Shupe
Brownlow Medallist
- Jun 21, 2011
- 13,335
- 10,396
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Indianapolis Colts
Bit surprised some on here are calling the MRP a joke. Seems fair to me. Pretty stupid thing to do when we were so far in front. Should have just been concentrating on running the match out. Learn form it, don't do it again.
