Shuey V Heppell

[The Bomb]

Heppell 2 years younger and has already been AA and top 4 in MVP.

 

[Vindicater]

Both are guns but completely different players.

Any team would love to have either and would make that choice based on what they allready have in their midfield.

 

[Happy Mastenator]

Shuey retiring.

Think non-bombers fans would pick Shuey over Heppell every day of the week, and twice on gameday.

 

[eth-dog]

Shuey retiring.

Think non-bombers fans would pick Shuey over Heppell every day of the week, and twice on gameday.

Think most would say both were very good players who didn't reach the peaks we all expected of them in 2011 (Heppell likely to retire as well)

 

[YeoGabbaGabba]

Think most would say both were very good players who didn't reach the peaks we all expected of them in 2011 (Heppell likely to retire as well)

I have the upmost respect for Heppell as a person. Was a good player at his peak too but not close to shuey. Shuey clearly BOG and got his team over the line in a Grand Final decided by less than a kick

 

[Ambrosia]

I had Yeo and Shuey as performing like top 10-20 players in the eagles premiership year.

I wouldn’t say Heppell has ever reached that level of impact