Simmonds OR Ottens

[Total Power]

Who is better?

 

[Bentleigh]

2 very good footballers.

Ottens would be ahead.

 

[Sealen]

I think Ottens is.

If Simmonds can put in more performances like he did on the weekend, it most likely would sway my opinion

 

[OneEyedHawk]

2 very good footballers.

Ottens would be ahead.

So Simmonds is a very good footballer, Tuck is an A grade player, Deledio=Judd and Tambling=the greatest aboriginal to ever play the game?

Ottens is a very good player, capable of being a superstar player. Simmonds is a very ordinary player.

 

[cs61]

Ottens is a very good player. Simmonds is a very average player

 

[tigerT]

ottens is the better footballer, but simmo is coming along very nicely and will continue to improve under wallace. Any tiger fan would be happy with simmo this season.

to the hawks supporters, u sit and follow bents around in every thread, just get over it, ur starting to sound like broken records

 

[jackson_rules]

Ottens is a very good player. Simmonds is a very average player

actually mate simmo is a very good footballer but then again you probably think hodge is better then judd

 

[Swifty_446]

actually mate simmo is a very good footballer but then again you probably think hodge is better then judd

Ha ha, Simmonds a VERY good player? In that case Peter Street is a very very very good player, as is Daniel Bandy.

Hasn't the Richmond line in 2005 been "Deledio = Judd"?

 

[Radz]

Both as they are both great players.

 

[celtic_pride]

Ottens easily

 

[Punt_Road_Roar]

Who Cares !!!!!!!!!


Go the Tiges !!!

 

[cs61]

He isn't a very good footballer. He's tall. Can kinda kick and can kinda mark. He isn't very good at anything. He plays as a third tall, at his height getting the third defender, should be killing them at his height if he was a very good player.

 

[mcphee_is_a_gun]

Ottens easily...

 

[Nightwolf]

Simmonds is a hack

 

[Bentleigh]

Simmonds is a hack

How did he go last week?

 

[F/D]

Ottens please.

 

[BalmyArmy]

Simmonds is worth much more to Richmond, purely because he wants to play for the club. Unlike Ottens. By the way, Ottens isn't really setting the world on fire down at Sheel Stadium is he? We did brilliantly getting two first round picks for him.

 

[cs61]

Ottens is in a different class to Simmonds. why are we comparing them.

Ottens is a very good player
Simmonds is very average

 

[JUBJUB]

Simmonds is worth much more to Richmond, purely because he wants to play for the club. Unlike Ottens.

So he's been at Richmond for his entire career has he ?

By the way, Ottens isn't really setting the world on fire down at Sheel Stadium is he?

He's doing very,very,very nicely thank you.

 

[SouthSwans]

i'm quite confused. what happened to all the brad bashing? ottens is a piece of absolute shyte. simmo by a country mile

 

[LongBomb]

Ottens easily.

Simmonds is a hack. Richmond will regret his 5 year, 500k per season deal.

 

[Bentleigh]

Ottens easily.

Simmonds is a hack. Richmond will regret his 5 year, 500k per season deal.

500k?

700k per season + bonus' Troy is on.

 

[superstar]

Ottens is a good honest player. Nothing more, nothing less.

Simmonds is ordinary.

 

[Tigerbob]

Ottens is a good honest player. Nothing more, nothing less.

Simmonds is ordinary.

All these Hawk supporters saying Simmonds is average..... typical.....idiots, you guys should know what ordinary is!!

Ottens has had more potential than Simmonds but has and never will realise it, mainly because he is heartless and wont ever be physically dominant.....

Im not gonna rate this tread but keep going with the good work Simmo, your doing mighty fine by me and your physical application to the games so far is something we never had with Donut!!!

 

[tigerT]

Ottens easily.

Simmonds is a hack. Richmond will regret his 5 year, 500k per season deal.

muppet..