Smith In Stevens Out?

[tinman]

Originally posted by crows98
just a quick reaction to a bad post thats all.......but it isnt very fair to say someone on any AFL LIST is crap. l have no football skills and would love to have the talent that some of these guys do. So dont bag them because you think they are crap , because they arnt crap they are not up to the other players standard thats all


football would be great if everyone was a Mark Ricciuto or Andrew Mcleod player

Yes, my apologies. My comment wasn't intended to malign him as a person and I'm sure he is a lovely bloke and he tries very hard. What I should have said was that his skills are appalling and he is nowhere near up to AFL standard. Is that OK?

His performance on Saturday was embarrasing. It is not his fault he isn't up to standard so I shouldn't have been personal. The real fault lies with the people who recruited and selected him. Am I allowed to say they are cr@p????

Anyone who wants to back him for the Brownlow can get on here.

 

[Alex99]

Originally posted by tinman
Yes, my apologies. My comment wasn't intended to malign him as a person and I'm sure he is a lovely bloke and he tries very hard. What I should have said was that his skills are appalling and he is nowhere near up to AFL standard. Is that OK?

His performance on Saturday was embarrasing. It is not his fault he isn't up to standard so I shouldn't have been personal. The real fault lies with the people who recruited and selected him. Am I allowed to say they are cr@p????

Anyone who wants to back him for the Brownlow can get on here.

tinman, you can say anything you want about the selectors...some of their selections have been cRAp.

but l give my appologies as well........it is your option and you are intited to it......he is a lot better player in defence but as a forward he looks as lost as l would

keep him at CBH or full back and he might be a good honest player

 

[Alex99]

Originally posted by tinman
Yes, my apologies. My comment wasn't intended to malign him as a person and I'm sure he is a lovely bloke and he tries very hard. What I should have said was that his skills are appalling and he is nowhere near up to AFL standard. Is that OK?

His performance on Saturday was embarrasing. It is not his fault he isn't up to standard so I shouldn't have been personal. The real fault lies with the people who recruited and selected him. Am I allowed to say they are cr@p????

Anyone who wants to back him for the Brownlow can get on here.

tinman, you can say anything you want about the selectors...some of their selections have been cRAp.

but l give my appologies as well........it is your option and you are intited to it......he is a lot better player in defence but as a forward he looks as lost as l would

keep him at CBH or full back and he might be a good honest player

 

[Stiffy_18]

I have seen him play on a number of occasions and he is crap. Now I am not footballer nor have I won a brownlow but that doesn't make me incapable of judging football talent.

Simply, Smith is not up to AFL standard. Hell he is struggling at SANFL level.

 

[napsyd]

It appears that the Tiser is trying to educate us as well as entertain us. Did you know that inspired and curious mean the same thing?

"The inclusion of Matthew Smith, cut then re-claimed by Adelaide in the rookie draft, in the Subiaco travelling party was curious.
Could the Crows be contemplating Smith's elevation from the rookie list should Mark Stevens' chronic knee condition force the key forward into retirement?"

 

[Stiffy_18]

Matthew Smith is dropped

It didn't take him long did it??????