Draft Watcher SMYTHE - 2022 DRAFT THREAD

[Smythe]

Cleaver?

He is in a bunch that I just couldn’t find a home for, there were about 20 that could have pushed in and may, but for me almost none of them are worth a national draft pick and a 2 yr contract, but some of them will get picked I’m sure. For me, Cleaver is a rookie pick, along with guys like Williams, Dewar, Draper, Adams etc from WA.
Gilbey WA and Teal VIC (due to bad luck) those two may even miss rookie picks and be train on players. I could name many more but for me, to answer the question, Cleaver is a rookie pick IMO and maybe IMO only but on this page that’s all that matters. Of course for him, I hope I’m wrong, regardless, I think he is on a list next year.

 

[Mofra]

He is in a bunch that I just couldn’t find a home for, there were about 20 that could have pushed in and may, but for me almost none of them are worth a national draft pick and a 2 yr contract, but some of them will get picked I’m sure. For me, Cleaver is a rookie pick, along with guys like Williams, Dewar, Draper, Adams etc from WA.
Gilbey WA and Teal VIC (due to bad luck) those two may even miss rookie picks and be train on players. I could name many more but for me, to answer the question, Cleaver is a rookie pick IMO and maybe IMO only but on this page that’s all that matters. Of course for him, I hope I’m wrong, regardless, I think he is on a list next year.

Fair enough. A couple of WA based draft watchers think he's severely underrated.
IIRC Port like Teal, and he's a sneaky chance at the Bulldogs 3rd pick

 

[Smythe]

Fair enough. A couple of WA based draft watchers think he's severely underrated.
IIRC Port like Teal, and he's a sneaky chance at the Bulldogs 3rd pick

Yeah he is, don’t get me wrong I like him, just positionally in terms of picking for needs late in the draft I couldn’t get him a home.
Teal could go anywhere from round 3 onwards, first I had him to wb funny enough, then to Freo, then rich, then Adel, but in the end I left him to a rookie spot.

 

[Apex36]

UPDATED
I think the positions are in order, so here is my final mock after fixing my North Melbourne pick mistakes(I had too many), and going back to my original swap of Ess and Stk picks.
It did change the outcome a fair bit as it went on.

ROUND ONE
1 - GWS - Aaron Cadman
2 - NTH - George Wardlaw
3 - NTH - Harry Sheezel
4 - BRIS - Will Ashcroft- Bid matched
Ess bid then trade 4, 22 & F3 to Stk for 10, 33, 44, 70 and F1
5 - STK - Elijah Tsatas
6 - GC - Bailey Humphrey
7 - HAW - Mattaes Phillipou
8 - GEE - Jhye Clark
9 - WCE - Ed Allan
10 - ESS - Cam McKenzie
11 - CAR - Jedd Busslinger
12 - WB - Rueben Ginbey
13 - BRIS - Jaspa Fletcher - Bid matched
14 - WCE - Oliver Hollands
15 - GWS - Jacob Konstanty
Melb trade 15 & F2 to GWS for 20 & 21
16 - SYD - Matthew Jefferson
17 - GWS - Brayden George
18 - COLL - Jake Ryan
19 - SYD - Lachlan Cowan
20 - MELB - Oli Hotton

ROUND TWO
21 - MELB - Harry Barnett
22 - WCE - Elijah Hewett
23 - ADEL - Max Michalanney - Bid matched
24 - WB - Josh Weddle
25 - STK - Charlie Clarke
26 - NTH - Lewis Hayes
27 - HAW - Mitch Szybkowski
28 - COLL - Henry Hustwaite
29 - ESS - Alwyn..Davey..Jnr - Bid matched
30 - WCE - Darcy Jones
31 - COLL - Joe Richards
32 - STK - Ethan Phillips
33 - CARL - Coby Burgiel
34 - FREO - Kaleb Smith
35 - CARL - Max Gruzewski
Carl trade F2 to Gws
36 - PORT- Jaiden Magor
37 - WCE - Isaac Keeler
Wce trade F3 to Melb

ROUND THREE
38 - WB - James Van Es
39 - HAW - Noah Long
40 - GWS - Harry Rowston - Bid matched
41 - SYD - Adam D’Aloia
42 - ESS - Anthony Munkara - Bid matched
43 - FREO - Harry Cole
44 - FREO - Jaxon Binns
45 - GC - Hugh Davies
46 - HAW- Tom..Scully
47 - RICH - Harry Lemmey
48 - GEE - Jed Hagan

ROUND FOUR
49 - ESS - Tom McCallum
50 - PORT - Billy Dowling
51 - NTH - Cooper Harvey - Bid matched
52 - FREO - Jasper Scaife - Bid matched
53 - RICH - Jake Walker
54 - ADEL - Will Verrell

Now we can all look forward to draft night
(so we can laugh at this attempt )

Tbh I’ll be ropeable if Collingwood’s draft turns out this way. Ryan is not worth a first round selection, especially with the likes of Hewitt, Hayes and Weddle on the board still. Richards too. He’s someone we should be looking at with our 4th pick, not a top 30 selection.

 

[Smythe]

Tbh I’ll be ropeable if Collingwood’s draft turns out this way. Ryan is not worth a first round selection, especially with the likes of Hewitt, Hayes and Weddle on the board still. Richards too. He’s someone we should be looking at with our 4th pick, not a top 30 selection.

Weddle was one that I racked my brain over with collingwoods first pick, along with possibly bidding for Michalanney, then going Weddle. With Richards I have heard a fair bit about two or three teams rating him well above other small fwds in this draft therefore he will go in that second round I have no doubt and with Collingwood liking Charlie Clarke but here in my mock they miss out on him so I had them grabbing Joe.
Not sure Collingwood need the likes of Hayes more than they need a bloke like Weddle and/or Jake Ryan. I think Jake plays the Pies game plan perfectly, so I had him fit in there.

 

[Rusty Beam]

Weddle was one that I racked my brain over with collingwoods first pick, along with possibly bidding for Michalanney, then going Weddle. With Richards I have heard a fair bit about two or three teams rating him well above other small fwds in this draft therefore he will go in that second round I have no doubt and with Collingwood liking Charlie Clarke but here in my mock they miss out on him so I had them grabbing Joe.
Not sure Collingwood need the likes of Hayes more than they need a bloke like Weddle and/or Jake Ryan. I think Jake plays the Pies game plan perfectly, so I had him fit in there.

Yeah, I’m with Apex.

Collingwood desperately need to develop some quality talls at both ends eventually. Maybe the need isn’t immediate, but it’s getting closer.

Personally based on your phantom and potential availability Hewett, Keeler would be the perfect to address our needs. Ideally another tall in Hayes, Weddle or Barnett would also be available.

 

[Smythe]

Yeah, I’m with Apex.

Collingwood desperately need to develop some quality talls at both ends eventually. Maybe the need isn’t immediate, but it’s getting closer. It would also be nice to upgrade them in the process.

Personally based on your phantom and potential availability Hewett, Keeler would be the perfect draft to address our needs. Ideally Hayes, Weddle or Barnett would also be available.

If Richards isn’t there at a potential 4th pick so be it.

Earlier in the year I had Hayes to you then Keeler, later in the year it was Weddle. now none of them. Getting Hayes may help get a trade done for his brother next year for cheap enough covering two developing needs.
With Weddle and Ryan, Weddle is 2cm taller but Ryan takes more marks, gets more intercepts, rebounds and runs more, uses the ball better and tackles more, hence, I chose him over Weddle.
Both may grow some more who knows.

 

[Apex36]

Weddle was one that I racked my brain over with collingwoods first pick, along with possibly bidding for Michalanney, then going Weddle. With Richards I have heard a fair bit about two or three teams rating him well above other small fwds in this draft therefore he will go in that second round I have no doubt and with Collingwood liking Charlie Clarke but here in my mock they miss out on him so I had them grabbing Joe.
Not sure Collingwood need the likes of Hayes more than they need a bloke like Weddle and/or Jake Ryan. I think Jake plays the Pies game plan perfectly, so I had him fit in there.

You’re not sure we need a quality KPD to develop? Outside of Moore we have a bloke at his 3rd club in Frampton who’s speculative, Kelly, who’s undersized and likely going to be delisted at the end of 2023, Dean, who’s a rookie, and Murphy, who does an excellent job, but once again is very undersized. Hayes would be ideal at our first pick, we get plenty of run and rebound from Quaynor, Maynard and Noble, as well as Daicos while he remains in defence. Overlooking a player who fills a dire need for a lesser player because he supposedly plays our game plan well is utterly bizarre.

 

[Smythe]

You’re not sure we need a quality KPD to develop? Outside of Moore we have a bloke at his 3rd club in Frampton who’s speculative, Kelly, who’s undersized and likely going to be delisted at the end of 2023, Dean, who’s a rookie, and Murphy, who does an excellent job, but once again is very undersized. Hayes would be ideal at our first pick, we get plenty of run and rebound from Quaynor, Maynard and Noble, as well as Daicos while he remains in defence. Overlooking a player who fills a dire need for a lesser player because he supposedly plays our game plan well is utterly bizarre.

I never said that.
I said Im not sure you need the like of Hayes more than a Weddle or Ryan. There are other kpd’s to get to develop or trade for one next year, but I also said if you read the other post I did have Hayes to you guys, then changed it to Keeler then Weddle but went for best available for your first pick. Either of the three would suit Collingwood as players you could develop but i believe Ryan is the best available of those. Therefore, chose him.
Positionally, if the pies want a KPD to develop with their first pick then best available for that position would be Hayes.

 

[Apex36]

I never said that.
I said Im not sure you need the like of Hayes more than a Weddle or Ryan. There are other kpd’s to get to develop or trade for one next year, but I also said if you read the other post I did have Hayes to you guys, then changed it to Keeler then Weddle but went for best available for your first pick. Either of the three would suit Collingwood as players you could develop but i believe Ryan is the best available of those. Therefore, chose him.
Positionally, if the pies want a KPD to develop with their first pick then best available for that position would be Hayes.

Ways to trigger a Collingwood supporter:

Tell them there’s always next year to get a decent KPP. We’ve been hearing that for nearly a ******* decade.

 

[Smythe]

NOVEMBER MID RANKINGS

1 Will Ashcroft - 180cm
2 George Wardlaw - 182cm
3 Elijah Tsatas - 186cm
4 Jhye Clark - 181cm
5 Mattaes Phillipou - 191cm Mid/Fwd
6 Harry Sheezel - 184cm Mid/Fwd
7 Bailey Humphrey - 185cm Fwd/Mid
8 Cam MacKenzie - 187cm
9 Rueben Ginbey - 189cm Def/Mid
10 Oliver Hollands - 184cm
11 Elijah Hewett - 186cm Mid/Fwd
12 Oli Hotton - 181cm Mid/Fwd
13 Ed Allan - 195cm
14 Henry Hustwaite - 194cm Def/Mid
15 Mitch Szybkowski - 186cm
16 Jaiden Magor - 185cm Mid/Fwd
17 Darcy Jones - 175cm Mid/Fwd/Def
18 Jaspa Fletcher - 184cm
19 Alwyn.Davey. JNR - 181cm Mid/Fwd
20 Coby Burgiel - 183cm Mid/Fwd
21 Jaxon Binns - 182cm
22 Adam D'Aloia - 186cm
23 Harry Rowston - 180cm
24 Billy Dowling - 187cm
25 Noah Long - 178cm Mid/Fwd
26 Jed Hagan - 175cm
27 Blake Drury - 177cm
28 Jake Walker - 185cm
29 Caleb Mitchell - 187cm
30 Jack Cleaver - 188cm Mid/Def
31 Ted Clohesy - 183cm
32 Lachlan Sullivan 181cm
33 Kobe Ryan - 183cm
34 Hugh Bond - 184cm
35 Taj Campbell-Farrell - 185cm
36 Connor McDonald - 185cm
37 Charlie Barnett - 188cm


NOVEMBER FWD RANKINGS

1 Aaron Cadman - 194cm
2 Matthew Jefferson - 195cm
3 Brayden George - 186cm
4 Jacob Konstanty - 176cm
5 Charlie Clarke - 182cm
6 Anthony Munkara -187cm
7 Joe Richards - 175cm
8 Isaac Keeler - 198cm
9 Harry Lemmey - 199cm
10 Tom.Scully - 201cm
11 Cooper Harvey - 180cm
12 Harry Cole - 185cm
13 Jack O'Sullivan - 177cm
14 Jasper Scaife - 198cm
15 Seth Campbell - 180cm
16 Brandon Leary - 177cm
17 Archie Lovelock - 178cm
18 Nick Sadler - 179cm
19 Shadeau Brain - 185cm
20 Jerome Lawrence - 196cm
21 Jovan Petric - 196cm
22 Tyrell Dewar - 185cm

NOVEMBER DEF RANKINGS

1 Jedd Busslinger - 194cm
2 Lewis Hayes - 197cm
3 Lachlan Cowan - 188cm
4 Max Michalanney - 191cm
5 Jakob Ryan - 189cm
6 Josh Weddle - 191cm
7 Kaleb Smith - 182cm
8 Sam Gilbey - 188cm
9 Ethan Phillips - 196cm
10 Max Gruzewski - 193cm
11 James Van Es - 196cm
12 Tom Mccallum - 192cm
13 Luke Teal - 189cm
14 Harvey Gallagher - 179cm
15 Cooper Vickery - 180cm
16 Jason Gillbee - 190cm
17 Hugh Davies - 196cm
18 Casey Voss - 182cm
19 Conrad Williams - 185cm
20 Osca Murdoch - 191cm
21 Bailey MacDonald - 182cm
22 Steely Green - 179cm
23 Jed Adams - 194cm
24 Jonti Schuback - 183cm
25 Lloyd Johnston - 183cm
26 Callum Verrell - 188cm
27 Jacob Anderson - 190cm
28 Rye Penny 185cm

NOVEMBER RUCK RANKINGS

1 Harry Barnett - 202cm Ruck/Fwd/Def
2 Phoenix Foster - 198cm Ruck/Fwd
3 Will Verall - 200cm
4 Hudson O’Keefe - 201cm
5 Nick Madden - 204cm
6 Max Knobel - 204cm
7 Olivier Northam - 195cm Ruck/Fwd
8 Ryan Eyres 198cm Utility
9 Jackson Broadbent - 201cm
10 Cameron Owen - 203cm
11 Harvey Howe - 201cm
12 Will Elliot - 201cm
13 Clay Tucker - 204cm

NOVEMBER MIXED RANKINGS

1 Will Ashcroft
2 George Wardlaw
3 Aaron Cadman
4 Elijah Tsatas
5 Jhye Clark
6 Mattaes Phillipou
7 Harry Sheezel
8 Bailey Humphrey
9 Cam MacKenzie
10 Jedd Busslinger
11 Reuben Ginbey
12 Oliver Hollands
13 Elijah Hewett
14 Matthew Jefferson
15 Brayden George
16 Lewis Hayes
17 Oli Hotton
18 Jacob Konstanty
19 Ed Allan
20 Harry Barnett
21 Henry Hustwaite
22 Lachlan Cowan
23 Max Michalanney
24 Jakob Ryan
25 Josh Weddle
26 Charlie Clarke
27 Mitch Szybkowski
28 Jaiden Magor
29 Darcy Jones
30 Jaspa Fletcher
31 Alwyn..Davey. Jnr
32 Coby Burgiel
33 Kaleb Smith
34 Sam Gilbey
35 Anthony Munkara
36 Joe Richards
37 Jaxon Binns
38 Adam D'Aloia
39 Harry Rowston
40 Isaac Keeler
41 Ethan Phillips
42 Max Gruzewski
43 James Van Es
44 Tom McCallum
45 Luke Teal
46 Harry Lemmey
47 Billy Dowling
48 Noah Long
49 Jed Hagan
50 Blake Drury
51 Jake Walker
52 Caleb Mitchell
53 Jack Cleaver
54 Tom..Scully
55 Cooper Harvey
56 Harry Cole
57 Harvey Gallagher
58 Phoenix Foster
59 Will Verell
60 Cooper Vickery
61 Jack O’Sullivan
62 Jason Gillbee
63 Hugh Davies
64 Jasper Scaife
65 Casey Voss
66 Conrad Williams
67 Osca Murdoch
68 Bailey MacDonald
69 Steely Green
70 Jed Adams
71 Jonti Schuback
72 Ted Clohesy
73 Lachlan Sullivan
74 Kobe Ryan
75 Hugh Bond
76 Taj Campbell-Farrell
77 Connor McDonald
78 Seth Campbell
79 Brandon Leary
80 Archie Lovelock
81 Nick Sadler
82 Shadeau Brain
83 Jerome Lawrence
84 Hudson O’Keefe
85 Nick Madden
86 Max Knobel
87 Jovan Petric
88 Olivier Northam
89 Lloyd Johnston
90 Callum Verrell
91 Jacob Anderson
92 Tyrell Dewar
93 Rye Penny
94 Ryan Eyres
95 Jackson Broadbent
96 Cameron Owen
97 Harvey Howe
98 Will Elliot
99 Clay Tucker
100 Charlie Barnett

 

[Bletch]

NOVEMBER MID RANKINGS

1 Will Ashcroft - 180cm
2 George Wardlaw - 182cm
3 Elijah Tsatas - 186cm
4 Jhye Clark - 181cm
5 Mattaes Phillipou - 191cm Mid/Fwd
6 Harry Sheezel - 184cm Mid/Fwd
7 Bailey Humphrey - 185cm Fwd/Mid
8 Cam MacKenzie - 187cm
9 Rueben Ginbey - 189cm Def/Mid
10 Oliver Hollands - 184cm
11 Elijah Hewett - 186cm Mid/Fwd
12 Oli Hotton - 181cm Mid/Fwd
13 Ed Allan - 195cm
14 Henry Hustwaite - 194cm Def/Mid
15 Mitch Szybkowski - 186cm
16 Jaiden Magor - 185cm Mid/Fwd
17 Darcy Jones - 175cm Mid/Fwd/Def
18 Jaspa Fletcher - 184cm
19 Alwyn.Davey. JNR - 181cm Mid/Fwd
20 Coby Burgiel - 183cm Mid/Fwd
21 Jaxon Binns - 182cm
22 Adam D'Aloia - 186cm
23 Harry Rowston - 180cm
24 Billy Dowling - 187cm
25 Noah Long - 178cm Mid/Fwd
26 Jed Hagan - 175cm
27 Blake Drury - 177cm
28 Jake Walker - 185cm
29 Caleb Mitchell - 187cm
30 Jack Cleaver - 188cm Mid/Def
31 Ted Clohesy - 183cm
32 Lachlan Sullivan 181cm
33 Kobe Ryan - 183cm
34 Hugh Bond - 184cm
35 Taj Campbell-Farrell - 185cm
36 Connor McDonald - 185cm
37 Charlie Barnett - 188cm


NOVEMBER FWD RANKINGS

1 Aaron Cadman - 194cm
2 Matthew Jefferson - 195cm
3 Brayden George - 186cm
4 Jacob Konstanty - 176cm
5 Charlie Clarke - 182cm
6 Anthony Munkara -187cm
7 Joe Richards - 175cm
8 Isaac Keeler - 198cm
9 Harry Lemmey - 199cm
10 Tom.Scully - 201cm
11 Cooper Harvey - 180cm
12 Harry Cole - 185cm
13 Jack O'Sullivan - 177cm
14 Jasper Scaife - 198cm
15 Seth Campbell - 180cm
16 Brandon Leary - 177cm
17 Archie Lovelock - 178cm
18 Nick Sadler - 179cm
19 Shadeau Brain - 185cm
20 Jerome Lawrence - 196cm
21 Jovan Petric - 196cm
22 Tyrell Dewar - 185cm

NOVEMBER DEF RANKINGS

1 Jedd Busslinger - 194cm
2 Lewis Hayes - 197cm
3 Lachlan Cowan - 188cm
4 Max Michalanney - 191cm
5 Jakob Ryan - 189cm
6 Josh Weddle - 191cm
7 Kaleb Smith - 182cm
8 Sam Gilbey - 188cm
9 Ethan Phillips - 196cm
10 Max Gruzewski - 193cm
11 James Van Es - 196cm
12 Tom Mccallum - 192cm
13 Luke Teal - 189cm
14 Harvey Gallagher - 179cm
15 Cooper Vickery - 180cm
16 Jason Gillbee - 190cm
17 Hugh Davies - 196cm
18 Casey Voss - 182cm
19 Conrad Williams - 185cm
20 Osca Murdoch - 191cm
21 Bailey MacDonald - 182cm
22 Steely Green - 179cm
23 Jed Adams - 194cm
24 Jonti Schuback - 183cm
25 Lloyd Johnston - 183cm
26 Callum Verrell - 188cm
27 Jacob Anderson - 190cm
28 Rye Penny 185cm

NOVEMBER RUCK RANKINGS

1 Harry Barnett - 202cm Ruck/Fwd/Def
2 Phoenix Foster - 198cm Ruck/Fwd
3 Will Verall - 200cm
4 Hudson O’Keefe - 201cm
5 Nick Madden - 204cm
6 Max Knobel - 204cm
7 Olivier Northam - 195cm Ruck/Fwd
8 Ryan Eyres 198cm Utility
9 Jackson Broadbent - 201cm
10 Cameron Owen - 203cm
11 Harvey Howe - 201cm
12 Will Elliot - 201cm
13 Clay Tucker - 204cm

NOVEMBER MIXED RANKINGS

1 Will Ashcroft
2 George Wardlaw
3 Aaron Cadman
4 Elijah Tsatas
5 Jhye Clark
6 Mattaes Phillipou
7 Harry Sheezel
8 Bailey Humphrey
9 Cam MacKenzie
10 Jedd Busslinger
11 Reuben Ginbey
12 Oliver Hollands
13 Elijah Hewett
14 Matthew Jefferson
15 Brayden George
16 Lewis Hayes
17 Oli Hotton
18 Jacob Konstanty
19 Ed Allan
20 Harry Barnett
21 Henry Hustwaite
22 Lachlan Cowan
23 Max Michalanney
24 Jakob Ryan
25 Charlie Clarke
26 Mitch Szybkowski
27 Jaiden Magor
28 Darcy Jones
29 Jaspa Fletcher
30 Alwyn..Davey. Jnr
31 Coby Burgiel
32 Kaleb Smith
33 Sam Gilbey
34 Anthony Munkara
35 Joe Richards
36 Jaxon Binns
37 Adam D'Aloia
38 Harry Rowston
39 Isaac Keeler
40 Ethan Phillips
41 Max Gruzewski
42 James Van Es
43 Tom McCallum
44 Luke Teal
45 Adam D'Alioa
46 Harry Lemmey
47 Billy Dowling
48 Noah Long
49 Jed Hagan
50 Blake Drury
51 Jake Walker
52 Caleb Mitchell
53 Jack Cleaver
54 Tom..Scully
55 Cooper Harvey
56 Harry Cole
57 Harvey Gallagher
58 Phoenix Foster
59 Will Verell
60 Cooper Vickery
61 Jack O’Sullivan
62 Jason Gillbee
63 Hugh Davies
64 Jasper Scaife
65 Casey Voss
66 Conrad Williams
67 Osca Murdoch
68 Bailey MacDonald
69 Steely Green
70 Jed Adams
71 Jonti Schuback
72 Ted Clohesy
73 Lachlan Sullivan
74 Kobe Ryan
75 Hugh Bond
76 Taj Campbell-Farrell
77 Connor McDonald
78 Seth Campbell
79 Brandon Leary
80 Archie Lovelock
81 Nick Sadler
82 Shadeau Brain
83 Jerome Lawrence
84 Hudson O’Keefe
85 Nick Madden
86 Max Knobel
87 Jovan Petric
88 Olivier Northam
89 Lloyd Johnston
90 Callum Verrell
91 Jacob Anderson
92 Tyrell Dewar
93 Rye Penny
94 Ryan Eyres
95 Jackson Broadbent
96 Cameron Owen
97 Harvey Howe
98 Will Elliot
99 Clay Tucker
100 Charlie Barnett

Love your work Smythe - love how you're prepared to rank down to 100.

Just a couple of things:

• Josh Weddle missing from the mixed rankings. I assume just oversight.
• D'Aloia gets a run twice - 37 and 45.

 

[Smythe]

Love your work Smythe - love how you're prepared to rank down to 100.

Just a couple of things:

• Josh Weddle missing from the mixed rankings. I assume just oversight.
• D'Aloia gets a run twice - 37 and 45.

yes, will be fixed now, sometimes when i transfer (well almost every time) on to here from my folders i stuff up a few things.

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

Full Phantom Draft

1. Aaron Cadman - GWS
2. Will Ashcroft - BRIS - Bid Matched (nth give 40&43 get Bris 35, haw give 48,50,52 get Bris 36)
3. Harry Sheezel - NTH
4. George Wardlaw - NTH
5. Mattaes Phillipou - ESS
6. Bailey Humphrey - GC
7. Elijah Tsatas - HAW
8. Jhye Clark - GEEL
9. Reuben Ginbey - WCE
10. Cameron MacKenzie - STK
11. Jedd Busslinger - CARL
12. Lewis Hayes - WB
13. Elijah Hewett - WCE
14. Matthew Jefferson - MELB
15. Henry Hustwaite - SYD
16. Jaspa Fletcher - BRIS - Bid Matched
17. Jacon Konstanty - GWS
18. Ed Allan - COLL
19. Oli Hotton - SYD
20. Oliver Hollands - GWS
21. Mitch Szybkowski - GWS
22. Darcy Jones - WCE
23. Brayden George - WB
24. Josh Weddle - ESS
25. Isaac Keeler - NTH
26. Alwyn Davey Jnr - ESS - Bid Matched
27. Coby Burgiel - HAW
28. Harry Barnett - COLL
29. Jakob Ryan - WCE
30. Charlie Clarke - COLL
31. James Van Es - STK
32. Lachlan Cowan - CARL
33. Sam Gilbey - FREO
34. Max Michalanney - ADEL - Bid Matched
35. Max Gruzewski - GWS
36. Jaiden Magor - STK
37. Adam D’Aloia - PORT
38. Harvey Gallagher - NTH
39. Jaxon Binns - HAW
40. Noah Long - MELB
41. Ethan Phillips - Wb
42. Harry Cole - Freo
43. Hugh Davies - Gc
44. Anthony Munkara - ESS - Bid Matched
45. Jack O’Sullivan - Carl
46. Phoenix Foster - Rich
47. Cooper Harvey - Nth - Bid Matched
48. Blake Drury - Geel
49. Cooper Vickery - Haw
50. Harry Rowston - Gws - Bid Matched
51. Billy Dowling - Adel
52. Harry Lemmey - Port
53. Luke Teal - Rich
54. Jed Adams - Freo

And that’s it IMO, a lot that are stiff to miss out but there will be plenty of rookie spots.

I really like Hayes for the Dogs, but bit of a reach at that pick, and id say we would take Oliver Hollands if that's the way it went but I'm hoping we take George like you indicated.

 

[Smythe]

I really like Hayes for the Dogs, but bit of a reach at that pick, and id say we would take Oliver Hollands if that's the way it went but I'm hoping we take George like you indicated.

That was an old mock. George however, may make it that far

 

[Flags_In_The_Bag]

That was an old mock. George however, may make it that far

Ahh ok, if the dogs got George at their 2nd pick id be stoked.

 

[Ancient Tiger]

The biggest fall from grace ever - Harry Lemmey. WTF happened to him? From No.1 KPF to who knows what pick.

 

[Davo-27]

The biggest fall from grace ever - Harry Lemmey. WTF happened to him? From No.1 KPF to who knows what pick.

I'm pretty sure someone at RMC went big on Lemmey late last year and over rated him which created a follow on affect where others cautiously followed their example, but unfortunately he didn't come on as expected and people adjusted their ratings, it happens, ratings early are at times speculative.

 

[Smythe]

The

The biggest fall from grace ever - Harry Lemmey. WTF happened to him? From No.1 KPF to who knows what pick.

There were a lot of things off-field that hampered his year and some personal issues. His development didn’t come on like it could have. He has the skill, that’s for sure.

 

[Albertonarmy]

The

There were a lot of things off-field that hampered his year and some personal issues. His development didn’t come on like it could have. He has the skill, that’s for sure.

Think he found it hard at league level , West's don't have a lot of forward entry's and when they do they seem to look for Josh Gore and Jono Beach , probably got a lot of attention from the senior defenders due to the potential number 1 tag, did ok in round 2 though

 

[Lore]

Full Phantom Draft

1. Aaron Cadman - GWS
2. Will Ashcroft - BRIS - Bid Matched (nth give 40&43 get Bris 35, haw give 48,50,52 get Bris 36)
3. Harry Sheezel - NTH
4. George Wardlaw - NTH
5. Mattaes Phillipou - ESS
6. Bailey Humphrey - GC
7. Elijah Tsatas - HAW
8. Jhye Clark - GEEL
9. Reuben Ginbey - WCE
10. Cameron MacKenzie - STK
11. Jedd Busslinger - CARL
12. Lewis Hayes - WB
13. Elijah Hewett - WCE
14. Matthew Jefferson - MELB
15. Henry Hustwaite - SYD
16. Jaspa Fletcher - BRIS - Bid Matched
17. Jacon Konstanty - GWS
18. Ed Allan - COLL
19. Oli Hotton - SYD
20. Oliver Hollands - GWS
21. Mitch Szybkowski - GWS
22. Darcy Jones - WCE
23. Brayden George - WB
24. Josh Weddle - ESS
25. Isaac Keeler - NTH
26. Alwyn Davey Jnr - ESS - Bid Matched
27. Coby Burgiel - HAW
28. Harry Barnett - COLL
29. Jakob Ryan - WCE
30. Charlie Clarke - COLL
31. James Van Es - STK
32. Lachlan Cowan - CARL
33. Sam Gilbey - FREO
34. Max Michalanney - ADEL - Bid Matched
35. Max Gruzewski - GWS
36. Jaiden Magor - STK
37. Adam D’Aloia - PORT
38. Harvey Gallagher - NTH
39. Jaxon Binns - HAW
40. Noah Long - MELB
41. Ethan Phillips - Wb
42. Harry Cole - Freo
43. Hugh Davies - Gc
44. Anthony Munkara - ESS - Bid Matched
45. Jack O’Sullivan - Carl
46. Phoenix Foster - Rich
47. Cooper Harvey - Nth - Bid Matched
48. Blake Drury - Geel
49. Cooper Vickery - Haw
50. Harry Rowston - Gws - Bid Matched
51. Billy Dowling - Adel
52. Harry Lemmey - Port
53. Luke Teal - Rich
54. Jed Adams - Freo

And that’s it IMO, a lot that are stiff to miss out but there will be plenty of rookie spots.

Considering how early you did this, back at the end of October, you actually did really well

 

[Smythe]

Considering how early you did this, back at the end of October, you actually did really well

Damn you Kinnear!

Considering how early you did this, back at the end of October, you actually did really well

cheers, should go with my gut more and not get carried away with here say. I had McKenzie going to hawks in an earlier one saying he is the typical mid Sam mitchell is looking for, but then changed it in my mock, in that one I also had ess taking Tsatas. I did have syd bidding for Rowston in my last one……but at pick 40 I think. Damn you Kinnear.

 

[I got the outside word]

Damn you Kinnear!

cheers, should go with my gut more and not get carried away with here say. I had McKenzie going to hawks in an earlier one saying he is the typical mid Sam mitchell is looking for, but then changed it in my mock, in that one I also had ess taking Tsatas. I did have syd bidding for Rowston in my last one……but at pick 40 I think. Damn you Kinnear.

Sydney were out for blood, it was glorious.