Trading Places Snake's trading game draft thread

[Snake Charmer]

BEST 22
B. Thompson, Talia, Jetta
HB. Saad, May, Hanley
C. Ah Chee , Scully, Hall
HF. Kerridge, Lynch, Swallow
F. Smith, Wright, Lloyd
R. Kreuzer, Jones, Miller
Int: Kennedy, Lyons, Kolodjashnij, Brodie

SECOND BEST 22
B. Willis - Himmelberg - Garthwaite
HB. Scrimshaw - Junker - Fox
C. Ellis-Yolman - Hallahan - Schoenfeld
HF. O'Kearney - Taberner - Setterfield
F. McLarty - Petrie Campbell
R. Nicholl - Fiorini - Rischitelli
Int. - Lebois - Villis - Joyce - Bolton

 

[Mitchell54]

Snake Charmer Thetrader15 harro92 Two Planks reggie Drew23 purrrrrrrrrrfect Magpies2010 LukeParkerno1 Danger Money JG22
All need to do your List Analysis. See Prochard's post last page(page 17) for info on what to include.

 

[Thetrader15]

Ahhhh so thats why you wanted to trade him even when i said i wasn't very interested, i thought the trade was fair though

Mine was Melksham to Freo. Ended up trading for Ibbotson

 

[nob2210]

I had to get Scott Selwood to Collingwood, and had to organize an on-trade from Collingwood to Adelaide to get it done...

 

[harro92]

Do we have thread to post list Analysis, also why can't we all vote, just make it u can't vote for yourself


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Prochard123]

Ok so Knightmare and Snoopdog have both said they're happy to be the judges. I've asked Bishop as our 3rd guy but he hasn't replied.

 

[Skipper_]

Ok so Knightmare and Snoopdog have both said they're happy to be the judges. I've asked Bishop as our 3rd guy but he hasn't replied.

If Bishop says no I'd be happy with just KM and Snoop as our judges.

 

[Mitchell54]

Snake Charmer nob2210 JG22 Crowowowow LukeParkerno1 harro92 Thommo333 reggie Magpies2010 Danger Money Prochard123 Drew23 Skipper_@Thetrader15 Two Planks purrrrrrrrrrfect Jedwards
Everyone done list analysis/bio of their team. If you have to do it still I suggest you start now. I think the judges are jusding today

 

[harro92]

What are the judges actually judging ?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Mitchell54]

What are the judges actually judging ?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Who did the best with the draft and trading.

 

[Prochard123]

First few clubs ratings have come in and Skipper_ is in the lead

 

[Skipper_]

First few clubs ratings have come in and Skipper_ is in the lead

Let us know when they have decided.

 

[harro92]

Let us know when they have decided.

Would be surprised if u didn't take it out


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Mitchell54]

First few clubs ratings have come in and Skipper_ is in the lead

Do you think they could or you post the results as they come in here?

 

[Prochard123]

Do you think they could or you post the results as they come in here?

The format i received is different to the one I intended, for good reasons however. I'll post the writing when all is done. However, i can tell you your weighed score if I have received it.


For Snoopdog im using the formula of:

Final score= 0.5 x (trading rating) + 0.4 (National draft rating) + 0.1 (rookie draft rating)
if someone didn't participate in the rookie draft the final score becomes the average of the trading and national draft ratings.

 

[nob2210]

Would be surprised if u didn't take it out


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Really? Wasn't that impressed looking at his list, but maybe just because I don't really rate guys like Gleeson, Colyer, McKenna, Hartley, Fantasia as a non-Bombers supporter.

 

[harro92]

Really? Wasn't that impressed looking at his list, but maybe just because I don't really rate guys like Gleeson, Colyer, McKenna, Hartley, Fantasia as a non-Bombers supporter.

Do you not rate them because u haven't seen them play enough?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Mitchell54]

Really? Wasn't that impressed looking at his list, but maybe just because I don't really rate guys like Gleeson, Colyer, McKenna, Hartley, Fantasia as a non-Bombers supporter.

I rate Fantasia. Hartley is handy. Not keen on the rest though.

 

[harro92]

I rate Fantasia. Hartley is handy. Not keen on the rest though.

I rate Fantasia hartley and choker other guys are depth players ATM


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[nob2210]

Do you not rate them because u haven't seen them play enough?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Very possibly, which is why I tried to include something like that in my statement, although looking back that was poorly done. Obviously, it's how I rate guys from the Eagles that you guys probably wouldn't, partly because I see them more and partly because I tend to be more optimistic about them than opposition would...

 

[harro92]

Very possibly, which is why I tried to include something like that in my statement, although looking back that was poorly done. Obviously, it's how I rate guys from the Eagles that you guys probably wouldn't, partly because I see them more and partly because I tend to be more optimistic about them than opposition would...

Which is fair enough mate you can only rate by what u see


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Prochard123]

From my point of view Skipper did really well considering what he started off with. He transformed pick 1 into many elite young players which was really well done, however there are obviously some of his actions that are left to be desired. However he is only currently first out of the 4 teams by a tiny margin, and it can be swayed easily.