Had a thought in the car on the way home, if its something we want to do as a group that will be permemant, to respect JMac and the club, then how about:
We purchase two guernseys, get #35 on the back of one of them, get someone with good photoshop skills to put together a good photo montage shot of JMac, and get them framed with the front of a home guernsey on the left, the photo montage in the middle, the back with the #35 on the right hand side, and donate it to the club.
That way its something that the club can hang up in the club shop or in the restaurant/bar, something thats respectful that people can look at when they go to the club.
In addition to that, if we wanted to do something for the Sorrento FC, we could do similar with a Port #35 guernsey, a Collingwood #3 guernsey, and two photos of JMac in action for Port & Collingwood.
It shouldnt cost any more than $400 I would think?
EDIT: Similar to the middle part of this, but with the photo where the footy is: