Sophie's Choice at Brisbane

[ooby]

If you absolutely HAD to let one of them go, would it be

• Luke Power
• Simon Black
• Jason Akermanis
• Nigel Lappin

Sorry Luke. I think it might be you But I'd hate myself.

 

[weagles_fan]

Firstly the oldest are Lappin and Akermanis.Then you look at the most damaging and Lappin isn't as damaging as Akermanis.

So Lappin is the one.

 

[Rawhead]

It would have to be lappin.

 

[ooby]

Take your point about age, but at his best still think Lappin can provide more than Power.
This time last year we were talking of Lappin for Brownlow, and he has shown he can play pretty tough. He has the type of build that can keep going for 3 or 4 more years.
Luke, good as he is, plays the type of game that some of the new guys, (and Hadley when he gets back) could cover.
And apologies, I meant to make this a poll. Perils of being a newbie who can't follow instuctions

 

[melbournemartin]

lappin, may aswell get somethin for him before his body just gives in

 

[happy hawker]

Has to be Lappin. Only because of his age. Not a bad quartet there.

 

[Tim the Toolman]

J. MacDonald!

 

[tigers2005]

Lappin would go in my book. Power is a great player with natural instinct around goals!!