Moved Thread SOS v Crows

[My name geoff]

The battle rages on. Let’s check the scorecard..


SOS: McGovern, O’Brien, Kennedy, Plowman, Philips, Stocker, Garlett

Crows: Gibbs, McAdam, McHenry


SOS looks to be on top at this stage, what does everyone else think?

 

[Runnin Blue]

Did you forget Carlton’s next year’s first to Adelaide?

 

[AFDogs]

Did you forget Carlton’s next year’s first to Adelaide?

Do Adelaide really get pick 1 or 2 next year?

I'm lost on how this works.

 

[Runnin Blue]

Do Adelaide really get pick 1 or 2 next year?

I'm lost on how this works.

If Carlton continue being shit, then yes, I believe that’s how it works.

 

[My name geoff]

Did you forget Carlton’s next year’s first to Adelaide?

Just looking at the scorecard as it stands. You can update next year when we know what players have been picked .

 

[AFDogs]

If Carlton continue being shit, then yes, I believe that’s how it works.

I can't see them finishing above anybody apart from maybe Gold Coast or Saints, so yeah. Strange move.

 

[darko]

Do Adelaide really get pick 1 or 2 next year?

I'm lost on how this works.

If Carlton wins the wooden spoon again then yes Adelaide get pick #1.

 

[sthmelb_dimmies]

Just looking at the scorecard as it stands. You can update next year when we know what players have been picked .

If you include Stocker for Baggers then you need to add 2019 First round for Crows.

Which at this point is looking like pick #1

 

[darko]

I can't see them finishing above anybody apart from maybe Gold Coast or Saints, so yeah. Strange move.

GC and Freo imo. I think Saints are better than Blues.

 

[Worm4]

If Carlton wins the wooden spoon again then yes Adelaide get pick #1.

Don't count your chickens, if Carlton win another spoon next year, they will have cause for a priority pick which possibly could be pick 1

 

[PrinceCharles]

I can't see them finishing above anybody apart from maybe Gold Coast or Saints, so yeah. Strange move.

Will finish above your club.

If you include Stocker for Baggers then you need to add 2019 First round for Crows.

Which at this point is looking like pick #1

Then you would need to include Adelaide's 2019 first as well, which could be top 10 as well based on this year.

 

[Danger in Texas]

If the results are the same as this year (which they won’t be) it’s 1 for 7 and 19. Win for us

More likely it’ll end up being 4 for 13 and 19

 

[Runnin Blue]

Don't count your chickens, if Carlton win another spoon next year, they will have cause for a priority pick which possibly could be pick 1

Wouldn’t put it past the VAFL.

 

[Great8]

Crows will make the 8 and Carlton will be bottom 2-3 IMO so in all likelihood it’s going to be 2 for 14ish & 19.
Carlton get what the wanted though so both clubs would be happy

 

[Great8]

Don't count your chickens, if Carlton win another spoon next year, they will have cause for a priority pick which possibly could be pick 1

PP is dead.
Are Carlton going to pretend they don’t want one again?

 

[pinot]

Did you forget Carlton’s next year’s first to Adelaide?

What about your next years first to Carlton we forgot that?

 

[AFDogs]

Will finish above your club.

Hahahaha

Couple key injuries and you blokes are cooked harder than you already are

 

[Crow till I die]

The battle rages on. Let’s check the scorecard..


SOS: McGovern, O’Brien, Kennedy, Plowman, Philips, Stocker, Garlett

Crows: Gibbs, McAdam, McHenry


SOS looks to be on top at this stage, what does everyone else think?

We also have a very early pick of yours today so when we know who we drafted we need to add that name as an in

 

[Pykie]

Don't count your chickens, if Carlton win another spoon next year, they will have cause for a priority pick which possibly could be pick 1

Absolutely no chance in hell the AFL gives a club a first round PP after knowingly trading out their 1st rounder in the full realization that the pick could of been a top 3 pick.

 

[The Joker]

Then you would need to include Adelaide's 2019 first as well, which could be top 10 as well based on this year.

No chance Adelaide get crunched by injuries to key players like they did this season. They will play finals next year, bookmark that shit!

Pick 1 or 2 for pick 19 and pick 10-15, another Carlton F/up on the cards here...

 

[BoltonsBlues]

Adeliade is definatly getting a top 10 pick next year. But in football its laughable to suggest they are getting pick one or two based on this years performance for the blues... yeh we were shit this year.. but the big picture and our list dynamics and structure and age is so good i believe we will make the enevitable jump up the ladder next year

 

[BluesRule]

Next Years Pick swap is a Great move by both clubs.

It is a line in the sand moment, as both clubs have Zero incentive to finish low (tank) and every incentive to improve up the ladder.

Really like it.

 

[The Joker]

Absolutely no chance in hell the AFL gives a club a first round PP after knowingly trading out their 1st rounder in the full realization that the pick could of been a top 3 pick.

Nope, I cant agree with that. Carlton only need to show how much they rated Stocker to justify trading their future pick. If Stocker plays regular league football in 2019, this trade should have no influence over the AFLs decision!

 

[Buzzasto DaSilva]

Adeliade is definatly getting a top 10 pick next year. But in football its laughable to suggest they are getting pick one or two based on this years performance for the blues... yeh we were shit this year.. but the big picture and our list dynamics and structure and age is so good i believe we will make the enevitable jump up the ladder next year

For Carlton to move up the ladder, they actually have to win more than two games. And I don't see that happening. Their list is horrible, they haven't improved it one iota this summer (Setterfield aside), and SOS continues to take such a proud club down a sad path.

 

[The Joker]

For Carlton to move up the ladder, they actually have to win more than two games. And I don't see that happening. Their list is horrible, they haven't improved it one iota this summer (Setterfield aside), and SOS continues to take such a proud club down a sad path.

Proud is subjective...