Southern Football League - Division 3 talk only!

Status
Not open for further replies.

(Log in to remove this ad.)

discotrain

Senior List
Joined
Jun 21, 2007
Posts
155
Likes
0
Location
home
AFL Club
Essendon
Coaches have not even been interviewed yet, or potential coaches. This is all news to me. Someone is stirring the pot early.
Would they even want him, he is well known for his loud antics, have played against him when he was at carnegie, tooronga and sandown and he hasnt changed. Plus dont think there would be room there for him with the JOOCE CABOOSE and Micky Lawrence in the goal square.
 
Joined
Jul 5, 2007
Posts
117
Likes
0
Location
Mulgrave
AFL Club
Collingwood
Would they even want him, he is well known for his loud antics, have played against him when he was at carnegie, tooronga and sandown and he hasnt changed. Plus dont think there would be room there for him with the JOOCE CABOOSE and Micky Lawrence in the goal square.
Not unless they change the goal square to the size of the centre square!
 
Joined
May 2, 2007
Posts
77
Likes
0
AFL Club
Richmond
my tips this week are black rock by 94 points with doveton to end up with about 17 players with disciplne being a problem and salerno being sacked before cricket starts.
in the twos wormy will fire up the boys and doveton to win by 35 points with the experience to shine through.
there my tips take them or leave them................
 

Giddo

Debutant
Joined
Apr 20, 2007
Posts
91
Likes
0
Location
MT ELIZA
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Doveton Eagles
black rock by 53 points with nick owen kicking 9 goals

mounters in the twos by about 4 goals, fielding their strongest side for the year

Well Well I have heard it all now !!! Owen to kick 9, he will be lucky to get 9 kicks.

But don't take my word for it come on down and we can all count them together !! :D:D
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

tadmorose

Senior List
Suspended
Joined
Nov 22, 2006
Posts
155
Likes
0
Location
mulgrave
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
st kilda
HEY scratcha did saleno get sacked after the game,whats going on down there,Wright and Gorman in the ressies ,it cost you in the ones you had know forward line,those two players would have given use a target.:confused:
 

scratcha

Senior List
Joined
Feb 4, 2007
Posts
260
Likes
0
Location
Narre Sth
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Doveton Eagles
HEY scratcha did saleno get sacked after the game,whats going on down there,Wright and Gorman in the ressies ,it cost you in the ones you had know forward line,those two players would have given use a target.:confused:
Wrighty actually injured. Was not gonna play at all. Could not run as you could tell out there, but good enough for to stand in the goal square for the 2s. Mind you would have been good enough to stand in the goal square in the 1s. Gormen, Pete Dye and Gardner would have all been handy in the 1s cos as you could tell, we did all right around the ground, just not alot of experience in the forward line. And Black Rock do have a good backline. These blokes had a falling out with Jason during the year so have played 2s most of the year, which is heartbreaking knowing how good they are and how better we could have been with them.
Jason hasnt been sacked. As far as I know know, he is still coach.
 

tadmorose

Senior List
Suspended
Joined
Nov 22, 2006
Posts
155
Likes
0
Location
mulgrave
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
st kilda
Wrighty actually injured. Was not gonna play at all. Could not run as you could tell out there, but good enough for to stand in the goal square for the 2s. Mind you would have been good enough to stand in the goal square in the 1s. Gormen, Pete Dye and Gardner would have all been handy in the 1s cos as you could tell, we did all right around the ground, just not alot of experience in the forward line. And Black Rock do have a good backline. These blokes had a falling out with Jason during the year so have played 2s most of the year, which is heartbreaking knowing how good they are and how better we could have been with them.
Jason hasnt been sacked. As far as I know know, he is still coach.
Why has he had such a falling out with these types of players,he must have known they could make a big difference,was it his pride?Heard a rumour around the ground that M Allen is on the market,Doveton would be silly not to chase him.
 

benchman

Senior List
Joined
May 9, 2007
Posts
244
Likes
0
Location
Black Rock
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
Black Rock
B: O'Niell (eagles), Rae (dandy), Pearce (mount)
HB: Love (cobras), Challis (rock), Colbert (eagles)
C: Black (dandy), Thomas (eagles), Jeffries (mount)
HF: Baker (cant), Owen (rock), Jewell (yarra)
F: Mussarad (skye), Sheedy (cobras), Johnstone (cant)
R: Wilkin (mount), Pearce (cant), Wilmott (rock)
Int: Stephens (skye), Hidgcock (eagles), Carrol (cant)

I would probably swap Black for Carrol just based on his injury and not playing the last 6-7 games, but it's hard to leave out a guy who wins the goal umpire award. A few stiff ones, Geddes, Fristad, Jenkins, McCarthy, Beardall, Tate, Costantino, Neville. But there are only 21 spots right?
 

BPS9

Draftee
Joined
Nov 21, 2006
Posts
18
Likes
0
Location
adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
B: O'Niell (eagles), Rae (dandy), Pearce (mount)
HB: Love (cobras), Challis (rock), Colbert (eagles)
C: Black (dandy), Thomas (eagles), Jeffries (mount)
HF: Baker (cant), Owen (rock), Jewell (yarra)
F: Mussarad (skye), Sheedy (cobras), Johnstone (cant)
R: Wilkin (mount), Pearce (cant), Wilmott (rock)
Int: Stephens (skye), Hidgcock (eagles), Carrol (cant)

I would probably swap Black for Carrol just based on his injury and not playing the last 6-7 games, but it's hard to leave out a guy who wins the goal umpire award. A few stiff ones, Geddes, Fristad, Jenkins, McCarthy, Beardall, Tate, Costantino, Neville. But there are only 21 spots right?

T.Barr would have to be unlucky to miss out as well. I hear he killed them on a half back flank in second half of year.
 

scratcha

Senior List
Joined
Feb 4, 2007
Posts
260
Likes
0
Location
Narre Sth
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Doveton Eagles
Well Well I have heard it all now !!! Owen to kick 9, he will be lucky to get 9 kicks.

But don't take my word for it come on down and we can all count them together !! :D:D
Hey Bazz what you think about the game on sat. Eagles have a good future with OJ, Gus, Cam V, Frisdad, Brett Hidgcock, and Brett Reid who are all teenages and had great years. Just inexperienced against the good Black Rock outfit. A few more good teenages coming down next year also, so might be time to retire:D:D:D
Actually its a good excuse to get away from the wife and kid each tuesday, thursday and Sat so I will be still having a dip next year!
 

blac04

All Australian
Joined
Nov 25, 2006
Posts
723
Likes
0
Location
endeavour hills
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Other Teams
doveton eagles
Hey Bazz what you think about the game on sat. Eagles have a good future with OJ, Gus, Cam V, Frisdad, Brett Hidgcock, and Brett Reid who are all teenages and had great years. Just inexperienced against the good Black Rock outfit. A few more good teenages coming down next year also, so might be time to retire:D:D:D
Actually its a good excuse to get away from the wife and kid each tuesday, thursday and Sat so I will be still having a dip next year!
you'll dominate in the guts in the 2's scratcha!! can't wait!!:D:D
 

scratcha

Senior List
Joined
Feb 4, 2007
Posts
260
Likes
0
Location
Narre Sth
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Doveton Eagles
B: O'Niell (eagles), Rae (dandy), Pearce (mount)
HB: Love (cobras), Challis (rock), Colbert (eagles)
C: Black (dandy), Thomas (eagles), Jeffries (mount)
HF: Baker (cant), Owen (rock), Jewell (yarra)
F: Mussarad (skye), Sheedy (cobras), Johnstone (cant)
R: Wilkin (mount), Pearce (cant), Wilmott (rock)
Int: Stephens (skye), Hidgcock (eagles), Carrol (cant)

I would probably swap Black for Carrol just based on his injury and not playing the last 6-7 games, but it's hard to leave out a guy who wins the goal umpire award. A few stiff ones, Geddes, Fristad, Jenkins, McCarthy, Beardall, Tate, Costantino, Neville. But there are only 21 spots right?
hey Benchman, were you at the game saturday watching your beloved Black Rock.
 

benchman

Senior List
Joined
May 9, 2007
Posts
244
Likes
0
Location
Black Rock
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
Black Rock
hey Benchman, were you at the game saturday watching your beloved Black Rock.
Sure was. How good was the rocker back line!!

Credit to eagles, fristad and thomas were outstanding i thought.

Doveton rezzies put up a better fight than i thought, congrats to them. Although, might be a completely different side next week by the looks?
 

No.4

Debutant
Joined
Apr 13, 2007
Posts
55
Likes
0
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Mount Waverley
B: O'Niell (eagles), Rae (dandy), Pearce (mount)
HB: Love (cobras), Challis (rock), Colbert (eagles)
C: Black (dandy), Thomas (eagles), Jeffries (mount)
HF: Baker (cant), Owen (rock), Jewell (yarra)
F: Mussarad (skye), Sheedy (cobras), Johnstone (cant)
R: Wilkin (mount), Pearce (cant), Wilmott (rock)
Int: Stephens (skye), Hidgcock (eagles), Carrol (cant)

I would probably swap Black for Carrol just based on his injury and not playing the last 6-7 games, but it's hard to leave out a guy who wins the goal umpire award. A few stiff ones, Geddes, Fristad, Jenkins, McCarthy, Beardall, Tate, Costantino, Neville. But there are only 21 spots right?
Well done benchman. Congratulations on looking thru the best each week and picking a team. :thumbsdown:

Surely Cam Kirkup from Mt could get a gig in the FP or atleast get a mention in the stiff ones category considering he kicked 40 goals for the year, playing as a crumbing forward. Also maybe the old man Gallagher could get a mention kicking 27 goals as a mid/forward (please no one tell him i said this). Or maybe young Tommy Robbo who has actually played CHF this year.

These are just opinions i guess, like yours. Maybe it comes from watching the same team week in week out. Lets just hope the guys who actually pick the team do more research. peace
 

No.4

Debutant
Joined
Apr 13, 2007
Posts
55
Likes
0
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Mount Waverley
Sorry that came out a lot harsher than was intended. Certainly agree with some selections but as mentioned have only really looked at one team week in week out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom