Autopsy St.Kilda vs GWS Giants, Friday 18th September, 2020 Gabba, 7.50pm

Remove this Banner Ad

Giant Strides

Moderator
Nov 23, 2015
4,745
6,133
AFL Club
GWS
9CFC82DC-F5A7-4DBD-BE3F-6E26876A9E0A.png


7TH V 10TH


2020 TOYOTA AFL PREMIERSHIP
Round 18 • ST KILDA V GWS
FRIDAY SEPTEMBER 18TH 7:50PM AEST (GABBA)

ROUND 18 TEAMS

SAINTS


B: J.Carlisle, D.Howard, C.Wilkie
HB: N.Coffield, J.Battle, B.Long
C: D.Hannebery, S.Ross, B.Hill
HF: J.Billings, T.Membrey, D.Butler
F: M.King, R.Marshall, J.Geary
FOLL: P.Ryder, J.Steele, H.Clark

I/C: D.Kent, J.Sinclair, B.Paton, J.Lonie
EMG: R.Byrnes, S.Savage, J.Marsh, L.Dunstan

IN: J.Carlisle, D.Hannebery
OUT: N.Hind (Omitted), Z.Jones (Injured)

GIANTS

B: C.Idun, L.Keeffe, H.Shaw
HB: L.Whitfield, N.Haynes, Z.Williams
C: J.Kelly, J.Hopper, H.Perryman
HF: J.Cameron, J.Riccardi, M.de Boer
F: T.Greene, J.Finlayson, B.Daniels
FOLL: S.Mumford, S.Coniglio, T.Taranto

I/C: C.Idun, D.Lloyd, J.Buckley, T.Green
EMER: B.Hill, M.Flynn, J.Caldwell, I.Cumming

IN: J.Riccardi, S.Coniglio
OUT: A.Kennedy (Omitted), H.Himmelberg (Omitted)

From Land of the Giants preview:


It's not just that if we beat St. Kilda other results have to fall our way for us to qualify for finals. It's a question of whether we even want to be there.

It's clear the playing group did not take the resumption of the season seriously after downing a near full-strength Richmond in the pre-season, then Geelong in Round 1. The difference in attitude with what followed afterwards is obvious. How else to explain a team so laden with talent losing to North, Adelaide, and Sydney?

When things got going again, a lot of people in the AFL community asked the same question - "Is this a real season?". Well, it certainly has been, and you can bet the AFL will have learned a great deal about scheduling when this is all over. Reports that our playing group hated living the hub concept demonstrate they just didn't buy into the revamped competition idea.

To repeat, we can still make finals if we win, and Collingwood lose to Port, and the Bombers beat Melbourne (and those two results are more plausible than us beating St. Kilda). But we have a lot of attitudinal issues to solve in the off-season, and we're probably better off in the long run getting to work on them as soon as possible.
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

(Log in to remove this ad.)

General Giant

Hall of Famer
Apr 12, 2012
36,831
28,954
AFL Club
GWS
High shot by saints.
Holding the ball call.

Mark taken by a player. Owe my leg. He can give it to a great fwd and goal kicker.


Commentary almost on their knees blowing the Saints

Ok fu** off.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Top Bottom