Post BF Upgrade Feedback - Click Here

Remove this Banner Ad

starting 22

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

lids_tiger_army

lids_tiger_army

Senior List
Joined
May 31, 2007
Posts
177
Reaction score
0
Location
melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
RICHMOND
 Bowden, Joel (veteran – outside list)
Brown, Nathan G.
Casserly, Travis
Collins, Andrew
Connors, Daniel
Cotchin, Trent
Coughlan, Mark
Deledio, Brett
Edwards, Shane
Foley, Nathan
Gourdis, David
Graham, Angus
Hughes, Cleve
Hyde, Chris
Jackson, Daniel
Johnson, Kane
King, Jake
McGuane, Luke
McMahon, Jordan
Meyer, Danny
Moore, Kelvin
Morton, Mitch
Newman, Chris
Oakley-Nicholls, Jarrad
Pattison, Adam
Pettifer, Kayne
Polak, Graham
Polo, Dean
Putt, Dean
Raines, Andrew
Rance, Alex
Richardson, Matthew (veteran – outside list)
Riewoldt, Jack
Schulz, Jay
Simmonds, Troy
Tambling, Richard
Thursfield, Will
Tivendale, Greg
Tuck, Shane
White, Matthew
Rookie List
 Cartledge, Tristan
Collard, Clayton
Howat, Cam
Silvester, Jarrod



I believe the selected 28 are all fighting for the starting 22 in round 1...
who do we think will be in and out..
all of the highlighted have a great chance of being in the team come round 1..
 
Take out Rance and put in Schulz or hughes and i think you'd be on the money. Riewoldt's a flanker and you need at least 1 second tall forward besides richo (although patto/simmo could feasibly play that role).

I reckon our 2nd 22 is actually quite promising. While we dont have a bunch of star youngsters yet, there seems to be alot of depth, especially

First 22
B: Newman Thursfield King
HB: Bowden Polak McMahon
C: Deledio Tuck Raines
HF: Pettifer Pattison Riewoldt
F: Brown Richardson Tambling
R: Simmonds Johnson Foley
Int: Morton, Polo, Tivendale, Coughlan

Second 22
B: Rance Silvester White
HB: Oakley-Nicholls McGuane Hyde
C: Howat Connors Edwards
HF: Gourdis Hughes Putt
F: Collard Schulz Meyer
R: Graham Jackson Cotchin
Int: Collins, Casserly, Cartledge, Moore
 
For the first time that i can remember, there is not a player on our list that i can say i wouldn't want there.

Previously we have had at least 1 (if not more) players that you just wished didn't represent this great club. This list is going places :thumbsu:
 
Rancid_Beasties said:
Take out Rance and put in Schulz or hughes and i think you'd be on the money. Riewoldt's a flanker and you need at least 1 second tall forward besides richo (although patto/simmo could feasibly play that role).

I reckon our 2nd 22 is actually quite promising. While we dont have a bunch of star youngsters yet, there seems to be alot of depth, especially

First 22
B: Newman Thursfield King
HB: Bowden Polak McMahon
C: Deledio Tuck Raines
HF: Pettifer Pattison Riewoldt
F: Brown Richardson Tambling
R: Simmonds Johnson Foley
Int: Morton, Polo, Tivendale, Coughlan

Second 22
B: Rance Silvester White
HB: Oakley-Nicholls McGuane Hyde
C: Howat Connors Edwards
HF: Gourdis Hughes Putt
F: Collard Schulz Meyer
R: Graham Jackson Cotchin
Int: Collins, Casserly, Cartledge, Moore
Click to expand...

there is definately alot of competition amongst the 2 teams you have posted.. i believe the highlighted players are the ones that really need to do well early on and put the pressure on each other to perform.. i also think we may see alot of improvement in a few of those players as they will all be hungrier knowing what they have below them.
we may very well have a few surprise packets next season (ala tuck 2005, raines 2006)
2008 is sure to surprise us all i think..:thumbsu:
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Rancid_Beasties said:
Take out Rance and put in Schulz or hughes and i think you'd be on the money. Riewoldt's a flanker and you need at least 1 second tall forward besides richo (although patto/simmo could feasibly play that role).

I reckon our 2nd 22 is actually quite promising. While we dont have a bunch of star youngsters yet, there seems to be alot of depth, especially

First 22
B: Newman Thursfield King
HB: Bowden Polak McMahon
C: Deledio Tuck Raines
HF: Pettifer Pattison Riewoldt
F: Brown Richardson Tambling
R: Simmonds Johnson Foley
Int: Morton, Polo, Tivendale, Coughlan

Second 22
B: Rance Silvester White
HB: Oakley-Nicholls McGuane Hyde
C: Howat Connors Edwards
HF: Gourdis Hughes Putt
F: Collard Schulz Meyer
R: Graham Jackson Cotchin
Int: Collins, Casserly, Cartledge, Moore
Click to expand...

Luke Mcguane is worthy to be one of the first defenders selected after showing the development he did last season...maybe with a ty esler no kick rule enforced he'll be even better.
 
roostertalk said:
Luke Mcguane is worthy to be one of the first defenders selected after showing the development he did last season...maybe with a ty esler no kick rule enforced he'll be even better.
Click to expand...
Are you kidding? At this stage he looks a lively type who could find a spot this year but one of the first defenders picked? Bowden #1, Polak #2, Thursfield #3, then some midfielder come defenders like king, polo, mcmahon etc all well ahead of him. 14 games, in and out of the team, no certainty to get even that many games this year.
 
Rancid_Beasties said:
Are you kidding? At this stage he looks a lively type who could find a spot this year but one of the first defenders picked? Bowden #1, Polak #2, Thursfield #3, then some midfielder come defenders like king, polo, mcmahon etc all well ahead of him. 14 games, in and out of the team, no certainty to get even that many games this year.
Click to expand...

probably got a little excited and agree with bowden, polak and thursfield and maybe king...but mcmahon (pretty ordinary year in an ordinary side) and polo(hasnt played footy for a long time and before then was hardly dominating) are definitely no certainties to be in the squad before Mcguane. He had a great finish to last season and if he continues that form will be a permanent fixture and rightly so.
 
This is what our best 22 SHOULD be in my opinion
B: McGuane Thursfield King
HB: Bowden Polak McMahon
C: Newman Coughlan Tambling
HF: Pettifer Richo Deledio
F: Brown Riewoldt Edwards
R: Simmonds Tuck Foley
Int: Raines, Pattison, Polo, Johnson
Also fighting for spots: Cotchin, Morton, Connors, Hughes, Jackson, Tivendale
 
First 22
B: Bowden Thursfield King
HB: Johnson, McGuane McMahon
C: Jackson Tuck Newman
HF: Pettifer Polak, Brown
F: Deledio Richo, Schulz
R: Simmonds Coughlan Foley
Int: Cotchin, Tivendale, Tambling, Pattison

Emerg: Morton, Raines, Riewoltd, Connors etc
 
Time to cut ties with Tivendale >> Coburg. He should not get a run in front of Cotchin or Edwards who need game time. You could argue that Cotchin/Edwards could do with some time in the two's, and Tivendale had a reasonable 2007, polling well in our B&F, but he is not the future of the club.
 
B: McGuane Thursfield King
HB: Bowden Rance McMahon
C: Newman Coughlan Tambling
HF: Pettifer Richo Morton
F: Brown Polak Deledio
R: Simmonds Tuck Foley
Int: Pattison, Polo, Edwards, Johnson
 

Remove this Banner Ad

No way will Rance play CHB in 2008. If he plays at all it will be third tall defender.

Newman Thursfield King
Bowden Polak McMahon
Jackson Coughlan Johnson
Pettifer Schulz Deledio
Brown Richardson Hyde
Simmonds Foley Tuck

Pattison Tambling Tivendale Moore

Not our future team, but the best team we can play in 2008. If they fail to perform then expect changes like last year.
 
Gee i find this hard but for what it's worth here's mine.



b. Jake King Luke Mcguane Daniel Conners
hb. Joel Bowden Will Thursfield Jordan McMahon
c. Richard Tambling COGGS Dean Polo
hf.The File Graham Polak Jack Riewoldt
f. Brett Deledio Richo Brown Dog
foll. Troy Simmonds Chris Newman Axel
int. Tucky, Raines, Alex Rance, Patto
emg. Shane Edwards Cleve Hughes Mitch Morton
Bit worried we have a lot of 1/2 back Flankers on our list and the back line is a little inexperenced but most of our list is
 
beaver fever said:
No way will Rance play CHB in 2008. If he plays at all it will be third tall defender.

Newman Thursfield King
Bowden Polak McMahon
Jackson Coughlan Johnson
Pettifer Schulz Deledio
Brown Richardson Hyde
Simmonds Foley Tuck

Pattison Tambling Tivendale Moore

Not our future team, but the best team we can play in 2008. If they fail to perform then expect changes like last year.
Click to expand...

Thats the most realistic so far.

Since when has Polak been a Full Forward and Richardson a CHF? Richo's only getting older, sorry to say.

When does Pattison play CHF?

Rance an automatic CHB yet everyone wants to see a video as soon as his drafted because they've never seen him play.
 
rfctigerarmy said:
Thats the most realistic so far.

Since when has Polak been a Full Forward and Richardson a CHF? Richo's only getting older, sorry to say.

When does Pattison play CHF?

Rance an automatic CHB yet everyone wants to see a video as soon as his drafted because they've never seen him play.
Click to expand...


I'm pretty sure Polak will be a forward in '08. They name Richo CHF, 'cause you can't put him FP, positions when naming a line-up mean SFA.

I read on either PRE/OER that Terry and co. have told Schulz there is a spot down back for him, which gets me thinking that Polak will be a forward, well at least to begin the season.

My starting 22 for Round 1 would be:

B: Raines - Thursfield - King
HB: Bowden - Schulz - McMahon
C: Newman - Tuck - Jackson
HF: Pettifer - Richo - Tambling
F: Brown - Polak - Deledio

1R: Simmonds - Foley - Johnson

Int: Patto - Morton - Polo - Cogs

Emg: Edwards - Cotchin - Tivendale

EDIT - Forgot Cogs, Patto & Raines :eek:

I don't really like having Schulz at CHB though, 'cause I'd like to fit in Tivva. So maybe Polak to CHB, Richo to FF, Petts to CHF, Morton to HF and Tivva gets bench...

This is very hard...Had to leave out Edwards and Moore who IMO will play a bit in 2008. I'd like to have Cotchin playing too but I can't fit him in.
 
FB: King Thursfield McGuane
HB: Bowden Polak McMahon
C: Newman Foley Deledio
HF: Pettifer Richardson Tambling
FF: Brown Schulz Edwards
R: Simmonds Coughlan Tuck
INT: Raines Pattison Johnson Polo


EMER: Jackson Connors Hyde Tivendale Cotchin
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Rancid_Beasties said:
Take out Rance and put in Schulz or hughes and i think you'd be on the money. Riewoldt's a flanker and you need at least 1 second tall forward besides richo (although patto/simmo could feasibly play that role).

I reckon our 2nd 22 is actually quite promising. While we dont have a bunch of star youngsters yet, there seems to be alot of depth, especially

First 22
B: Newman Thursfield King
HB: Bowden Polak McMahon
C: Deledio Tuck Raines
HF: Pettifer Pattison Riewoldt
F: Brown Richardson Tambling
R: Simmonds Johnson Foley
Int: Morton, Polo, Tivendale, Coughlan

Second 22
B: Rance Silvester White
HB: Oakley-Nicholls McGuane Hyde
C: Howat Connors Edwards
HF: Gourdis Hughes Putt
F: Collard Schulz Meyer
R: Graham Jackson Cotchin
Int: Collins, Casserly, Cartledge, Moore
Click to expand...

Mcguane/sarge will get a gig, the back half is too small
 
B-King Thursty Mguane
HB-Newman Polak Mchman
C- Cotchin Coughlan Tuck
HF- Bling Rewolt Pettifer
F -COnnors RIcho Brown

R: Simmo foley lids

I: patto johnson raines tiv/edwards/shulz/jackson

Dnt think that would be the startin 22 but i would liekt o see it liek that
 
Bowden, Joel
Brown, Nathan G.
Casserly, Travis
Collins, Andrew
Connors, Daniel
Cotchin, Trent
Coughlan, Mark
Deledio, Brett
Edwards, Shane
Foley, Nathan
Gourdis, David
Graham, Angus
Hughes, Cleve
Hyde, Chris
Jackson, Daniel
Johnson, Kane
King, Jake
McGuane, Luke
McMahon, Jordan
Meyer, Danny
Moore, Kelvin
Morton, Mitch
Newman, Chris
Oakley-Nicholls, Jarrad
Pattison, Adam
Pettifer, Kayne
Polak, Graham
Polo, Dean
Putt, Dean
Raines, Andrew
Rance, Alex
Richardson, Matthew
Riewoldt, Jack
Schulz, Jay
Simmonds, Troy
Tambling, Richard
Thursfield, Will
Tivendale, Greg
Tuck, Shane
White, Matthew


Those in bold I have seen enough of and are convinced will not play in a AFL premiership, due to retirement, injuries or ability and based solely that I think we are at least 2-3 years away, I hope I'm wrong.
So I guess the question I think is, do the selectors look at the long future now, throw them in the deep end and play the blokes who are likely to be around when we are good enough ? mix and match them a bit to give some experienced players to have around, or just pick purely on form ??
 
B: Raines Thursfield King
HB: Bowden Polak Newman
C: McMahon Tuck Johnson
HF: Pettifer Deledio Tambling
F: Brown Richo Edwards
R: Simmonds Coughlan Foley

Int: Polo, McGuane, Morton, Pattison

Emg: Tivendale, Riewoldt, Connors, Cotchin
 
FWIW:
Richmond 22
B: Newman Thursfield McGuane
HB: Bowden Polak McMahon
C: Polo Coughlan Tambling
HF: Pettifer Simmonds Deledio
F: Brown Richo Morton
R: Pattison Tuck Foley
I: Johnson Schulz Raines Edwards
E: Cotchin Connors King

At Coburg I would like to see the following players played in these positions:
Riewoldt - HFF
Hughes - CHF
Graham - Ruck
Putt - FF/Ruck
Meyer - HFF/Midfield
JON - HBF/Wing
Cotchin - HFF/FP
Connors - HBF/Midfield
Gourdis - CHB
Rance - HBF/BP/FB
King - Midfield
Casserly - HBF/BP
Collins - BP/HBF

Get them playing in the positions that they will be playing at AFL level.
 
Realistic Tiger said:
FWIW:
Richmond 22
B: Newman Thursfield McGuane
HB: Bowden Polak McMahon
C: Polo Coughlan Tambling
HF: Pettifer Simmonds Deledio
F: Brown Richo Morton
R: Pattison Tuck Foley
I: Johnson Schulz Raines Edwards
E: Cotchin Connors King

At Coburg I would like to see the following players played in these positions:
Riewoldt - HFF
Hughes - CHF
Graham - Ruck
Putt - FF/Ruck
Meyer - HFF/Midfield
JON - HBF/Wing
Cotchin - HFF/FP
Connors - HBF/Midfield
Gourdis - CHB
Rance - HBF/BP/FB
King - Midfield
Casserly - HBF/BP
Collins - BP/HBF

Get them playing in the positions that they will be playing at AFL level.
Click to expand...
I like that team, but I am surprised King isn't in the side
King should be an automatic
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom