State of origin side- 90s — now

Remove this Banner Ad

Lingsface

Lingsface

Premiership Player
Veteran
May 9, 2005
4,233
2,330
perth
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
geelong
So I was thinking I would do a state of origin post on an all time team but I’ll just do my all time which started watching football in the 90s- WA/SA/Vic/Allies
(Off the top of my head and will try to make a mixture of present and 90s)

WA
D Rich D Glass Mcgovern
H Taylor A Rance L McPharlin
P Matera B Cousin D Kerr
S Coniglio J Kennedy P Cripps
M Lecras L Franklin E Betts
R- D Cox S Black N Fyfe
I/C- Jackovich M Priddis Natanui P Bell

South Australia

G Wanganeen N Smart C Daniel
S Hurn C Cornes C Enright
S Burgoyne M Ricuttio A Goodes
S Kernahan M Pavlich W Tredrae
D Jarman T Modra A Cooney
R/ B Grundy L Neale J Francou
I/C L Darcy K Cornes P Burgoyne S Goodwin

Vic
S Silvagni M Scarlett G Archer
C Johnson T Stewart L Hodge
D Martin M Voss S Pendlebury
S Johnson J Brown G Ablett snr
M Lloyd T Lockett J Akermanis
Ruck- M Gawn G Ablett Jnr C Judd
I/C- R Harvey J Selwood J Cameron J Roughead

Allies-
L Barry Trent Croad Paul Kelly
A McLeod M Michael M Long
M Richardson N Buckley S Crawford
I Heeney W Carey T Hawkins
N Reiwoldt J Dunstall C Rioli
Ruck- C Keating L Hayes J Hird
I/C - G Birchall B Brownless T Walker J Reiwoldt
 
Last edited:
For SA my changes off the top of my head.
In:
Pav
Darren jarman
Ben hart
Craig Bradley

Out:
Bickley
Puopolo
C Cornes
K cornes
 
Lingsface said:
So I was thinking I would do a state of origin post on an all time team but I’ll just do my all time which started watching football in the 90s- WA/SA/Vic/Allies
(Off the top of my head and will try to make a mixture of present and 90s)

WA
D Rich D Glass Mcgovern
H Taylor A Rance L McPharlin
P Matera B Cousin D Kerr
S Coniglio J Kennedy P Cripps
M Lecras L Franklin E Betts
R- D Cox S Black N Fyfe
I/C- Jackovich M Priddis Natanui P Bell

South Australia

G Wanganeen N Smart C Daniel
S Hurn C Cornes C Enright
S Burgoyne M Ricuttio A Goodes
P Burgoyne S Kernahan W Tredrae
P Puopolo T Modra A Cooney
R/ B Grundy L Neale J Francou
I/C L Darcy K Cornes M Bickley S Goodwin

Vic
S Silvagni M Scarlett G Archer
C Johnson T Stewart L Hodge
D Martin M Voss S Pendlebury
S Johnson J Brown G Ablett snr
M Lloyd T Lockett J Akermanis
Ruck- M Gawn G Ablett Jnr C Judd
I/C- R Harvey J Selwood J Cameron J Roughead

Allies-
L Barry Trent Croad Paul Kelly
A McLeod M Michael M Long
M Richardson N Buckley S Crawford
I Heeney N Reiwoldt T Hawkins
J Reiwoldt J Dunstall C Rioli
Ruck- C Keating L Hayes J Hird
I/C - G Birchall B Brownless T Walker I Smith
Click to expand...
WA backline too tall. Jackovich first choice CHB.
Vic bench. Only need one tall.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Mick F said:
WA backline too tall. Jackovich first choice CHB.
Vic bench. Only need one tall.
Click to expand...
I think I’d stick with Rance or McPharlin over Jackovich. But there’s so many good WA talk back man hard to find a spot for the smalls.
 
Lingsface said:
I think I’d stick with Rance or McPharlin over Jackovich. But there’s so many good WA talk back man hard to find a spot for the smalls.
Click to expand...
Rance can quite easily play small/medium, definetely not a big lumbering tall.

All those sides are amazing, as you'd expect.
 
I’d replace Grimes with Chris Johnson


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
I was seriously confused about Silvagni in a pocket and no Dustin Fletcher with Jeremy Cameron somehow making the bench - then I worked it out.
 
GWT6 said:
I was seriously confused about Silvagni in a pocket and no Dustin Fletcher with Jeremy Cameron somehow making the bench - then I worked it out.
Click to expand...


I couldn’t make an argument for Cameron to be ranked at that level.

But there is a very legitimate argument between Silvagni and Scarlett

There’s arguments you can make either way but I would wager that he majority of footy fans over the last 35 years would say the two genuine top fullbacks grouped together are those two with the likes of Fletcher, Glass and Rance a step or two below
 
The WA side I’d be finding room for the likes of Worsfold, McKenna, Kemp, Sumich and Farmer
 
PhatBoy said:
I couldn’t make an argument for Cameron to be ranked at that level.

But there is a very legitimate argument between Silvagni and Scarlett

There’s arguments you can make either way but I would wager that he majority of footy fans over the last 35 years would say the two genuine top fullbacks grouped together are those two with the likes of Fletcher, Glass and Rance a step or two below
Click to expand...
I would have Scarlett in that team, but spent a lot of his time as a back pocket, not taking the hardest option. Silvagni always played on the most dangerous forward. Dustin Fletcher split his time between the two, Archer a great CHB. T Stewart is not even qualified to carry their bags to the game.
And Jeremy Cameron in the team of the last 30 years? Give me a spell.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

GWT6 said:
I would have Scarlett in that team, but spent a lot of his time as a back pocket, not taking the hardest option. Silvagni always played on the most dangerous forward. Dustin Fletcher split his time between the two, Archer a great CHB. T Stewart is not even qualified to carry their bags to the game.
And Jeremy Cameron in the team of the last 30 years? Give me a spell.
Click to expand...


That’s a bit of a misnomer because of where Scarlett ended up. He spent a good 7-8 seasons blanking the #Opposition forward.

I do see your point as he played more loose than Silvagni towards the end but he was every bit a man on man fullback for most of his career
 
hilly said:
Biased but I'd sneak Wayne Carey into either the SA or Allies team.
Click to expand...
Damn haha that was a mistake he’s allies chf for sure. N Reiwoldt to the flank Hawkins to the pocket and J Reiwoldt to the bench pushing I Smith out.
 
GWT6 said:
I would have Scarlett in that team, but spent a lot of his time as a back pocket, not taking the hardest option. Silvagni always played on the most dangerous forward. Dustin Fletcher split his time between the two, Archer a great CHB. T Stewart is not even qualified to carry their bags to the game.
And Jeremy Cameron in the team of the last 30 years? Give me a spell.
Click to expand...
Archer CHB he was barely 6ft he’s not holding down the CHF on the other team, Stewart already 4 All Australians he’s a superstar.

Cameron will end up a 700 goal player and he’s very versatile with his running ability can play as a half forward wingman or deep forward, one of the best forwards of the modern time. Have a spell, hit the bench.
 
Lingsface said:
Archer CHB he was barely 6ft he’s not holding down the CHF on the other team, Stewart already 4 All Australians he’s a superstar.

Cameron will end up a 700 goal player and he’s very versatile with his running ability can play as a half forward wingman or deep forward, one of the best forwards of the modern time. Have a spell, hit the bench.
Click to expand...


He may end up that way and we all know he is very elite but I don’t think he’s in that company yet
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Cleric
Whats the current requirement for State of Origin eligibility?
Replies
21
Views
751
Kwality
K
RUNVS
Who wins - Your 2015 side vs 2024 side?
2
Replies
33
Views
835
PJays
P
Coolangatta
Opinion Instead of a "gather round" why not a State of Origin round?
Replies
11
Views
742
Cunnington Cartel
Cunnington Cartel
bzparkes
Would original expansion clubs have greater support if they named themselves after a state/area?
2
Replies
26
Views
2K
Johnny Bananas
Johnny Bananas
Chief
Game Footy Survivor 4 - Touched off the boot. # VOTE NOW # STOP THE HAWKS #
21 22 23 24 25
Replies
602
Views
9K
Paul Kersey
Paul Kersey
Bunk Moreland
Roast The absolute state of Channel 7 broadcasts
4 5 6 7 8
Replies
182
Views
8K
Jesslc
J
Teen Wolf
Club CEOs and league interested in return to AFLW State of Origin
2
Replies
29
Views
2K
GC2015
GC2015

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top