Rumour State of Origin?

mattymac

GM of Awareness
Jul 9, 2009
14,883
25,526
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
No
Heard Johnny Platten on the radio app today. Apart from uncomfortable childhood memories of the time we were kids and saw some bird giving him a gobby in the park and couldn't understand what or why, he also talked about an upcoming state of origin game for bushfire relief.

I thought 'awesome, that makes sense since both Vic and SA have been hit by bushfires'.

But later they said it would just be some "Vic v Allstars" wank again and held at 'Marvel stadium' no less. The AFL clearly has an anti-SOO mindset and even when the opportunity arises they need to water it down into a Greater Victoria v a bunch of people from other states at a second rate venue malarky.

Thought it initially sounded great when the Platypus was talking about it. Now couldn't be less interested.

I know some of you VFL purists are dead against state of origin. But when you look at rugby that's something they well and truly have over footy. And yes, on paper we might not have a supreme team atm, but perhaps it would be stronger if SOO wasn't deliberately sidelined by the VFL uber alles mentality for decades. Used to get 50k mid week and have games completely unpredictable on paper because their was a passion that now only the rugby states can muster while we whimper about potential injuries or other excuses why not to do it.

So let's hear the usual excuses why not to try, it's off season after all 🤣
 

LiquidCrow

Club Legend
Oct 21, 2012
1,523
2,662
AFL Club
Adelaide
Apart from uncomfortable childhood memories of the time we were kids and saw some bird giving him a gobby in the park and couldn't understand what or why
Not quite what I expected to read, but ok.

Have no interest in another Vic vs Allstars game - would rather a Slowdown over that.

They always say we won't be able to field a competitive SA team, but give it a few years when the likes of Luko, Rankine, Rozee, Hately and others from that promising crop are up and about and who knows.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Samcro24

Suffering from BS Awareness
Oct 28, 2014
6,683
14,755
AFL Club
Adelaide
I’m not interested in all stars, but I’ve been on the “sa would get flogged” bandwagon for some time. I hope it comes back just to highlight that elephant in the room.

It won’t though. Club footy is too important and the game is alot more lucrative than it was when origin died. Can’t see the best players playing it every year. Some already complain that the season is too long.
 

1990crow

Brownlow Medallist
Jan 31, 2009
19,139
23,156
AFL Club
Adelaide
Who from our side would play SOO?

SA - Laird, Smith, Brown
NSW - Walker
Vic - Sloane

Crouch brothers probably don’t make Vic team.
Gibbs borderline SA due to poor SA depth. Same for Fogarty so early into his career.
Talia would go close to Vic side.
 

brucetiki

Spec Moderator
Nov 7, 2002
20,506
11,602
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Adelaide, Centrals
Annoucement at 12:00pm confirming the match.

I'm hoping it's not an 'All Stars' farce like 2008, but the fact that media is talking about the 'first SOO match since 1999' has me a tad optimistic that it will be true State of Origin, but then I can't see WA being too thrilled about missing out on a SOO match that's between Victoria and SA.
 

Elite Crow

Premium Platinum
Mar 21, 2008
55,237
75,940
AFL Club
Adelaide
Couple of things, this isn’t a State of Origin game in the true sense. It’s to raise money for a worthy cause featuring the best players in the comp.

It will be the Vics against the All Stars, it’s the only way the whole comp can get behind it and be included.

If it was to be a true SOO match it could only be Vic v WA. That Vic midfield is unbelievable and the only team having a chance to compete would be WA and even then they’d be flogged.

Any suggestion of SA is absolutely laughable, it would give 119 a run. That’s the last thing this game needs.

Again the intention of it is to raise money by putting on a quality game featuring the best players in the comp where everyone is included.

Please keep sight of that before you whinge.
 

Crows I Am

Club Legend
Jul 12, 2006
1,120
1,340
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
North Adelaide
Couple of things, this isn’t a State of Origin game in the true sense. It’s to raise money for a worthy cause featuring the best players in the comp.

It will be the Vics against the All Stars, it’s the only way the whole comp can get behind it and be included.

If it was to be a true SOO match it could only be Vic v WA. That Vic midfield is unbelievable and the only team having a chance to compete would be WA and even then they’d be flogged.

Any suggestion of SA is absolutely laughable, it would give 119 a run. That’s the last thing this game needs.

Again the intention of it is to raise money by putting on a quality game featuring the best players in the comp where everyone is included.

Please keep sight of that before you whinge.
Well said, the whole idea of this game is to raise money for the bushfire victims. Without playing a round robin style tournament (which none of the players or clubs would agree to) this is the only way it is viable. This will at least get the whole country interested and get as hopefully get as much exposure as possible.

The sad part of it is when you realize that we will be lucky to get any players in either team. Laird and Talia the only ones with a shot.
 

ftmch

Club Legend
Aug 15, 2009
2,559
2,907
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Legs, Wests Tigers
Couple of things, this isn’t a State of Origin game in the true sense. It’s to raise money for a worthy cause featuring the best players in the comp.

It will be the Vics against the All Stars, it’s the only way the whole comp can get behind it and be included.

If it was to be a true SOO match it could only be Vic v WA. That Vic midfield is unbelievable and the only team having a chance to compete would be WA and even then they’d be flogged.

Any suggestion of SA is absolutely laughable, it would give 119 a run. That’s the last thing this game needs.

Again the intention of it is to raise money by putting on a quality game featuring the best players in the comp where everyone is included.

Please keep sight of that before you whinge.
I just hate that the notion of 'All Stars', as it just further feeds and reinforces the notion of Victoria, and then everyone else. It's bullshit.

If they can't make true SOO work (I apprecaite the many factors at play that may drive that), then why not just do a full All-Stars game from across the competition. The best 44 players in the comp right now, split across 2 teams, and go at it.

They won't do it, because the Victorian football media and public won't like it - but evidently it's fine for the rest of the traditional footballing states like SA and WA.
 

Crows I Am

Club Legend
Jul 12, 2006
1,120
1,340
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
North Adelaide
I just hate that the notion of 'All Stars', as it just further feeds and reinforces the notion of Victoria, and then everyone else. It's bullshit.

If they can't make true SOO work (I apprecaite the many factors at play that may drive that), then why not just do a full All-Stars game from across the competition. The best 44 players in the comp right now, split across 2 teams, and go at it.

They won't do it, because the Victorian football media and public won't like it - but evidently it's fine for the rest of the traditional footballing states like SA and WA.
That would be another good option - do an 'East' vs 'West' game. Vic/NSW/QLD/Tas vs WA/SA/NT. The east team would be dominated by Vics but would still be a few allies in there.
 

Cap

Hall of Famer
Jul 27, 2004
31,054
14,958
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Norwood
I'm more annoyed it's limited to 3.

Otherwise there would have been no chance of a crows player being in.
 
Jul 31, 2007
13,487
19,044
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Sin City Swamprats, Dethklok
Do we know where the money is going?

Quite a few of the fundraising appeals have been only for the NSW fires (some of my friends donated and then found out afterwards). Not that those ones aren't a worthy cause, but people thought they were donating towards the Cudlee Creek fire victims.
 

FR0GGY

Press the button
Oct 9, 2004
39,639
48,798
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
CDFC
Do we know where the money is going?

Quite a few of the fundraising appeals have been only for the NSW fires (some of my friends donated and then found out afterwards). Not that those ones aren't a worthy cause, but people thought they were donating towards the Cudlee Creek fire victims.
1.5mill to the Red Cross, 1 million to a regional support fund.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

BunjiMac

Norm Smith Medallist
Sep 20, 2007
5,424
7,133
AFL Club
Adelaide
I hope they raise tonnes of money, but I also hope our players aren't chosen.

It's not a real state of origin, it's more like an exhibition.

The cause is good, so hope it's financially successful, but wouldn't want our players injured as a result.

Would feel different if it was a real state of origin match.
 

AFC3000

Norm Smith Medallist
Sep 20, 2011
5,072
8,572
AFL Club
Adelaide
For charity, great, will watch and likely enjoy it so no complaints about this match.

On this concept on State of Origin...

Well, this is not State Of Origin, let's not pretend it is, I could care less about teaming up with Queensland, NSW, WA, NT and Tasmania to beat the Victorians. I'd never be passionate about this team.

If we had 3 players in the Victorian team and none in the All Stars team, I think I'd finding myself going for the Vics and supporting our players.

That said, I don't really care about the State of Origin concept at all, I have no desire to sit alongside Port supporting mates cheering on SA players from clubs I don't like playing against Crows players from other states.

We've moved on from the State vs State rivalries haven't we? Maybe it's because I just don't see one we'd win any time soon.
 

radiojake

Brownlow Medallist
Nov 28, 2011
15,460
25,303
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
LIVFC
what a joke calling this match 'State of Origin'

If they called it a charity exhibition match, then Victoria v All Stars doesn't bother me

Calling Victoria v All Stars 'State of Origin' is more disrespectful to the concept of state footy than when the Crows tried to wear the state jumper against Port
 

Jcpdragonx

Brownlow Medallist
Sep 19, 2010
11,280
11,561
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
Lakers, Chiefs
jesus SA a shit midfield.

Ebert, Neale, Hewett, Dumont (LoL) hes shit.
Massive deficiency
Redden as well, and Wingard would have to play midfield. With Grundy rucking its not that bad, but the depth would be worse than any AFL club
 

John Who

Norm Smith Medallist
Apr 16, 2017
6,349
4,369
AFL Club
Adelaide
I think people should focus on the cause for the game instead of the name being applied. Also, it might be externally a State of Origin theme, but the charity match would probably have the game mentality of an AFLX game (ie. players won’t take it full on serious leading towards the main season).

As a cause, I’m all for it.
 

Top Bottom