Having asked some questions about big comebacks on page 102 of the Stats Questions thread, I became curious about trying to make a list of the biggest comeback for each season, and seeing how far back I could go in relation to keeping the sequence of seasons consecutive.
I began by using *Paul's* well known website and used the Scoring Progression link for seasons 2008 to 2013. I then used the link for each team and looked at the instances where each team had won from particular deficits at the end of each quarter. From this, I made a shortlist of games worth researching. To further assist, I then checked with newspaper microfilm of The Age, The Sun and The Herald-Sun, as well as a few other major papers if the team making the comeback was not Melbourne based. I have also used the Greatest Comebacks section in the AFL Record; however some of my discoveries are not presently listed in the Record.
Naturally, I wanted to discover precise minute-marks of specific quarters in unearthing the biggest comeback for each season, and was fortunate to be able to do so for more seasons than I expected. On the other hand, the newspapers do not seem to have reported much data for this statistic for particular seasons. 1976 provided me with interesting reading, but 1979 gave me nothing specific. Hence, where I do not have a precise minute-mark listed I have had to assume the deficit at the break was the largest for the season. Also, sometimes I found a report which said something such as "early in the second quarter". This is true for the 1980, 1983, 1990 and 1991 comebacks, hence no specific minute-mark.
I have also included a column which lists the scores, where known, prior to the comeback. I have included 2013 in the table though of course that could change by season's end (though what a mighty comeback it would need to be). Let me know about any errors I might have posted.
Hope this preamble makes sense, and here is what I have found.
I began by using *Paul's* well known website and used the Scoring Progression link for seasons 2008 to 2013. I then used the link for each team and looked at the instances where each team had won from particular deficits at the end of each quarter. From this, I made a shortlist of games worth researching. To further assist, I then checked with newspaper microfilm of The Age, The Sun and The Herald-Sun, as well as a few other major papers if the team making the comeback was not Melbourne based. I have also used the Greatest Comebacks section in the AFL Record; however some of my discoveries are not presently listed in the Record.
Naturally, I wanted to discover precise minute-marks of specific quarters in unearthing the biggest comeback for each season, and was fortunate to be able to do so for more seasons than I expected. On the other hand, the newspapers do not seem to have reported much data for this statistic for particular seasons. 1976 provided me with interesting reading, but 1979 gave me nothing specific. Hence, where I do not have a precise minute-mark listed I have had to assume the deficit at the break was the largest for the season. Also, sometimes I found a report which said something such as "early in the second quarter". This is true for the 1980, 1983, 1990 and 1991 comebacks, hence no specific minute-mark.
I have also included a column which lists the scores, where known, prior to the comeback. I have included 2013 in the table though of course that could change by season's end (though what a mighty comeback it would need to be). Let me know about any errors I might have posted.
Hope this preamble makes sense, and here is what I have found.
Season | Round | Defecit | Time | Final scores | Scores prior to comeback | Venue |
1976 | 12 | 44 | 3rd Q (6 min) | St.K 18.14 (122) d Haw 13.19 (97) | 33-77 | Princes Park |
1977 | 9 | 47 | 4th Q (4 min) | Melb 20.12 (132) d St.K 18.19 (127) | 79-126 | Moorabbin |
1978 | 20 | 55 | 2nd Q (10 min) | Coll 19.9 (123) d Rich 16.13 (109) | 7-62 | MCG |
1979 | 16 | 36 | 1/4 time | Geel 20.9 (129) d St.K 14.20 (104) | 14-50 | Kardinia Park |
1980 | 2 | 39 | 2nd Q | Carl 14.25 (109) d Geel 15.14 (104) | ? | Princes Park |
1981 | 17 | 43 | 1st Q (23 min) | Fitz 17.14 (116) d Rich 16.19 (115) | ? | MCG |
1982 | 21 | 48 | 2nd Q (1 min) | Rich 19.13 (127) d Syd 16.14 (110) | 3-51 | SCG |
1983 | 20 | 48 | 2nd Q | Foot 19.11 (125) d Fitz 14.15 (99) | 12-60 | Western Oval |
1984 | 7 | 41 | 1/2 time | Carl 18.14 (122) d Melb 16.9 (105) | 30-71 | MCG |
1985 | 2 | 44 | 1st Q (19 min) | Foot 20.14 (134) d N.Melb 16.12 (108) | 0-44 | Waverley |
1986 | 19 | 36 | 1/2 time | Melb 18.19 (127) d Geel 17.18 (120) | 34-70 | MCG |
1987 | 4 | 51 | 3rd Q (23 min) | Coll 16.14 (110) d Rich 15.10 (100) | 41-92 | Waverley |
1988 | 5 | 43 | 2nd Q (13 min) | Bris 13.15 (93) d St.K 12.12 (84) | ? | Moorabbin |
1989 | 6 | 56 | 2nd Q (28 min) | Haw 26.15 (171) d Geel 25.13 (163) | 52-108 | Princes Park |
1990 | 15 | 50 | 2nd Q | WCE 16.12 (108) d St.K 14.6 (90) | 13-63 | WACA |
1991 | 8 | 40 | 2nd Q (25 min) | N.Melb 22.18 (150) d Geel 17.17 (119) | ? | Kardinia Park |
1992 | 6 | 47 | 4th Q (3 min) | Ess 18.16 (124) d Melb 19.9 (123) | 74-121 | MCG |
1993 | Pre | 42 | 1/2 time | Ess 17.9 (111) d Adel 14.16 (100) | 42-84 | MCG |
1994 | 7 | 51 | 3rd Q | St.K 16.14 (110) d Syd 17.7 (109) | ? | SCG |
1995 | 16 | 51 | 3rd Q (25 min) | Bris 14.20 (104) d Haw 14.13 (97) | 37-88 | Gabba |
1996 | 11 | 39 | 2nd Q (6 min) | Haw 16.12 (108) d Adel 14.15 (99) | 21-60 | Waverley |
1997 | 12 | 40 | 1/4 time | Port 14.10 (94) d WB 12.10 (82) | 10-50 | Princes Park |
1998 | 10 | 49 | 1st Q (time on) | WCE 16.17 (113) d WB 15.10 (100) | 3-52 | WACA |
1999 | 13 | 63 | 2nd Q (5 min) | Haw 17.7 (109) d St.K 14.12 (96) | 7-70 | Waverley |
2000 | 15 | 42 | 2nd Q (22 min) | WB 16.10 (106) d N.Melb 15.12 (102) | 30-72 | Docklands |
2001 | 16 | 69 | 2nd Q (10 min) | Ess 27.9 (171) d N.Melb 25.9 (159) | 22-91 | MCG |
2002 | 9 | 40 | 2nd Q (13 min) | WB 18.9 (117) d Geel 17.3 (105) | 21-61 | Kardinia Park |
2003 | 5 | 51 | 2nd Q (22 min) | Rich 18.7 (115) d Haw 14.11 (95) | 27-78 | MCG |
2004 | 6 | 40 | 2nd Q (32 min) | WB 19.6 (120) d N.Melb 18.11 (119) | 50-90 | Manuka |
19 | 40 | 4th Q (1 min) | N.Melb 17.16 (118) d Syd 18.4 (112) | 60-100 | SCG | |
2005 | 18 | 40 | 3rd Q (5 min) | N.Melb 15.10 (100) d Port 14.12 (96) | 21-61 | Manuka |
2006 | 10 | 54 | 3rd Q (18 min) | WCE 16.5 (101) d Geel 15.8 (98) | 31-85 | Kardinia Park |
2007 | 3 | 48 | 2nd Q (29 min) | Carl 18.17 (125) d Ess 17.20 (122) | 37-85 | MCG |
2008 | 7 | 51 | 3rd Q (1 min) | Melb 17.17 (119) d Fre 15.23 (113) | 26-77 | MCG |
2009 | 21 | 47 | 1st Q (31 min) | Bris 16.11 (107) d Port 14.8 (92) | 13-60 | Gabba |
2010 | 15 | 36 | 2nd Q (10 min) | Coll 16.9 (105) d Port 12.7 (79) | 9-45 | Football Park |
2011 | 5 | 40 | 3rd Q (29 min) | Gold 15.14 (104) d Port 15.11 (101) | 51-91 | Football Park |
2012 | 21 | 38 | 2nd Q (1 min) | Bris 13.17 (95) d Adel 12.13 (85) | 3-41 | Gabba |
22 | 38 | 2nd Q (14 min) | Haw 15.12 (102) d Syd 14.11 (95) | 9-47 | Gabba | |
2013 | 13 | 52 | 3rd Q (21 min) | Bris 15.13 (103) d Geel 14.14 (98) | 36-88 | Gabba |
Last edited:




