Post BF Upgrade Feedback - Click Here

Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch Steele Sidebottom

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Black_White said:
So why aren't those players being attacked/traded/hung from the nearest yardarm?
Click to expand...

I don't know, I can throw up some excuses which I don't necessarily believe in but I have heard:
  1. Sidebottom is vice-captain
  2. Sidebottom is experienced
  3. Maynard, Moore and Aish etc are inexperienced youngsters
  4. Scharenberg etc are injured
  5. the rest are shit.
 
Gone Critical said:
Reactions here way over the top. Sidey is a solid B+ mid who has a great history in finals. He is one of our better players overall.

If someone gave us a crazy trade sure take it but thats unlikely. There is no way you are getting a top 10 draft pick for a 26 yo in his 9th season who has had a solid career. He also comes with a solid contract out to 2021 which makes any trade more difficult

Baby, bathwater.
Click to expand...

Yep, decision made. We aren't playing finals for 5 years so better use to give him up to a side that will be and that can't hurt us. Jk
 
Collingwoodity said:
I don't know, I can throw up some excuses which I don't necessarily believe in but I have heard:
  1. Sidebottom is vice-captain Didn't know Sidey was self appointed
  2. Sidebottom is experienced but not seriously coached in the last 5 years
  3. Maynard, Moore and Aish etc are inexperienced youngsters poor buggers. What a future they have.....
  4. Scharenberg etc are injured 2-3 weeks surely!
  5. the rest are shit. Bloody Hine
Click to expand...
 
sideswipe said:
I heard there was some AFL club that recently signed a 27 year old to a 4 year deal and he is now battling in their reserves. Maybe we should see if those dumb shits will take any of our crap players (Sidey isn't one). Sounds like they will buy anything.
Click to expand...
Lol. Gold.

So sad we've become the butt of jokes like this.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

loki04 said:
Honestly you can't keep trading heart and soul players out and then ask for loyalty from the ones who remain. Sidebottom is a Collingwood man and unless he wants out should remain so, we have traded away too many players since Bucks took over imo.
Click to expand...
Nothing truer
 
Gone Critical said:
Reactions here way over the top. Sidey is a solid B+ mid who has a great history in finals. He is one of our better players overall.

If someone gave us a crazy trade sure take it but thats unlikely. There is no way you are getting a top 10 draft pick for a 26 yo in his 9th season who has had a solid career. He also comes with a solid contract out to 2021 which makes any trade more difficult

Baby, bathwater.
Click to expand...
Agree.
A really good B + player.
And terrific in the bigger games.
His stand out attribute (which people seem to forget) is elite running.

Up and down, up and down, gets to the contest, gets to the ball.
And people want to move him on? That's perplexing to say the least.

Also I think it's surprising that anyone would suggest if we wanted to move him on at this stage they'd hand over a top 10 pick? Just won't happen.

We have him, he has seniority, runs and runs, can kick a goal (that's a bit forgotten)
His value is there for us.

Far better to move on the average talent.

(Ps somebody gives a top draft pick, then sure let's look at it. BUT it's not going to happen)
 
Kappa said:
The most overrated player in modern Collingwood history.

His defensive efforts are child-like, his kicking is crap, has no idea how to weight his kicks.. half the time they land a metre short... he doesn't get ANY hard ball... just a weak outside mid with no hurt factor and no defensive efforts.

Pack him up at the end of the year and pray someone is stupid enough to give us a late 1st round pick for him.
Click to expand...

The question is, have you got the plumbs to admit you got this wrong?
 
Kappa said:
Agreed, 1 good game and suddenly a player over his career is no longer overrated and he's actually an A grade superstar... right?

Or do I bump this thread next time he has a poor game and ask you to admit you're wrong.
Click to expand...

Just what I thought :rolleyes:
 

Remove this Banner Ad

ThexderX said:
Ha ha there it is...he pulls a half good game our with a freakish goal and out come the Sidey is elite folk.

You forget his 8 bad games leading up to his one ok game.
Click to expand...
8 bad games?
Really?
According to our BF experts he's our 2nd best player in 2017.
https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/2017-didaka-medal-leaderboard.1161020/
And I'm sure the real experts vote in a similar way.
Care to elaborate on your last 8 games before yesterdays?
Because you appear to have nfi.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Black_White said:
8 bad games?
Really?
According to our BF experts he's our 2nd best player in 2017.
https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/2017-didaka-medal-leaderboard.1161020/
And I'm sure the real experts vote in a similar way.
Care to elaborate on your last 8 games before yesterdays?
Because you appear to have nfi.
Click to expand...
2nd best players in the our side is not something to be proud of.

If you really think he has been our second best player then you're delusional.

He's been consistently average, even poor at times.
 
ThexderX said:
2nd best players in the our side is not something to be proud of.

If you really think he has been our second best player then you're delusional.

He's been consistently average, even poor at times.
Click to expand...
Not something to be proud of?
Well that sums up exactly where you are coming from.
Tell me who has been better in our side this year.
 
Black_White said:
Not something to be proud of?
Well that sums up exactly where you are coming from.
Tell me who has been better in our side this year.
Click to expand...
Forget stats and Supercoach points, because they are junk, but here are a few names that I believe have been better and had more impact on games, not just cheap touches.

Treloar
Pendles
Grundy
Adams
Varcoe
Howe
Reid
Dunn (for the games he has played)

The fact there aren't more names ahead of him is testament to where we are on the ladder...3rd last (probably 2nd last by the end of the round).

For some reason Sidebottom seems to get a free pass by most supporters and media - he is horribly overrated.

Sidebottom is the epitomy of our team - most others have simply gone past him/us and live off past glory.
 
I'll give you Grundy.
Though if you actually watch the games you may see he is the king of the turnovers.
Treloar? Been dissapointing really, and hasn't played all games.
Pendles? Are you reading the posts? He is voted ahead of Sidebottom as you would see if you looked at the votes, so not sure why you have included him.
Adams, Varcoe, Howe. Flashes. In and out of the play. Pop up, go missing, time and time again. Howe the best of those three, simply because he doesn't need to hunt his own ball, the ball finds him due to our leaking forward defence.

You're having a laugh naming the rest.
 
Kappa said:
Yea, you thought 1 good game should completely change how his career should be viewed :rolleyes: Typical Bigfooty genius
Click to expand...
Or one bad game?
Obvious troll is obvious.
You and TG are the most embarrassing posters on any Magpie board.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

TradeDraft
    • Like
    • Haha
Player Watch Roan Steele
10 11 12 13 14
Replies
339
Views
23K
Ludovico
Ludovico

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom