Wow that list would just make Geelong deliver a package into their pants wouldn't it? Out of that list only Palmer and Hasleby have good statistics to prove they win the ball a lot.
Selwood, Ablet, Bartel, Kelly, Ling, Corey all average over 20 disposals a game, we only have 2 players in our midfield that do that. They have 6.
Schammer, our 3rd best midfielder averages 16 disposals, in comparison someone like Chapman for Geelong who is a forward averages 17 and a lot more goals.
You cant even bother comparing statistics over the careers of our players to Geelongs, the only one with the experience of these guys on our midfield list is Hase and possibly Schammer but he hasn't played his entire career as a midfielder.
Here are reason why:
Palmer - 1 season, hardly a fair comparison.
Hill - 2 games, hardly a fair comparison.
Suban - 2 games, hardly a fair comparison.
Ibbo - 1 full season, hardly a fair comparison.
Crowley - granted, doesnt get the ball as much as we would like.
Mundy - played majority of his career on a HBF until this season, possessions not at a premium there.
Hinkley - played less than 10 games.
What you need to realise is that all of our decent midfield options have played less then 25 games bar Hase, Scham and Crowls.
Ablett, Bartel, Kelly, Corey etc were not superstars before they played 25 games.
Dont expect these guys to be in the same level as the Cats because it ain't going to happy. Probably not ever, but bear in mind this Geelong midfield in probably in the top 3 midfields the competition has ever seen.