Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Doesn't Buddha have a potential father son coming thorough? If so this makes that al a lot easier to manage...
Buddha is not smart enough for the job, sorry.
Mackie would be good with a bit of experience under his belt-he is a smart cookie. So would Lonergan actually. Solid guys.
Haha yep-that is exactly what I am basing it on. Have seen more that enough to conclude that Mackie is a very cluey guy. Have you seen him interviewed etc-he is way ahead of Chappy and Buddha for mine in terms of 'intellectual depth'. And Buddha is a step back in time. Fresh, young blood for mine is needed these days. Lonergan seems like a seriously level-headed person with plenty of brains.Not being a smart arse here - but have you ever had an in Depth conversation with either Mackie or Lonergan? Or are you making this assumption based on a career of 45
Second interviews?
Haha yep-that is exactly what I am basing it on. Have seen more that enough to conclude that Mackie is a very cluey guy. Have you seen him interviewed etc-he is way ahead of Chappy and Buddha for mine in terms of 'intellectual depth'. Lonergan seems like a seriously level-headed person with plenty of brains.
Happy to be corrected.
Ha-yep good point. Of course those South Australians all come from good stock don't they? Settled by civilised types! Not like the convict stock of Geelong!Mackie is from South Australia.
The club has to draw the line somewhere.
Would Rosie King come back to take over from Cook?
Has now had CEO experience with an outside organisation with Netball Vic.
Or could Stuart Fox be teased out of the MCC gig or is that too much of a cushy job?
That was exactly the first thought that came to my mind. Reverse bias...Do you really think we will be better for this...its more likely he will be like Ling and his commentary. He will slant him self to be obvious in non bias
Won't happen, but I'd love to see Grant Thomas sounded out for the role. He had his flaws as a coach, particularly on the tactical side, but it seems to me he was excellent at building relationships with players, and also the development side of coaching (both personal and football). More importantly, he was somewhat of a trailblazer for the modern footy manager. At StKilda, he not only coached, but he handled contracts, TPP, actively engaged in recruiting, and was groundbreaking in training initiatives, such as overseas camps. He certainly overextended himself in those days, but looking back, he really was a trailblazer in many respects and exposed himself to a range of football skills. It may not be a popular view on here, but I also see him as a person of character. Unlike many, I feel he parks his bias and gives unconflicted opinions on the footy. Further, his opinions seem to indicate he has a respect for Chris Scott. He's a straight-shooter who calls out the AFL boys club for what it is. This has made him an outsider, but with our man now "inside" the tent we shouldn't fear any repercussions. I think Grant Thomas really would have so much to offer in a footy role at clubland.
What I suspect is every chance of happening though is Simon Lethlean. Mates with Gill and Chris Scott, second chance in a forgiving industry. All fits nicely.
Not thrilled with the idea of Simon Lethlean - do we really need that sort of cultural influence around the club?
Won't happen, but I'd love to see Grant Thomas sounded out for the role. He had his flaws as a coach, particularly on the tactical side, but it seems to me he was excellent at building relationships with players, and also the development side of coaching (both personal and football). More importantly, he was somewhat of a trailblazer for the modern footy manager. At StKilda, he not only coached, but he handled contracts, TPP, actively engaged in recruiting, and was groundbreaking in training initiatives, such as overseas camps. He certainly overextended himself in those days, but looking back, he really was a trailblazer in many respects and exposed himself to a range of football skills. It may not be a popular view on here, but I also see him as a person of character. Unlike many, I feel he parks his bias and gives unconflicted opinions on the footy. Further, his opinions seem to indicate he has a respect for Chris Scott. He's a straight-shooter who calls out the AFL boys club for what it is. This has made him an outsider, but with our man now "inside" the tent we shouldn't fear any repercussions. I think Grant Thomas really would have so much to offer in a footy role at clubland.
What I suspect is every chance of happening though is Simon Lethlean. Mates with Gill and Chris Scott, second chance in a forgiving industry. All fits nicely.
When was the last time Grant Thomas worked at an AFL club?Grant Thomas would be perfect. Good thinking, zb!
Not thrilled with the idea of Simon Lethlean - do we really need that sort of cultural influence around the club?
When was the last time Grant Thomas worked at an AFL club?
I feel a bit sorry for him - he looked like he was paranoid spouting off in the media. Turns out he was 100% right.Hasn't had any role since sacked as coach in 06 I think it was?
I feel a bit sorry for him - he looked like he was paranoid spouting off in the media. Turns out he was 100% right.
Geez you are lazy. All I said is I'm glad he's gone.Like I said the onus is on you.
Wonder who will be in line to replace him?
BUDDHA.Time to get Buddha back to the club?
Gary Hocking
Buddha is not smart enough for the job, sorry.
Mackie would be good with a bit of experience under his belt-he is a smart cookie. So would Lonergan actually. Solid guys.
Haha. That last line nails it.I honestly don't/didn't have a great enough understanding of his role to know if he was good bad or otherwise, which is what I suspect most people here are also like.. but we just assume he was good as he was ours.
So if he was going great then I hope we find an good replacement, and if he wasn't that great then I hope we find a better replacement.
I am not certain it changes things for us fans really at all though.. just a different person to blame when we aren't happy