Struzyna & Doecke 2024 Phantom Draft Edition.

[I Wouldnt But Greenwood]

Welcome to Ian Struzyna & Dylan Doecke 2024 Phantom Draft. We break down all predicted pick trades & matched bids.

(I am aware we are missing later picks. I will clean this up & update by Wednesday.)

 

[THE_GUN]

Welcome to Ian Struzyna & Dylan Doecke 2024 Phantom Draft. We break down all predicted pick trades & matched bids.

Think you might be a little bit Bias thinking Richmond trade #11 for Norths F1
Very doubtful any pick prior to #18 gets traded into future picks

But good effort with the selections

 

[I Wouldnt But Greenwood]

Think you might be a little bit Bias thinking Richmond trade #11 for Norths F1
Very doubtful any pick prior to #18 gets traded into future picks

But good effort with the selections

My Fremantle mate made that trade & pick, as he thinks Richmond can get a Key Position player later in the draft & get two top 5 picks next year!
I appreciate the feedback, more is welcome.

 

[CDC60]

Adelaide don't have a F2 and they don't have Pick 57 in this draft ether. You traded Pick 64 as part of the deal for P2

 

[RUNVS]

Welcome to Ian Struzyna & Dylan Doecke 2024 Phantom Draft. We break down all predicted pick trades & matched bids.

How dare you pick players A and B for the Swans, when clearly the Swans need players C and X much more. You sir are a liar and a fraud. Good day to you.

 

[I Wouldnt But Greenwood]

How dare you pick players A and B for the Swans, when clearly the Swans need players C and X much more. You sir are a liar and a fraud. Good day to you.

Hahaha I have been exposed!!!

 

[I Wouldnt But Greenwood]

Adelaide don't have a F2 and they don't have Pick 57 in this draft ether. You traded Pick 64 as part of the deal for P2

Adelaides pick 64 will come into pick 57. I should of double checked Adelaides Future picks, thanks for the heads up I will correct it.

 

[CDC60]

Adelaides pick 64 will come into pick 57. I should of double checked Adelaides Future picks, thanks for the heads up I will correct it.

But you traded 64.

 

[Moonatic77]

Think you might be a little bit Bias thinking Richmond trade #11 for Norths F1
Very doubtful any pick prior to #18 gets traded into future picks

But good effort with the selections

Would be pretty ok if that happened

 

[Johnny Bananas]

Adelaide don't have a F2 and they don't have Pick 57 in this draft ether. You traded Pick 64 as part of the deal for P2

According to the rumours they're trying to acquire a F2 to move up. Those same rumours say they're moving up for Jagga though.

 

[Johnny Bananas]

Freo taking Gerreyn is curious, I thought they were well stocked for tall forwards and trucks.

 

[I Wouldnt But Greenwood]

But you traded 64.

Yes I did…. Thanks mate, thought there may have been a mistake within this draft. I’ll correct this when I am on my laptop.

 

[Addy23]

Welcome to Ian Struzyna & Dylan Doecke 2024 Phantom Draft. We break down all predicted pick trades & matched bids.

Good work mate! Would be thrilled if Shanahan got to Port.

P.S think you've made a small mistake in the heights of Dattoli and Hynes

 

[Chip Scab1]

Would be pretty ok if that happened

Surely won't happen for anything less than #5 (which it will be next year). I understand Richmond won't do it, and neither should we. I'd be more interested in our 2 & 2024 R3 (39 before bids) for Essendon's 2x2025 R1 + 28, 31.

I don't understand why that isn't being discussed.

 

[LB2Snake]

Would be pretty ok if that happened

I think something like it is a possibility. Pick 18 for norths F1 would be madness by North. Who knows, but just can’t see it.

 

[I Wouldnt But Greenwood]

Good work mate! Would be thrilled if Shanahan got to Port.

P.S think you've made a small mistake in the heights of Dattoli and Hynes

That you are right sir haha, thank you I shall correct!

 

[THE_GUN]

Surely won't happen for anything less than #5 (which it will be next year). I understand Richmond won't do it, and neither should we. I'd be more interested in our 2 & 2024 R3 (39 before bids) for Essendon's 2x2025 R1 + 28, 31.

I don't understand why that isn't being discussed.

You are extremely optimistic with your expectation

So North out : #2 + F3 (which is not worth anything really)
North in : Essendon F1 , Melbourne F1 , #28 , #31

NO CHANCE

 

[Chip Scab1]

You are extremely optimistic with your expectation

So North out : #2 + F3 (which is not worth anything really)
North in : Essendon F1 , Melbourne F1 , #28 , #31

NO CHANCE

Which is ok, completely understand. But, you'll have to have another go at the output, this time with some reality thrown in for good measure. Hope you don't mind my attempt at that.

Out North and In Essington: O'Sullivan (2) and (40ish), Kako (not bid on where it would hurt).

In North, Out Essington: Essendon F1 (12ish), Melbourne (14ish), 28 (35ish), 31(39ish)

Is it so in our favour now once you add in the dose of realism?

 

[sydney_gws]

You are extremely optimistic with your expectation

So North out : #2 + F3 (which is not worth anything really)
North in : Essendon F1 , Melbourne F1 , #28 , #31

NO CHANCE

The problem is essendon with 2,kako and Melbourne with 5,9 both might improve ( but more likely 2026 not 2025). Other than that, is this trade too much in favour of North that essendon won't consider it?

 

[LB2Snake]

The problem is essendon with 2,kako and Melbourne with 5,9 both might improve ( but more likely 2026 not 2025). Other than that, is this trade too much in favour of North that essendon won't consider it?

As a north supporter I have so little interest in that trade. What am I missing?

 

[Chip Scab1]

As a north supporter I have so little interest in that trade. What am I missing?

Hannaford & Gerreyn (Maybe) on top of 3x R1's next season. With one being Ludowycke and other holes we do have. Time to see/use what we have and further develop Goad, WDawson, Goater and Duursma and Hardeman.

 

[LB2Snake]

Hannaford & Gerreyn (Maybe) on top of 3x R1's next season. With one being Ludowycke and other holes we do have. Time to see/use what we have and further develop Goad, WDawson, Goater and Duursma and Hardeman.

I thought the draft was deep, not as elite as normal at top end though.
4 good picks for 1, including a chance of gett

But they are all “maybe” picks and scenarios. There’s a reason why Bombres would want to do what they are doing, in this hypothetical.
Top 2 players/talent are hard to come by. It’s your stars than win you games. The role players are massively important, but the real deal blokes are the ones that win premierships.

 

[THE_GUN]

Which is ok, completely understand. But, you'll have to have another go at the output, this time with some reality thrown in for good measure. Hope you don't mind my attempt at that.

Out North and In Essington: O'Sullivan (2) and (40ish), Kako (not bid on where it would hurt).

In North, Out Essington: Essendon F1 (12ish), Melbourne (14ish), 28 (35ish), 31(39ish)

Is it so in our favour now once you add in the dose of realism?

Yeah Nah

40 ish in a bad draft
Kako is already theirs
FOS is not worth 2 1st rounders in any draft he might even not be 2nd best in this years draft
Essendon will be bottom 6 next year and Melbourne could be holding their hand

Could look something like for north
Out : #FOS
In : #4 , #5 , #28 , #31