Discussion Supercoach DRAFT 2017 - Discussion thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Here2tellyouwhy

SA GREAT
Sep 3, 2005
28,044
71,000
Adelaide
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
West Coast Eagles
Here's our full draft - 8 teams with 22 person squads. 2 rounds linear, rest snake order.

Pretty experienced league, this is our 5th year.

Thoughts on best/worst teams & how I drafted (team 2)?

View attachment 347327

I can share my pre-Draft notes/research if anyone's interest, but I think everyone would of drafted by now. My notes pretty much ordered my top 180 players based on last years average, JLT performance, position, potential breakouts + returning Essendon players.

I only did 5-6 hours of research, but I felt incredibly confident during the process and felt like I drafted very well because of the prep - only regret is picking Stevens way early. Anyway, felt much better than last year... going in with no prep and no notes haha
LOL
Wingard at 54 Nroo at 56 :drunk:
 

Gerald Preston

Club Legend
Jul 15, 2013
1,100
1,006
Twiggys Dance Club
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Arsenal FC
Had mates over and we selected 8 teams of 22 (old school with a whiteboard) no lap tops etc.......Now I want to enter all the teams properly online........can someone please explain the Live draft one computer/offline selections.......do I just get all of them to sign up and join the league and then I can select all the players for each team from my computer? Cheers in advance!!!!
 

Golden_6

Premiership Player
Aug 15, 2014
3,960
6,504
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Other Teams
Chicago Bulls
Thoughts on the team? Little weaker in defence but loaded midfield
8 team, 15 a side:
Backs: Z Williams, Montagna, Hibberd Macmillan (K Kolo)
Mids: JPK, Trealor, Bont, Rockliff, Viney (Coniglio, Ross, J Kelly
Ruck: Hickey
Forwards: Dahlhaus, Gunston, J Riewoldt T Lynch (Billings)
 

zannnn

Debutant
May 12, 2012
145
72
Melbourne
AFL Club
Essendon
Had mates over and we selected 8 teams of 22 (old school with a whiteboard) no lap tops etc.......Now I want to enter all the teams properly online........can someone please explain the Live draft one computer/offline selections.......do I just get all of them to sign up and join the league and then I can select all the players for each team from my computer? Cheers in advance!!!!
I'm pretty sure that's what needs to happen. We sign up to the league and post-draft our commisioner goes online and manually creates each of the teams for us (by selecting the picks in draft order).
 

pattycripps

Draftee
Aug 3, 2015
6
1
AFL Club
Carlton
Here's our full draft - 8 teams with 22 person squads. 2 rounds linear, rest snake order.

Pretty experienced league, this is our 5th year.

Thoughts on best/worst teams & how I drafted (team 2)?

View attachment 347327

I can share my pre-Draft notes/research if anyone's interest, but I think everyone would of drafted by now. My notes pretty much ordered my top 180 players based on last years average, JLT performance, position, potential breakouts + returning Essendon players.

I only did 5-6 hours of research, but I felt incredibly confident during the process and felt like I drafted very well because of the prep - only regret is picking Stevens way early. Anyway, felt much better than last year... going in with no prep and no notes haha
hey zannnn mate i got my draft tomorrow and never done draft before. would love your notes if you are willing to share? thanks man. let me know
 

zannnn

Debutant
May 12, 2012
145
72
Melbourne
AFL Club
Essendon
hey zannnn mate i got my draft tomorrow and never done draft before. would love your notes if you are willing to share? thanks man. let me know
Hopefully not too late.

https://www.dropbox.com/s/6hii95we53d5fqy/draft cheat sheet.xlsx?dl=0

The structure of my spreadsheet is as follows: The first tab I spent the most time ordering top 56 players - red text players are injured. The next tab is the top 57-180 - didnt spend as much time as I would of liked so theres a few players that should be moved around and maybe a few missing. Green players are players I liked and moved up a fair bit. These are the only two tabs that I really looked at when doing the live draft.

The next few tabs are just further references for each possie. Injuries was a manual list from articles I read but AFL have since posted the injury list on their website. Last 3 tabs are just data sources.

Hopefully you find my analysis useful (first 2 tabs), if not, its just a spreadsheet with player averages, JLT scores etc. that still may be of some use.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

pattycripps

Draftee
Aug 3, 2015
6
1
AFL Club
Carlton
Hopefully not too late.

https://www.dropbox.com/s/6hii95we53d5fqy/draft cheat sheet.xlsx?dl=0

The structure of my spreadsheet is as follows: The first tab I spent the most time ordering top 56 players - red text players are injured. The next tab is the top 57-180 - didnt spend as much time as I would of liked so theres a few players that should be moved around and maybe a few missing. Green players are players I liked and moved up a fair bit. These are the only two tabs that I really looked at when doing the live draft.

The next few tabs are just further references for each possie. Injuries was a manual list from articles I read but AFL have since posted the injury list on their website. Last 3 tabs are just data sources.

Hopefully you find my analysis useful (first 2 tabs), if not, its just a spreadsheet with player averages, JLT scores etc. that still may be of some use.
you are a legend. thanks so much
 

zannnn

Debutant
May 12, 2012
145
72
Melbourne
AFL Club
Essendon
you are a legend. thanks so much
No worries. Just take caution with picks and use some discretion - the list isnt perfect with a few mistakes e.g. Stevens is pretty high and i think i just heard hes not playing rnd1. At work now so cant do a thorough look at the list. Good luck

Edit: sorry to the guys that sent me private messages for my notes throughout the week, i didnt check my PMs and missed them.
 
Last edited:

Armitage2Riewoldt

Moderator
May 23, 2008
14,479
12,306
Melbourne
AFL Club
St Kilda
6 players. 14 on the field. 5 on the bench. Some interesting results, I was team 4. How'd I go?

upload_2017-3-22_21-33-33.png


The uh first JK was a mistake :p And a lot more Forwards, Rucks and defenders went in the top 20 than I had planned for. So my midfield got pretty stacked pretty quickly. Rest of the field suffered a little but I'm happy to grab Rance, Gunston, Tuohy and Rioli late. Purposely left rucks til last cos I figured I was gonna get a pretty decent one anyway.
 

brentman

Team Captain
Sep 10, 2014
425
142
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
Newcastle United
I took Wallis in the draft without realising he would miss the first half of the season, think he is worth holding on to?
replacements include:
Carlisle
Jamie Elliott (only out for 1-2 weeks)
Hrovat
De Goey (6 weeks)
Cloke
B Hill
Hopper
Vickert
Crameri
Membery
Jong
Tomahawk
Lobb
C Cameron
Petrie
Bell
 

just signed

Debutant
Oct 30, 2005
124
24
Melbourne
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
CARLTON
How high do people think Ablett should go?

6 players. 14 on the field. 5 on the bench. Some interesting results, I was team 4. How'd I go?

View attachment 348504

The uh first JK was a mistake :p And a lot more Forwards, Rucks and defenders went in the top 20 than I had planned for. So my midfield got pretty stacked pretty quickly. Rest of the field suffered a little but I'm happy to grab Rance, Gunston, Tuohy and Rioli late. Purposely left rucks til last cos I figured I was gonna get a pretty decent one anyway.[/QUOTE
 

Gerald Preston

Club Legend
Jul 15, 2013
1,100
1,006
Twiggys Dance Club
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Arsenal FC
Noob draft question, I had Pittard but traded him........now I want to get him back and it seems I have to go through Waiver wire? Can someone please explain how I can get him? I'm currently 4th on the list? I have nfi :/........do the three people above me on the list get a day to steal him?
 

toxic

Hall of Famer
Day Off
May 9, 2008
36,622
47,681
GONE
AFL Club
Collingwood
Noob draft question, I had Pittard but traded him........now I want to get him back and it seems I have to go through Waiver wire? Can someone please explain how I can get him? I'm currently 4th on the list? I have nfi :/........do the three people above me on the list get a day to steal him?
Yes they do.

Wait till very last minute to trade for him. Anything earlier alerts those who mite have forgotten about him
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Top Bottom