Supercoach DRAFT - Discussion thread

[Judd2Sewell]

If you mean Patty - he got picked up later. I couldn't be bothered putting every selections up last night.

 

[cdcanman]

That's because you were the only one paying attention to the waiver wire

That's right, because I was the best player in our league last year.

its easy when you're playing on your own!!

Exactly, I was the best coach because I paid attention to my team all year, just like in regular SC. Just because you didn't, doesn't necessarily mean that you or any one else would have beaten me. Coulda, shoulda, didn't.

Oh....it's on now!!!

It's kinda like Mummy and Daddy fighting, only weirder

Wager? I'm sensing wager.
Weekly thread discussing wager?

 

[Krujan]

It's kinda like Mummy and Daddy fighting, only weirder

Wager? I'm sensing wager.
Weekly thread discussing wager?

In a SC sense, Kadog and I are very much alike. Last year we were in a few leagues together and never had more than 4 or 5 POD's between us and traded wins all year. This SC Draft League will no doubt sort out the wheat from the chaff.

 

[Kadog]

In a SC sense, Kadog and I are very much alike. Last year we were in a few leagues together and never had more than 4 or 5 POD's between us and traded wins all year. This SC Draft League will no doubt sort out the wheat from the chaff.

If I win I get $150. If you win you get $50! LOL

 

[Chester89]

Just did our draft this afternoon:

Top 10:

Spoiler

SSB 1) Goldy
NN 2) Fyfe
B 3) Ablett
DB 4) Danger
DH 5) Pendles
M 6) Hannebery
TB 7) Jacobs
MF 8) Gray
KHASB 9) Priddis
LPO 10) Deledio

11 to 20:

Spoiler

LPO 11) Swan
KHASB 12) D. Martin
MF 13) S. Martin
TB 14) Mummy (yes, he took two rucks with his first two - couldn't log back and it auto picked)
M 15) Selwood
DH 16) Shaw
DB 17) Beams
B 18) Mitchell
NN 19) Dahlhaus
SSB 20) JPK

21 to 30:

Spoiler

SSB 21) The Bont
NN 22) McVeigh
B 23) Ward
DB 24) Sloane
DH 25) Rockliff
M 26) Montagna
TB 27) Mundy
MF 28) Boyd
KHASB 29) Treloar
LPO 30) Sandilands

31 to 40:

Spoiler

LPO 31) Armitage
KHASB 32) NicNat
MF 33) Neale
TB 34) Hodge
M 35) Houli
DH 36) Bennell
DB 37) Gawn
B 38) Maric
NN 39) Parker
SSB 40) Rance

41 to 50:

Spoiler

SSB 41) Hartlett
NN 42) Wingard
B 43) M. Murphy
DB 44) Macdonald
DH 45) Libba
M 46) Ellis
TB 47) T. Mitchell
MF 48) Zorko
KHASB 49) Steven
LPO 50) R. Murphy

51 to 60:

Spoiler

LPO 51) J. Bartel
KHASB 52) Enright
MF 53) Gaff
TB 54) D. Shiel
M 55) Gunston
DH 56) Franklin
DB 57) Sidebottom
B 58) Laird
NN 59) Barlow
SSB 60) K. K.

61 to 70:

Spoiler

SSB 61) S. Gray
NN 62) Wines
B 63) Rioli
DB 64) Goddard
DH 65) Franklin
M 66) Simpson
TB 67) D. Smith
MF 68) Motlop
KHASB 69) J. Reiwoldt
LPO 70) J. Gibson

Finished up with:

Spoiler

D - McVeigh, Langdon, Yeo, Johanneson

M - Fyfe, Parker, Wines, Cotchin, Prestia

R - Lobbe

F - Dahlhaus, Wingard, Barlow, Hall

Bench - Malceski, Hanley, Viney, Palmer, Vandenberg

Wow rocky at 25 is crazy he should be 5 or 6

 

[Better Loosen Up]

I am playing this for the first time this year and supposedly have the draft starting at 9pm tonight.

Thing is, I see you guys talking about what picks you have prior to the draft starting and can't work this out for the life of me where to find this.

Any help would be appreciated

 

[Judd2Sewell]

I am playing this for the first time this year and supposedly have the draft starting at 9pm tonight.

Thing is, I see you guys talking about what picks you have prior to the draft starting and can't work this out for the life of me where to find this.

Any help would be appreciated

Your league should have set it up, are you doing it with mates?

Some leagues don't work out the draft order until right before the draft so you can't really plan. Sounds like that's what's happening?

 

[brentman]

Anyone know where i can find a good page where people have shared all their drafts? footyprophet is good but they seem to focus on UF.

Side note - noticed Heater going outside of the top 10 in most of these drafts, if he maintains last years performance he should be top 5 for mosts drafts (depending on the team structure of your league). Positional scarcity regarding defenders is at an all time high and he is well up there as a result.

 

[NSWCROW]

I've never done SC DRAFT before but i'm keen to try this year if anyone knows a league ??

 

[Krujan]

Anyone know where i can find a good page where people have shared all their drafts? footyprophet is good but they seem to focus on UF.

Side note - noticed Heater going outside of the top 10 in most of these drafts, if he maintains last years performance he should be top 5 for mosts drafts (depending on the team structure of your league). Positional scarcity regarding defenders is at an all time high and he is well up there as a result.

Heater was 6th for overall points last year. Absolute gold as far as SC Draft goes. I was lucky enough to draft him with my 4th or 5th round pick though. I'd seriously consider him with my 1st pick this year if it's any lower than a top 5 pick.

 

[Judd2Sewell]

What do you reckon, I'm offering up:

Fyfe (M1) and A. Hall (F4)
for:
D. Martin (F1) and A. Treloar (M3)

Currently my midfield is:
Fyfe
Parker
Wines
Prestia
Cotchin

Forwards:
Dahlhaus
Wingard
Barlow
Hall

 

[brentman]

What do you reckon, I'm offering up:

Fyfe (M1) and A. Hall (F4)
for:
D. Martin (F1) and A. Treloar (M3)

Currently my midfield is:
Fyfe
Parker
Wines
Prestia
Cotchin

Forwards:
Dahlhaus
Wingard
Barlow
Hall

I like it.
Im not as bullish as others on Hall, too much of a yo-yo for h2h leagues. Hall and Fyfe are also less durable than Dusty and Treloar.
I see it as:
125 avg + 85 avg
for
105 avg + 110 avg

 

[brentman]

Heater was 6th for overall points last year. Absolute gold as far as SC Draft goes. I was lucky enough to draft him with my 4th or 5th round pick though. I'd seriously consider him with my 1st pick this year if it's any lower than a top 5 pick.

100%, i'd go so far as to say he should be a lock for a top 5 pick.
Only reason i wouldnt is because others seem to undervalue him, therefore there may be a chance that he'll slip through to the 2nd rd where i could pick him up.

 

[brentman]

Wow rocky at 25 is crazy he should be 5 or 6

So many crazy picks in that draft to mention, wouldnt know where to start.

 

[Judd2Sewell]

I like it.
Im not as bullish as others on Hall, too much of a yo-yo for h2h leagues. Hall and Fyfe are also less durable than Dusty and Treloar.
I see it as:
125 avg + 85 avg
for
105 avg + 110 avg

Exactly what I was thinking. I hope Dusty can take the next step too and reach 110.

With Dusty in I will have 4 of the top 8 forwards - Deledio, Martin, Dahlhaus, Montagna, Wingard, Barlow, Roughead (when fully fit) and Bennell. With Wingard being the weakest link.

 

[Judd2Sewell]

So many crazy picks in that draft to mention, wouldnt know where to start.

Pray tell? I'm interested to hear what people think.

 

[Big Sauce 21]

Wow rocky at 25 is crazy he should be 5 or 6

Swan, McVeigh, Dahlhaus

 

[10571z]

Had my draft went Ablett at #2. Risky but if he gets back close to his best and stays injury free itll be worth it

We have waivers off but does anyone know if its possible to have players go straight into freeagency instead of having to wait a few days? It says they will be released at 12pm wednesday

 

[gothedons]

Had my draft went Ablett at #2. Risky but if he gets back close to his best and stays injury free itll be worth it

We have waivers off but does anyone know if its possible to have players go straight into freeagency instead of having to wait a few days? It says they will be released at 12pm wednesday

can you post some of your draft order... have mine sunday and need to get more gauge on how others rate positional players!

 

[brentman]

Pray tell? I'm interested to hear what people think.

Swan @ 11 - Way too high
Shaw @ 16 - Too low
Smitchell @ 18 - Way too high
Ward @ 23 - Too high
Bont @ 21 - Too high
Sandi @ 30 - Too high
Parker @ 39 - too low
Hartlett @ 41 - Way too high
Shiel @ 54 - Way too low
Laird @ 58 - way too low
Sidebottom @ 57 - way too low
Barlow @ 59 - Way too low

 

[10571z]

Swan @ 11 - Way too high
Shaw @ 16 - Too low
Smitchell @ 18 - Way too high
Ward @ 23 - Too high
Bont @ 21 - Too high
Sandi @ 30 - Too high
Parker @ 39 - too low
Hartlett @ 41 - Way too high
Shiel @ 54 - Way too low
Laird @ 58 - way too low
Sidebottom @ 57 - way too low
Barlow @ 59 - Way too low

Sidey went before 25 in our league. Shaw went after 16 people are always keen to pick up a mid first

 

[brentman]

Sidey went before 25 in our league. Shaw went after 16 people are always keen to pick up a mid first

Only time it can make sense to pick up a mid very early is if you play with captains.
We dont play with captains because it distorts the importance of early draft picks.
Most in our league undervalue non-mids. Based on last years results, with our league structure (8 teams, 22 players), the most valuable player was Shaw, followed closely by Goldy.

 

[hendo8888]

Only time it can make sense to pick up a mid very early is if you play with captains.
We dont play with captains because it distorts the importance of early draft picks.
Most in our league undervalue non-mids. Based on last years results, with our league structure (8 teams, 22 players), the most valuable player was Shaw, followed closely by Goldy.

Yeah, if I had pick 3, I'd take whichever of Goldy, Shaw or DMartin is available. In that order.

 

[Hawks92]

Rockliff goes first round surely! I'll be ecstatic if I get him at 8

 

[10571z]

Best roughies who had low scores... Gibbs, Hanley, hall, crouch