SuperCoach Regrets thread

[Adz]

Broughton WTF - def a trade this week.

 

[Temploar]

Not a regret but glad i picked Shaw over Broughton this week otherwise i would have regretted it.

 

[Chronz]

Ugh, Broughton not playing midfield. What the **** Lyon you dog.

 

[scyth]

broughton. yargh.

zaka gave me a scare, but he came good in the end. still might replace him with ryder. weeks ago i was set on stanton instead of watson, too.

 

[pulpdriver]

Ugh, Broughton not playing midfield. What the **** Lyon you dog.

The ball was down in defence plenty during the 2nd half. Broughton just didn't get near it. I thought he was very, very average tonight.

 

[Adz]

The ball was down in defence plenty during the 2nd half. Broughton just didn't get near it. I thought he was very, very average tonight.

Will you be trading him?

 

[pulpdriver]

Will you be trading him?

Probably not. It's one round. Should bounce back. he's a quality player and they usually do. Broughton > Hanley sounds tempting though.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Probably not. It's one round. Should bounce back. he's a quality player and they usually do. Broughton > Hanley sounds tempting though.

Do it please

 

[mdippa]

buying Mitch Robinson. Big big mistake right there!

 

[pulpdriver]

Do it please

Don't rate the Irishman?

 

[Judd_Magic]

buying Mitch Robinson. Big big mistake right there!

Ha! Ha! Fail.

 

[Ball Hog]

Not buying Kreuzer after he was in my team almost all pre season. Not having him in DT or SC is really killing me on the inside at the moment. Putting Shiel on the ground ahead of McDonald and Magner was stupid considering I made sure he was on the bench in my DT team because I thought he would be sub affected. I know rookies scores are hard to predict but that really was a poor oversight by me.

Picking Broughton too, I honestly have very little idea why I picked him for SC at this point. DT yes, but I really doubt he will be a good SC pick and I'm NOT basing that comment on his score this round.

 

[Ed_Gein]

broughton had 35 points at qtr time after playing in the middle, then when shifted to defense he got 22 for the rest of the game....

 

[ThePezDispenser]

broughton had 35 points at qtr time after playing in the middle, then when shifted to defense he got 22 for the rest of the game....

Farrrrrkkkk... Seems to be a horrible decision picking him up!!!

 

[Ed_Gein]

Farrrrrkkkk... Seems to be a horrible decision picking him up!!!

well, he averages 135 against the swans. so he might be a good captain choice next week.

 

[galindez]

yeah, I was 50/50 between Broughton and Birchall. Settled on Broughton, maybe mistakenly.

Though I do remember loads of people trading him out last year, just before he started playing midfield more and smashing it every week

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Getting conned into Dylan Shiel. Should have gone with my gut and taken James McDonald or Thomas Ledger.

 

[raymagoo]

majority of the team! broughton is a goose! saw him get one possy after half time last night!

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Luckily i foresaw this with Broughton. He will pick it up though...when Lyon realises what a moron he is. He as himself, Lyon...not Broughton.

 

[Raveneyes]

No regrets yet (far too early for that).

I picked Broughton over Suckling, started Shiel over McDonald, started Smedts over Kennedy, picked Swan over Pendles and have Martin, Goodes etc.

But it's round one, so not panicking.

Round three I will revisit my rookie picks, but won't be trading premiums unless something drastic happens.

 

[GOAUS!]

Having Shiel on the field ahead of Kennedy.

 

[GOAUS!]

And picking Swan over Pendlebury.

 

[coryne]

Making Goodes my captain I thought he was going to KILL the GWS and make me a bucket-load of points. Instead he scores 90, while Pendlebury (who I have) goes on and scores 167 . I didn't even play it smark and make him VC, so I could take advantage of the partial lock-out ................ Also didn't get a chance to finish off my team, so I have Zorko (inj?), Pfeiffer (not playing) and Stevens (not playing?) in there. So I am pretty happy with my premiums (even those that under-performed) but rookies may be a little shakey ATM

 

[Judd_Magic]

Starting Shiel over Kennedy.

Ellis over Bugg.

Picking Morris instead of Moher for my bench. May fix this up with a trade.

And getting Coniglio over Mcdonold although its only one game so far. I may fix this up with a trade if Coniglio doesn't improve.

Happy with the rest of my team though. Just wish I had a forth premium midfielder in the midfield.

 

[V23]

Not picking up C. Smith, switched him to Ledger 15 minutes before lockout. Ledger could still do well but I'll probably have to burn a trade to bring Smith in.