Thread starter
#1
If you were picking the Swans teams for the first week of a finals campaign, who would you pick?
Mine is based on current form, and previous proven ability to step up in big games.
B Barry Bolton Bevan
HB Kennelly Richards Mattner
C Malceski Kirk McVeigh
HF OKeefe Hall Moore
Fl Davis OLoughlin Everitt
M Jolly, J Bolton, Goodes
R Buchanan, Jack, Barlow, Schmidt
Obviously the backline is pretty interchangable based on opposition forwards.
Davis gets picked based on no-one who has replaced him has done a better job or shown more potential. It is an outrage he isnt getting picked, no-one has put their hand up and taken his spot.
Bird, Ablett, Playfair, LRT arent doing enough IMO. Bird needs longer to develop, but the others are running out of excuses. They are handy at best to fill in for injured players.
Thoughts
Mine is based on current form, and previous proven ability to step up in big games.
B Barry Bolton Bevan
HB Kennelly Richards Mattner
C Malceski Kirk McVeigh
HF OKeefe Hall Moore
Fl Davis OLoughlin Everitt
M Jolly, J Bolton, Goodes
R Buchanan, Jack, Barlow, Schmidt
Obviously the backline is pretty interchangable based on opposition forwards.
Davis gets picked based on no-one who has replaced him has done a better job or shown more potential. It is an outrage he isnt getting picked, no-one has put their hand up and taken his spot.
Bird, Ablett, Playfair, LRT arent doing enough IMO. Bird needs longer to develop, but the others are running out of excuses. They are handy at best to fill in for injured players.
Thoughts

