Autopsy Swans vs Eagles

[Tedeski]

Think Grundy Smith Rampe all in good form around him helps too

Even mcveigh with his leadership helped im sure

I mean tonight Marsh was probably the best down back

Regarding McVeigh?
Absence makes the heart grow fonder.
Last time I heard about Macca, he was gorrrrrn!

 

[RW]

And best not to dwell on the umpiring...but I just have to say I can't help but feel like that non 50 metre penalty would have been paid against us if the roles were reversed. As many have said the umpiring is just so incompetent, every week. It is just so frustrating to watch.

Tonight was about normal for games in Perth, the crowd definitely is a factor.

 

[The King!]

Regarding McVeigh?
Absence makes the heart grow fonder.
Last time I heard about Macca, he was gorrrrrn!

Mcveighs leadership is always useful

I personally think mcveigh was fine when fit last year

Sadly was not fit in his last game, but he can hit a target at least and point out thingw

 

[Kapanis]

Mills, hmmm, can't be honest on here, otherwise,

 

[CD__]

Really? Defensively he is shocking in my eyes. Has too much separation. Gets beaten one on one through his lack of pure defensive nous. Has been isolated by opposition coaches because of it.

Will be an A grade mid at worst. Purely as a defender he sucks bit gets away with it because of his class.

Not his fault. Shouldn't be playing there.

I think you're majorly overplaying this, he's had a couple of marks taken on him by bigger, stronger opponents but he's not exactly getting towelled up.

 

[scaryness]

Mcveighs leadership is always useful

I personally think mcveigh was fine when fit last year

Sadly was not fit in his last game, but he can hit a target at least and point out thingw

Maybe we have misunderstood what McVeigh's pointing provides to the team this whole time.

 

[MK38]

Tonight was about normal for games in Perth, the crowd definitely is a factor.

Oh yes I know it's just that every week it is just so bad. We never seem to get that home ground advantage in the umpiring. I don't get how they get so influenced by the crowd, if a free is there pay it, if not don't. Simple.

 

[Tedeski]

Mcveighs leadership is always useful

I personally think mcveigh was fine when fit last year

Sadly was not fit in his last game, but he can hit a target at least and point out thingw

You're right.
Sam Mitchell was slow as tonight but his skills get the job done.
Macca has been our most skilled & reliable player & had to go back often to fix things.

We definitely could have done with Macca out there. I also thought Cunningham was terrific tonight & he would have been a big help against the Pies last week.

 

[The King!]

You're right.
Sam Mitchell was slow as tonight but his skills get the job done.
Macca has been our most skilled & reliable player & had to go back often to fix things.

We definitely could have done with Macca out there. I also thought Cunningham was terrific tonight & he would have been a big help against the Pies last week.

I like Cunningham if he is forward/mid

His bodywork and goal were good

 

[scaryness]

Missed the first 3 quarters and have one eye on the replay.

Did Cunningham just win a 1-on-1 contest mark inside 50?

 

[Dubsforsam1]

We are short of about 5-6 goals.

Take Franklin as injured after that hit, Tippet injured, Rohan injured, Heeney injured, Rampe/McVeigh injured which means Jones can't go into the middle and Papley playing his first game of the season. There are 5/6 goals already

 

[kickthething]

Maybe we have misunderstood what McVeigh's pointing provides to the team this whole time.

Just still scarred from the GF performance.....

 

[Kennedy Parker]

Missed the first 3 quarters and have one eye on the replay.

Did Cunningham just win a 1-on-1 contest mark inside 50?

Yes. Cunningham was fine tonight, kicked a goal and laid a lot of tackles, did his job.

 

[MK38]

Missed the first 3 quarters and have one eye on the replay.

Did Cunningham just win a 1-on-1 contest mark inside 50?

He was good tonight.

 

[Tedeski]

I like Cunningham if he is forward/mid

His bodywork and goal were good

He's a hard working player that got a few things wrong against WBulldogs. Should have been left in against the Pies at home.

 

[The King!]

So what was pre season this year?


Ring a ring a rosy?

Game of dodgeball

Duck duck goose

Then a bit of chasey round the fort and a push on the swings

 

[SilentHunter_]

Yeah cunningham was good tonight I'll admit.

 

[The King!]

Sinclair did a pretty solid job tonight considering his talent level

 

[Olian]

So what was pre season this year?


Ring a ring a rosy?

Game of dodgeball

Duck duck goose

Then a bit of chasey round the fort and a push on the swings

No who could spend the most time in rehab?

 

[Punts]

Wonder what horse thinks when Sam and buddy are on the wing and the the 3 smallest blokes are in the 50 I'm paps , KJ and Harry

Kick it long to our talls

 

[Olian]

Sinclair did a pretty solid job tonight considering his talent level

He was up against Giles it was a shootout of the spuds.

 

[The King!]

He was up against Giles it was a shootout of the spuds.

Yeah and he was ok, thats all

 

[Olian]

Yeah and he was ok, thats all

True he did manage to mark the ball tonight.

 

[Ticky009]

Kids are doing their best. Our senior players are driving me nuts, to the point I had to close the back door...much unladylike swearing was occurring
K Jack signed to '19. ROK was assigned to the NEAFL in better form.

 

[Banyo Bloods]

Non 50 from Mitchell kick, Papley in the back of WC player and Hearn not looking at footy and taking florent out were absolute howlers. Fisher number 2 ump was disgraceful has NFI