Autopsy Swans vs Tigers

[Swan4Life]

OUT: Lloyd
IN: Mills

Lloyd with 3 turnovers under no pressure which led directly to 3 Richmond goals. This clown will cost us a flag if we don't act decisively. Cunningham also near the edge of the cliff, needs to lift his game. Tippo a little anonymous but to be expected given the layoff.

Everyone else - virtually flawless.

 

[doona]

I just saw a replay of Naismith's tackle on Houli. I reckon he might be in some trouble for the first final.

 

[MickyG]

http://www.afl.com.au/video/2016-08-27/big-swan-in-hot-water

Nothing to be worried about a good strong tackle.

Not a sling tackle Jason.

Single action and him being Ok makes me optimistic he'll only get a fine.

 

[MickyG]

I was wrong. Thank goodness they gave Benny that opportunity. Three more games at that intensity please (hopefully 3 gets it done).

I was right. Cunningham's form is terrible.

 

[The King!]

OUT: Lloyd
IN: Mills

Lloyd with 3 turnovers under no pressure which led directly to 3 Richmond goals. This clown will cost us a flag if we don't act decisively. Cunningham also near the edge of the cliff, needs to lift his game. Tippo a little anonymous but to be expected given the layoff.

Everyone else - virtually flawless.

Lloyd can butcher it
But no way should he go ahead of Cunningham imo

 

[Banyo Bloods]

http://www.afl.com.au/video/2016-08-27/big-swan-in-hot-water

Nothing to be worried about a good strong tackle.

In comparison this tackle this year didn't result in a suspension.

 

[miggs]

One of the more enjoyable games. Wasnt a sliver of danger during the game. Towers comes back in right? Was discussing with a mate surely he was just rested. Or have i missed something

 

[Kennedy Parker]

One of the more enjoyable games. Wasnt a sliver of danger during the game. Towers comes back in right? Was discussing with a mate surely he was just rested. Or have i missed something

Think the coaches just rate McGlynn higher.

Cunningham should be out for Mills, don't really want to see him for the finals anyway.

 

[Lakeside Swan]

In comparison this tackle this year didn't result in a suspension.

That's identicle and this is similar:


The only thing going against him is he's not wear we an poo colours.

 

[miggs]

Think the coaches just rate McGlynn higher.

Cunningham should be out for Mills, don't really want to see him for the finals anyway.

Id rather see towers and mills in for marsh and cunningham. Messes up balance a bit mcglynn probably did enough. Although kinda feels like making a century against zimbabwe

 

[Kennedy Parker]

Id rather see towers and mills in for marsh and cunningham. Messes up balance a bit mcglynn probably did enough. Although kinda feels like making a century against zimbabwe

Think Marsh will come down to match ups, if we play GWS we may need an extra tall down back.

McGlynn's experience could be valuable given the profile of our list. Did some okay things against North the week before.

Towers should still be in the frame, see how he goes in the NEAFL final. If we don't go with Marsh I think Towers should come in and McVeigh might go back.

 

[doona]

Towers should still be in the frame, see how he goes in the NEAFL final.

Is he eligible to play?

 

[Kennedy Parker]

Is he eligible to play?

Not sure but would've thought he's played enough reserve game this year.

 

[doona]

Not sure but would've thought he's played enough reserve game this year.

I found this, dont know if it is current.....

a player must play a minimum of three (3) Competition home and away Matches with the Club
to qualify for the finals unless otherwise approved by the AFL.

http://www.neafl.com.au/fileadmin/user_upload/Documents/NEAFL_Rules___Regulations_2013.pdf

 

[Kennedy Parker]

I found this, dont know if it is current.....



http://www.neafl.com.au/fileadmin/user_upload/Documents/NEAFL_Rules___Regulations_2013.pdf

Well he's surely played more than that. Been dropped 3 times this year from memory.

Think he's around 5-6 reserve games this year.

 

[swannyfan]

What's the record of minor premiers going on to to win the premiership?

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Thinking more longterm X.Richards or Sam Reid? or can they both play in the same team?

 

[CD__]

How good is it having JPK consistently kicking sausage rolls again? His inside 50 work is criminally underrated, not just the goals but his innate ability to put teammates into space and set up scoring opportunities, genuine superstar.

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

What's the record of minor premiers going on to to win the premiership?

Not that good.

 

[SilentHunter_]

Thinking more longterm X.Richards or Sam Reid? or can they both play in the same team?

Reid is finished imo.

 

[CD__]

Reid is finished imo.

Unless he requests a trade he is an absolute certainty to be lining up in our best 22 for Round 1 next year.

 

[swannyfan]

Not that good.

So you're saying there is a chance

 

[SilentHunter_]

Unless he requests a trade he is an absolute certainty to be lining up in our best 22 for Round 1 next year.

If richards keeps on playing the way he is I see no need for Reid.

 

[CD__]

If richards keeps on playing the way he is I see no need for Reid.

I love what Xavier has done over the past couple of months but Reid is an upgrade on him in every possible facet of the game.

 

[The King!]

Unless he requests a trade he is an absolute certainty to be lining up in our best 22 for Round 1 next year.

Who for?

If we roll on and say win a flag you then turn around to XR and throw him out for a player who has never peformed at his current output