From Wikipedia:
Tredrea consistently finishes amongst the top of league goalkicking and marks. He has won Port's Best and Fairest award 3 times, in 2001, 2004 and 2005 and was Runner-Up in 1999, 2002 and 2003. He has been selected in the
All Australian Team at Centre Half Forward in 4 consecutive years 2001-04 including being named the 2004 vice-captain. Tredrea had the honour of being acting captain of Port Adelaide in 2004 when
Matthew Primus was injured. During that year Tredrea kicked a career-best 81 goals as he led Port Adelaide to its first AFL
premiership, and raised the Premiership Cup with coach
Mark Williams.
Adam Simpson's career highlights
Best and fairest 2002
3rd best and fairest 2001, 03, 04
All-Australian 2002
AFL Rising Star 1996
I make that Tredrea = Four-time All-Australian, Simpson = 1
Tredrea = 3 time B&F and 3 time runner up, Simpson = 1-time B&F and 3 time third placing
Tredrea = Captained a premiership, Simpson = Enough said.