- Sep 21, 2012
- AFL Club
- Other Teams
- Piggy Smith, Heat
It is a significant investment, but he ticked and still ticks plenty of boxes to the point where I can’t really fault it.What we have up to get him requires getting an A grade star in return.
As you’ve pointed out, he’s not an A grade star.
He’s a good (albeit limited) footballer, but when looking at the ROI he’s already a bust.
Proven performer, big game experience, young enough to give us 150 games, consummate professional, plays a position of need and offers attributes that we needed at the time and still need now.
2 picks in the teens for Shiel and Mosquito is fair enough I reckon