Tambling

[marco polo]

That confuses even me. although I see more promise in him then I do in Tambling. Dew, who knows what he'll do. Probably sit in the stands eating pies for all I care. Doesn't change the fact he's better then Tambling.

During which one of Rocca's 10 goals did you see this promise?

 

[polakthetiger]

Sponge Bob > Roughead

 

[Ruanaidh]

Inane tripe. End this thread.

 

[Hawks1523]

During which one of Rocca's 10 goals did you see this promise?

Both. Tambling has shown me **** all. Sponge bob is awesome. Tigers will fail again,with the two biggest duds in the AFL being at this club.

 

[aron_rox]

Q whats the difference between tambling and rodan and krackour. Are they the same type of players?

honest question

 

[tigers_of_old_08]

It's the only thing worth discussing with Tigers fans. You don't care, yet you brang up Tasmania. So I said it's going well. I'll leave this in it's own thread, because I can. If I wanted to reel people in, I would have been more creative with posts.

If you tried to post this rubbish on the Carlton Board you'd have been red-carded by now and this thread would have been closed.

You are fortunate we have more tolerant Mods on the Richmond Board.

May I suggest you take any further trolling to Bay 13?

 

[tigers71]

That confuses even me. although I see more promise in him then I do in Tambling. Dew, who knows what he'll do. Probably sit in the stands eating pies for all I care. Doesn't change the fact he's better then Tambling.

You come in here talk crap or shit and we defend which we do unfortunately. So say something which is the blatant obvious. Maybe just maybe we have heard the tambling/franklin many times over 2007. I for one think worry about your own f team. We worry about our own so do the right thing when you close the door behind you dont come back. Maybe a little red card would the apporiate thing for you.

 

[Hawks1523]

You come in here talk crap or shit and we defend which we do unfortunately. So say something which is the blatant obvious. Maybe just maybe we have heard the tambling/franklin many times over 2007. I for one think worry about your own f team. We worry about our own so do the right thing when you close the door behind you dont come back. Maybe a little red card would the apporiate thing for you.

I didn't mention Franklin. One of your own did. And, I'm just saying, I think RIchomnd wont be a successful side, until you get rid of Tambling and Wallace. I think the rest of your list is decent, and these are the things holding you back!

As for bay 13. One step ahead.

 

[skybeau]

That confuses even me.

You poor bugger. It must be hard going through life without a brain.

I've heard surgeons can do a great cheap brain transplant these, maybe you should get someone to book you in for one. Perhaps wait for the post-Christmas sales though.

 

[tigers71]

I didn't mention Franklin. One of your own did. And, I'm just saying, I think RIchomnd wont be a successful side, until you get rid of Tambling and Wallace. I think the rest of your list is decent, and these are the things holding you back!

As for bay 13. One step ahead.

You basically dont know anything about AFL and contracts. If we get rid of Terry than we have to pay him out. Tambling is 1 out of 39 player of a list and I dont think he's to blame what about our senior players Einstein. They did not stand up and we had a long injury list also.

 

[Hawks1523]

You poor bugger. It must be hard going through life without a brain.

I've heard surgeons can do a great cheap brain transplant these, maybe you should get someone to book you in for one. Perhaps wait for the post-Christmas sales though.

Does Greg Miller know the name of a good one? Or anybody on the Richmond board?

 

[Hawks1523]

You basically dont know anything about AFL and contracts. If we get rid of Terry than we have to pay him out. Tambling is 1 out of 39 player of a list and I dont think he's to blame what about our senior players Einstein. They did not stand up and we had a long injury list also.

I'm not doubting any of that. And to be honest, I'd pay him out and bring in a new coach. But Tambling has played 20 games this season, and has he honestly shown anything? I personally think Richmond are better off without him. I may be wrong, but it's a personal opinion I'm sharing with the loving Richmond faithful.

 

[tigers71]

I'm not doubting any of that. And to be honest, I'd pay him out and bring in a new coach. But Tambling has played 20 games this season, and has he honestly shown anything? I personally think Richmond are better off without him. I may be wrong, but it's a personal opinion I'm sharing with the loving Richmond faithful.

Who do you suppose you bring in Alastair?

 

[skybeau]

I'm not doubting any of that. And to be honest, I'd pay him out and bring in a new coach. But Tambling has played 20 games this season, and has he honestly shown anything? I personally think Richmond are better off without him. I may be wrong, but it's a personal opinion I'm sharing with the loving Richmond faithful.

Well thanks for sharing.

I'm afraid you're wrong.

But don't let get in the way of demonstrating your idiocy by any means.

 

[Hawks1523]

Who do you suppose you bring in Alastair?

Sheedy? It's been touted around, and if he's still any decent coach might be just the thing the Tiges need? Don't pay much attention to assistants / VFL coaches. I just don't think Wallace is upto AFL coaching, didn't think he was at the Bulldogs, don't think so at the Tigers.

 

[NQTIGER]

Dont worry about these hawthorn fjuckwits they are obsessed with tambling and wallace.

Maybe they know that sniper clarkson and buddy wont deliver the next flag and hope to get wallace

 

[_RT_]

Do you really rate him that highly here? Do you all think he will be a star, and go on to be a great AFL player? Or will you, and the club wise up and dump this spud from your playing list?

Now as much as you're going to deny it I am 100% positive that along with countless other little Hawk tossers you were spending many a day dreaming about the Hawks picking up Tambling back in the 04 draft, and when the Hawks went with Roughead and Franklin instead you were probably thinking to yourself how they have stuffed up in a big way.

It was only plain dumb luck that Hawthorn struck gold with Franklin not some brilliant recruiting that some of your fellow supporters like to claim.

But to answer your questions:
1. Yes I do still rate him highly
2. He may not go on to be a superstar but he will be a very good player for the next 7-10 years while helping return Richmond to the top of the ladder

Now that you've become the 1000th Hawk fan to start a Tambling thread and have had the same answers given to you as the other 999 I think it might be time to move on.

 

[tigers71]

Now as much as you're going to deny it I am 100% positive that along with countless other little Hawk tossers you were spending many a day dreaming about the Hawks picking up Tambling back in the 04 draft, and when the Hawks went with Roughead and Franklin instead you were probably thinking to yourself how they have stuffed up in a big way.

It was only plain dumb luck that Hawthorn struck gold with Franklin not some brilliant recruiting that some of your fellow supporters like to claim.

But to answer your questions:
1. Yes I do still rate him highly
2. He may not go on to be a superstar but he will be a very good player for the next 7-10 years while helping return Richmond to the top of the ladder

Now that you've become the 1000th Hawk fan to start a Tambling thread and have had the same answers given to you as the other 999 I think it might be time to move on.

Talk slowly as these gooses do not understand english and logic

 

[Hawks1523]

Now as much as you're going to deny it I am 100% positive that along with countless other little Hawk tossers you were spending many a day dreaming about the Hawks picking up Tambling back in the 04 draft, and when the Hawks went with Roughead and Franklin instead you were probably thinking to yourself how they have stuffed up in a big way.

It was only plain dumb luck that Hawthorn struck gold with Franklin not some brilliant recruiting that some of your fellow supporters like to claim.

But to answer your questions:
1. Yes I do still rate him highly
2. He may not go on to be a superstar but he will be a very good player for the next 7-10 years while helping return Richmond to the top of the ladder

Now that you've become the 1000th Hawk fan to start a Tambling thread and have had the same answers given to you as the other 999 I think it might be time to move on.

To be honest? I didn't look into or care about the 2004 draft. It's no secret we were dismal in those years, and I supported, went to games and that was all. Didn't read into anything, no draft news, any of it. Didn't know a thing about Tambling in 2004. It's cool you rate him highly, like I'm saying this is my opinion I am stating. From my point of view, he hasn't shown much and his spot is better filled with somebody else, seems you all disagree and that's fine. Can't we have a friendly discussion about it?

 

[_RT_]

Just to see how good your knowledge of kids is how would you rate this players first 3 seasons.

Year 1 - 7.8 possies 2.5 marks 1 tackles 0.5 goals per game over 4 games
Year 2 - 8.5 possies 3.5 marks 1.5 tackles 0.9 goals per game over 15 games
Year 3 - 7.2 possies 2.2 marks 0.7 tackles 0.5 goals per game over 13 games.

Now is this a player you would keep around or one you would want dumped?

 

[PUNTROADHAMMER]

Do you really rate him that highly here? Do you all think he will be a star, and go on to be a great AFL player? Or will you, and the club wise up and dump this spud from your playing list?

Hasn't Hawthorn deemed it a masterstroke recruiting S Dew?? - still giggling about that one. The only pack he's regularly near has Tim Tam written on it.

 

[sante]

That the best you have? I still can't believe Richmond fans think this fool will make it. Delisted end of 08. Bookmark it.

No chance. If that happens, then Buddy doesn't do drugs...

 

[Equus]

Do you really rate him that highly here? Do you all think he will be a star, and go on to be a great AFL player? Or will you, and the club wise up and dump this spud from your playing list?

Time will tell. Just be patient. Bookmark it and return next year.

 

[Swanny36]

i still dont know why everyone is making a big deal about the tambling/buddy draft mistake that richmond made everyone has made mistakes in the draft at some points

 

[Rayzorwire]

i still dont know why everyone is making a big deal about the tambling/buddy draft mistake that richmond made everyone has made mistakes in the draft at some points

The only time we can judge if it was a mistake or not is at the end of both their respective careers.