tarrant

[magpies42]

I heard that bartel still hasn't signed?! if this is the case would you guys be interested in a straight swap bartel for taz?! i thin its fair you guys need a tall we need a classy in n under player

 

[thehoff]

Keep dreaming... We have a player by the name of... N.Ablett that will fil that void in the near future.

Bartel will stay a cat.

 

[JUBJUB]

if this is the case would you guys be interested in a straight swap bartel for taz?!

NO WAY !!!!!!!!!

I wouldn't even trade James Rahilly or Matt McCarthy for Tarrant.Send him to Carlton.They take crap players nobody wants.

 

[LifeSpan-Void]

I heard that bartel still hasn't signed?! if this is the case would you guys be interested in a straight swap bartel for taz?! i thin its fair you guys need a tall we need a classy in n under player

Geelong has enough "talls", all we need is a "quality" tall. tarrant is uh... crap.

KTHX

 

[Kegs44]

Bartel is a way better player than TAZ and there is no way that trade will ever happen. TAZ is overrated big time

 

[WestCat]

Tarrant isn't the player we're after, he lacks consistency and doesn't kick enough goals for Geelong to chase him. Bartel finished about 12th (or thereabouts) in last year's Brownlow despite only playing about 12 or 13 games, he has had some injury troubles this year but has shrugged them off now and is playing spectacular footy (see yesterday's game), to suggest a straight swap grossly underrates Bartel.

Jimmy will stay with Geelong for a while and will be a champion footballer. I don't think Tarrant works hard enough to make use of his talent to be worth chasing. We already have a tall-medium forward who shows glimpses and then plays like crap for a few games and that's Gardiner, however, Charlie is quite a few years younger than Tarrant and I think will develop into a less spectacular but similar footballer.

 

[Turbocat]

A player of his talent could useful, a player with attitude could be useless. When he say , like Ottens said , "I want Geelong " then we can start talking

 

[Ricketts]

I wouldn't want Tarrant for anything.

 

[fugsy]

Tarrant who?

 

[BillyMiller]

you guys are tripping....
Tarrant is a player with a ton of talent & potential -
don’t know how he could fit in with Henry starting to do so well,
& definately wouldn’t swap Jimmy Bartel for him....
apparently he was a cats supporter as a kid & if he did show interest in
a move down here the club would be mad not to have a good hard look
at him. i’d love to see him in hoops instead of stripes

 

[D0nk]

I must admit I haven't seen much of Collingwood this year, or Tarrant. Friday night I watched as he dropped his head, didn't put any second efforts in and just seemed totally dis-interested.

If you want a Trade you could do a swap with Fevola, they're almost on par atm.

 

[LongBomb]

Kingsley > Tarrant.

 

[JUBJUB]

Tarrant is a player with a ton of talent & potential -

Isn't that the description given to nearly all draft prospects ?

 

[nananana catman]

Could we afford it?

 

[Ricketts]

Could we afford it?

Kent is a better and cheaper option.

 

[JUBJUB]

Kent is a better and cheaper option.

Should we start calling him Dimmeys ?

 

[D0nk]

Should we start calling him Dimmeys ?

Haha Kent's Crazy Warehouse.

 

[JUBJUB]

Haha Kent's Crazy Warehouse.

Now that sounds better

 

[Ricketts]

Haha Kent's Crazy Warehouse.

*Krazy.

 

[tayls]

Don't forget about Big Henry, give him 2 more seasons he will be better than Tarrant. NO TRADE.

 

[JUBJUB]

Don't forget about Big Henry, give him 2 more seasons he will be better than Tarrant. NO TRADE.

Um... he's already better than Tarrant

 

[nananana catman]

*Krazy.

 

[LifeSpan-Void]

so i guess to summarise, EddieBoy, NO - we don't want your metrosexual full forward with nice biceps and hair, but no ticker.

 

[Unwritten_Law]

Take Gardiner. HFF for HFF

 

[Art Corvelay]

I agree, you'd be nuts to trade Bartel for Tarrant

However, the guy is playing injured, and is getting shocking delivery. On paper he'd probably fit in well with your team, and would get the delivery to make him a good player.