You're a Mod, I agree with you
I have no power on this board, disagree away.
Shaw has always pissed me off. For ME, his negatives always outweighed his positives, and there were always playes that did the things he did better.
Marley Williams and Toovey are both better one on one defenders who don't give away stupid free kicks constantly.
Harry and Seedsman (sson young) provide just as much run and carry
So for me, I have no issue trading him for a high pick or good young player. We gain a goal or two a game simply by him no longer beig there.
What pisses me off the most about Shaw? What REALLY farking gets my goat? His brain snaps/fades come at the WORST times in games. Almost always when the game is at that tipping point. Against Freo he did it when we were in control and on the way back (or just in front if memory serves).
Against Hawthorn we were in control of that match, then Heath decides to stupidly give away a 50 for absolutely no reason whatsoever other than being a complete dick.
Against Port, gives away 2 unnecessary frees that gift goal to Anus Wantfrees and then gets sucked in and gives him another.
I just can't deal with his dickness anymore.