Taylor + Pick 12

[brookers#5]

For the goose would you guys accept that.

 

[sauce_head]

For the goose would you guys accept that.

No, he is staying or we rebuild.

 

[versatyl_console]

LOL try pick 12 and thorp

 

[kirbatron]

LOL try pick 12 and thorp

turn it up.

Pick 12 and Boyle/Dowler?

 

[The Punter]

Forget the pick. Thorp for Maguire straight up. (If he cannot be persuaded to return to St Kilda, which is what we would rather have happen.)

 

[sauce_head]

Forget the pick. Thorp for Maguire straight up. (If he cannot be persuaded to return to St Kilda, which is what we would rather have happen.)

Are you saying you would rather see him go than return to the saints?

 

[goodie23]

[rhetorical question]Why do people bother theoretically offering up expendable players for necessary players?[/rhetorical question]

 

[The Punter]

Are you saying you would rather see him go than return to the saints?

No, I'd much, much rather see him return. Goose belongs at St kilda and I'm now convinced he is staying.

 

[sauce_head]

No, I'd much, much rather see him return. Goose belongs at St kilda and I'm now convinced he is staying.

Good, sorry for doubting you mate. I want him here as well.

 

[bubblegoose]

No, I'd much, much rather see him return. Goose belongs at St kilda and I'm now convinced he is staying.

What's the word Punter? I've tried through my source to get the inside story but to no avail as yet.

 

[Flashhh]

he can come to the dee's for col sylvia and pick 21

 

[The Punter]

Bubblegoose - Goose on Gold104 this morning stating it is only a matter of putting pen to paper (he is in Thailand at the moment), and Sheldon saying negotiations with X Clarke, Baker & Maguire all well down the road, with all indicating desire to remain at Moorabbin.

 

[bubblegoose]

Thanks Punter! Guess how big the smile on my face is right now! That's it! Beers after work are ON! woohoo!

 

[DannyJ]

Thorp won't be traded, he will be a champion.

Maguire is a good player that get's injured. Pick 12 + Taylor is a fair offer.

He could possibly go cheaper if he quit, and threatin' a PSD move.

I think he will stay and sign a deal though, so no need to worry.

 

[St DAC]

Gets injured? A freak broken leg, and accompanying complications is not a repeat offender in the injury stakes ...

I too hope he signs soon ... decent CHB's are hard to find.

Why would Hawthorn need him? Croad goes pretty well at CHB ...

 

[DannyJ]

Gets injured? A freak broken leg, and accompanying complications is not a repeat offender in the injury stakes ...

I too hope he signs soon ... decent CHB's are hard to find.

Why would Hawthorn need him? Croad goes pretty well at CHB ...

He has missed a lot of football last year due to a re-occurence of leg soreness, which I suppose in reality he will be over next year.

We would play Croad at FB, we need two big KPP's allowing Gilham to be our third tall. Maguire will end up staying, but it would be nice if he declared he wanted out (for us anyway)

 

[The Punter]

Maguire and Croad were at similar stages at the same age. Both suffered problems (Maguire & leg, Croad & ego).

Croad attracted the #1 pick.

So, before we get into a full fledged argument about whether Simon Taylor will become the next John Nicholls or Lawrence Bingham, let's just say we disagree on Taylor's worth, huh?

 

[Flashhh]

Croad attracted the #1 pick.

Croad attracted the number one pick? ....I think you'll also find that it was Croad AND MCPHARLIN, who is a KPP who can play at both ends (priceless) who were traded for pick #1.

 

[sainter]

He has missed a lot of football last year due to a re-occurence of leg soreness, which I suppose in reality he will be over next year.

We would play Croad at FB, we need two big KPP's allowing Gilham to be our third tall. Maguire will end up staying, but it would be nice if he declared he wanted out (for us anyway)

Yep.

He probably returned too early but the fact that once he returned to the team the senior team he was able to finish the season would suggest that he should be OK. He struggled to recapture his form from before the injury but it was always going to take time and he'll be better for it next season.

 

[lion_gooner]

how about cameron wood for maguire?????

 

[St DAC]

how about cameron wood for maguire?????

And Sherman; perhaps.

 

[lion_gooner]

nah not sherman

wood for maguire would suit both teams really good

brisbane need a chb so bradshaw can play in the forward line 100% of the time

and maguire being good friends with brown could help

and you need a good ruckman

 

[St DAC]

Maguire is an establised CHB. Wood is not an established ruckman. For that trade to happen Brisbane would need to offer Wood plus a player IMO. Sherman appears to be on the outer at Brisbane, and he's the type of midfielder we need. Hence why I suggested him.

BTW Goose is not a particularly close mate to Brown; they just both come from the same part of Victoria.

Doesn't Wood want to return to SA rather than move to Melbourne?

 

[mad-saint-guy]

wood for maguire would suit both teams really good

brisbane need a chb so bradshaw can play in the forward line 100% of the time

and you need a good ruckman

It would suit Brisbane well, not St Kilda.

While Brisbane need a CHB, so do St Kilda. As you said, we need a GOOD ruckman. Wood is a 20 year old who has never had more than 16 hitouts in a game and was overtaken by an 18 year old this year. He will not help us win a premiership.

 

[dp3[WLD]]

be such a sham if goose left