Remove this Banner Ad

team for north

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

toommy said:
as usual you missed the point entirely
Click to expand...

No I havent. You say that banging bodies will shorten his career. I say he is already near the end of his career and has no injury problems, and one game in Round 1 against a possible taller opponent will not make any difference. You compared him wrongly to Brereton and Carey - those guys phyically were washed up in their mid-late 20's. Clement has already passed that phase of his career and is still AA standard (should have been picked last season, we all agree that). Physically theres no comparison between those guys and Clement. Generally a defender would take less physical punishment than a forward anyway, as he's the hunter rather than the hunted.
 
Ok I will name my final team & I will see how close I get:

Lockyer Presti Maxwell

Jonhson Clement R Shaw

H Shaw Obree Pendelbury

Thomas Cloke Davis

Fraser Rocca Medhurst

Ruck: Richards Licuria Swan

Bench: Burns Egan Lonie Bryan

I think they will play Fraser forward for two resons, One to get his match fitness up & he will also pinch hit in Ruck.

Richards (although doesnt deserve a game) will play as he adds structure to our team & allows Fraser to go forward.

Bryan also will play as if Richards struggles then Fraser can Ruck with Bryan as a third tall in forward line.

I believe they will try Richards, Fraser & Bryan in the early rounds (while we have potent forwards out in Didak & Bucks). However if Richards fails to deliever then he will be gone.

I hope he stands up, but only time will tell!
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

BoundforGlory said:
Ok I will name my final team & I will see how close I get:

Lockyer Presti Maxwell

Jonhson Clement R Shaw

H Shaw Obree Pendelbury

Thomas Cloke Davis

Fraser Rocca Medhurst

Ruck: Richards Licuria Swan

Bench: Burns Egan Lonie Bryan

I think they will play Fraser forward for two resons, One to get his match fitness up & he will also pinch hit in Ruck.

Richards (although doesnt deserve a game) will play as he adds structure to our team & allows Fraser to go forward.

Bryan also will play as if Richards struggles then Fraser can Ruck with Bryan as a third tall in forward line.

I believe they will try Richards, Fraser & Bryan in the early rounds (while we have potent forwards out in Didak & Bucks). However if Richards fails to deliever then he will be gone.

I hope he stands up, but only time will tell!
Click to expand...
i would have wakelin at chb on hale.
 
My Team would be :

B: Lockyer Presti Wakelin
HB: Clement Maxwell O'Brien
C: Johnson Pendlebury H. Shaw
HF: T. Cloke Fraser Thomas
F: Davis Rocca Medhurst
Foll: Bryan, Burns, O'Bree
Inter: Richards, Licuria, Swan, D**k
Emerg: R. Shaw, Egan, Reid
 
Dead Eye Didak said:
My Team would be :

B: Lockyer Presti Wakelin
HB: Clement Maxwell O'Brien
C: Johnson Pendlebury H. Shaw
HF: T. Cloke Fraser Thomas
F: Davis Rocca Medhurst
Foll: Bryan, Burns, O'Bree
Inter: Richards, Licuria, Swan, D**k
Emerg: R. Shaw, Egan, Reid
Click to expand...
thats the team i would pick(subject to positional changes). at least it takes the opposition into account
 
Based on Dead Eye Didak's team for your mob. I'll slot in our likely line up to give you an idea of potential match ups.

B: Lockyer Presti Wakelin
F. Thomas Edwards Campbell
HB: Clement Maxwell O'Brien
HF: Jones Hale Grant
C: Johnson Pendlebury H. Shaw
C: Wells Harris Grant
HF: T. Cloke Fraser Thomas
HB: Hansen Petrie Sinclair
F: Davis Rocca Medhurst
FB: Riggio Watt Pratt
Foll: Bryan, Burns, O'Bree
Foll: McIntosh Simpson Harvey
Inter: Richards, Licuria, Swan, D**k
Inter (from): Rawlings Moran Archer Swallow Firrito Trotter Brown
Emerg: R. Shaw, Egan, Reid
 
Lidge said:
Do you realise Hale is 200cm+ tall? Be stoked if Wakelin took Hale.
Click to expand...

That wouldn't bother Wakelin one bit. He always thrashes Ottens who is a bit taller than Hale.

This is why teams don't panic when Sandilands is rested forward. Height doesn't matter if you know how to play as a key defender.

Clement and Maxwell are both around the same size and a bit shorter than Wakelin, they have no problems in playing on the taller ruckmen. Although Maxwell struggled against ruckmen sized players who are actually good down forward (Lade, Everitt, Charman).
 
Lidge said:
Do you realise Hale is 200cm+ tall? Be stoked if Wakelin took Hale.
Click to expand...

Hale has not shown to be a great mark for his size, doesn't take a lot of overhead or contested marks.
 
Tas said:
Hale has not shown to be a great mark for his size, doesn't take a lot of overhead or contested marks.
Click to expand...

Yes. Fraser when forward always gets matched up against a medium defende for example Gibson or Firrito because he isn't a great overhead mark for his size, but he moves around like a flanker.
 
Dead Eye Didak said:
My Team would be :

B: Lockyer Presti Wakelin
HB: Clement Maxwell O'Brien
C: Johnson Pendlebury H. Shaw
HF: T. Cloke Fraser Thomas
F: Davis Rocca Medhurst
Foll: Bryan, Burns, O'Bree
Inter: Richards, Licuria, Swan, D**k
Emerg: R. Shaw, Egan, Reid
Click to expand...
D**k ahead of Egan, R. Shaw, N. Brown and Reid.

I mean, he's good... but, he will take time.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

lockyer presti wakes
maxwell clement h shaw
r shaw obree johnson
davis cloke medhurst
egan rocca fraser

foll richards licca swan

inter thomas pendlebury burns lonie

I believe the pies will take a more experienced team into round 1. none of the new draft picks will play!
 
Reid will play as it will force the roos to play a tall in defence with no thompson up forward they will struugle to match up with height.
 
Lidge said:
Based on Dead Eye Didak's team for your mob. I'll slot in our likely line up to give you an idea of potential match ups.

B: Lockyer Presti Wakelin
F. Thomas Edwards Campbell
HB: Clement Maxwell O'Brien
HF: Jones Hale Grant
C: Johnson Pendlebury H. Shaw
C: Wells Harris Grant
HF: T. Cloke Fraser Thomas
HB: Hansen Petrie Sinclair
F: Davis Rocca Medhurst
FB: Riggio Watt Pratt
Foll: Bryan, Burns, O'Bree
Foll: McIntosh Simpson Harvey
Inter: Richards, Licuria, Swan, D**k
Inter (from): Rawlings Moran Archer Swallow Firrito Trotter Brown
Emerg: R. Shaw, Egan, Reid
Click to expand...

taking a look at those teams we are way too top heavy

up forward the roos only have 1 real big bloke in Hale, the rest are quick little blokes, Edwards is a leading type forward.......no way that wakelin, presti, maxwell and h.o'brien will all get a game, i reckon only two of the four will play

attempt a match up thing

B: Lockyer, Presti, Iles
F: Thomas, Edwards, Campbell
HB: Clement, Maxwell, Lonie
HF: S.Grant, Hale, C.Jones
C: B.Johnson, O'Bree, H.Shaw
C: Wells, Harris, Grant????-Rawlings perhaps
HF: L.Davis, Cloke, Thomas
HB: Hansen, Petrie, Sinclair
F: Medhurst, Rocca, Egan
B: Riggio, Watt, Pratt
Foll: Fraser, Licka, Pendles
Foll: McIntosh, Simpson, Booma
Int: Swan, Burns, Richards, R.Shaw
Int: Brown, Moran, Archer, Swallow

Lonie has done some good jobs on awkward dangerous mid sized types in Burton and Goodes, so he can get first crack at C.Jones.

Clement to smother Shagger when he is up forward.

Presti seems perfect for Edwards

Iles/Lockyer get the jobs on Thomas-Campbell, worried bout these we need to find a good quick back pocket stopper hopefully iles can fill that role

Hale will be too tall for all our defenders, let max try to run him around a bit

In the middle need to hard tag Booma as he kills us, step forward R.Shaw.

Also keep a close check on Wells as he can spark them if given any space

Obree head to head with Harris, should be a good battle
Licka v Simpson
Rawlings may go to B.Johnson i reckon
the roos will need to cut out H.Shaw and Swans run somehow

Up forward

petrie will take cloke
watt to take rocca
pratt may get medders
sinclair thomas
riggio to l.davis
egan will be too nimble for hansen, so that would force the kangas to change their structure a bit

Fraser will be too good around the ground for the BigMc, and should break even in the HO
 
doppleganger said:
taking a look at those teams we are way too top heavy

up forward the roos only have 1 real big bloke in Hale, the rest are quick little blokes, Edwards is a leading type forward.......no way that wakelin, presti, maxwell and h.o'brien will all get a game, i reckon only two of the four will play

I think you'll find if we went into the game with a shortage of talls in our backline we'll be in trouble. The Roo's do have guys in their side that a versatile. I mean the Roos could through Petrie, Brown, Hale, Moran all up forward, if this occurs you will need your Wakelins, Maxwell, and O'Briens.
Click to expand...
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

If you ask anyone at Collingwood, which of the new Draft Picks has impressed the coaching staff and players the most at Collingwood, everyone will mention D**k. Plus l don;t think Didak will play, so D**k could well take the role of a goal kicking forward pocket.
 
Lidge said:
Matt Campbell is only 66kgs (& 169cms) If they're good enough - you pick them.
Click to expand...

yeah bit of a diffrence being a short ass and weighing 66kg then being 182 and 68kg
we'll see though :)

I think daisy was around 72-73kg when he first started playing. Think hes put on 3-4kg now. not sure though
 
Dead Eye Didak said:
If you ask anyone at Collingwood, which of the new Draft Picks has impressed the coaching staff and players the most at Collingwood, everyone will mention D**k. Plus l don;t think Didak will play, so D**k could well take the role of a goal kicking forward pocket.
Click to expand...

True they have been talking him up a fair bit. I reckon he's a chance.
 
There's not enough room for him if you play Leon Davis, Medhurst and Egan which I think we will go with.

Reid and Cox are the wild card's but I reckon we have a fairly experienced 22 available.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

team for north

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top