Opinion Team of the Year

Schods

Senior List
Apr 21, 2013
198
145
AFL Club
Collingwood
North Melbourne:

FB: M.Williams, R.Tarrant, A.Mullett
CHB: L.McDonald, S.Thompson, J.Macmillan
C: S.Gibson, B.Cunnington, S.Atley
CHF: N.Hrovat, J.Waite, T.Garner
FF: S.Higgins, B.Brown, M.Wood
Foll: T.Goldstein, J.Ziebell, A.Swallow
Int: T.Dumont, R.Clarke, D.Mountford, J.Simpkin
E: K.Turner, B.Preuss, E.Vickers-Willis

Anyone have a different sides? I know I'm a Collingwood supporter, just wanting some other opinions. Thanks.
 
Last edited:

boneofshin

Premium Gold
Aug 1, 2012
4,433
8,084
Melbourne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
North Melbourne:

FB: M.Williams, R.Tarrant, A.Mullett
CHB: L.McDonald, S.Thompson, J.Macmillan
C: S.Gibson, B.Cunnington, S.Atley
CHF: N.Hrovat, J.Waite, T.Garner
FF: S.Higgins, B.Brown, M.Wood
Foll: T.Goldstein, J.Ziebell, A.Swallow
Int: R.Clarke, K.Turner, T.Dumont, J.Simpkin
E: B.Preuss, D.Mountford, C.Wagner

Anyone have a different sides? I know I'm a Collingwood supporter, just wanting some other opinions. Thanks.
Mountford probably deserves a spot IMO. Not sure if Wood did enough this year.
 

ArchKing Carey

Club Legend
Jun 17, 2011
1,140
2,961
Melbourne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Toronto Raptors, Arsenal FC
Prob
North Melbourne:

FB: M.Williams, R.Tarrant, A.Mullett
CHB: L.McDonald, S.Thompson, J.Macmillan
C: S.Gibson, B.Cunnington, S.Atley
CHF: N.Hrovat, J.Waite, T.Garner
FF: S.Higgins, B.Brown, M.Wood
Foll: T.Goldstein, J.Ziebell, A.Swallow
Int: R.Clarke, K.Turner, T.Dumont, J.Simpkin
E: B.Preuss, D.Mountford, C.Wagner

Anyone have a different sides? I know I'm a Collingwood supporter, just wanting some other opinions. Thanks.
Probably squeeze in Ed Vickers-Willis in place of JMac. JMac to the bench with Turner in the emergencies.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

roos_fanatic08

Brownlow Medallist
Sep 21, 2008
20,161
29,786
Vic
AFL Club
North Melbourne
North Melbourne:

FB: M.Williams, R.Tarrant, A.Mullett
CHB: L.McDonald, S.Thompson, J.Macmillan
C: S.Gibson, B.Cunnington, S.Atley
CHF: N.Hrovat, J.Waite, T.Garner
FF: S.Higgins, B.Brown, M.Wood
Foll: T.Goldstein, J.Ziebell, A.Swallow
Int: T.Dumont, R.Clarke, D.Mountford, J.Simpkin
E: K.Turner, B.Preuss, E.Vickers-Willis

Anyone have a different sides? I know I'm a Collingwood supporter, just wanting some other opinions. Thanks.
Turner was out 4th best goal kicker. Would've been top 2 if he didn't get injured. As much as I love what Simpkin, Wood and Mountford brought to the table I I think one of them has to be swapped out for Turner.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

GarnerSmash

With new and improved hamstrings!
Jun 2, 2009
26,373
50,340
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Tough to pick a team out of 36 players when the 22nd player played only 13 games for the year.

Atley - 22 games
Brown - 22
Gibson - 22
Hrovat - 22
McDonald - 22
Higgins - 21
Tarrant - 21
Thompson - 21
Cunnington - 20
Dumont - 19
Goldstein - 19
Ziebell - 19
Mullett - 18
Garner - 18
Swallow - 16
Clarke - 15
Turner - 15
Macmillan - 13
Hansen - 13
Simpkin - 13
M. Williams - 13
Mountford - 12
Waite - 10
Wood - 10
Thomas - 9
Durdin - 8
Preuss - 8
Neilson - 7
Daw - 7
Vickers-Willis - 7
Anderson - 5
Hibberd - 4
Wagner - 4
Zurhaar - 4
J. Williams - 2
McKay - 1
 

Gasometer

Hall of Famer
Mar 14, 2002
49,873
58,631
Gasometer Wing
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Kangaroos
Atley - 22 games
Brown - 22
Gibson - 22
Hrovat - 22
McDonald - 22
Higgins - 21
Tarrant - 21
Thompson - 21
Cunnington - 20
Dumont - 19

Goldstein - 19
Ziebell - 19
Mullett - 18
Garner - 18

Swallow - 16
Clarke - 15
Turner - 15
Macmillan - 13

Hansen - 13
Simpkin - 13
M. Williams - 13

Mountford - 12
Waite - 10
Wood - 10

Thomas - 9
Durdin - 8
Preuss - 8
Neilson - 7
Daw - 7
Vickers-Willis - 7
Anderson - 5
Hibberd - 4
Wagner - 4
Zurhaar - 4
J. Williams - 2
McKay - 1


Bold- injuries hurt us - need to get on the park in 2018
Underlined- good years- need to improve again in 2018
Red- form drop off cost us- trade, end of, unsure.
The rest- work in progress
 

GarnerSmash

With new and improved hamstrings!
Jun 2, 2009
26,373
50,340
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Atley - 22 games
Brown - 22
Gibson - 22
Hrovat - 22
McDonald - 22
Higgins - 21
Tarrant - 21
Thompson - 21
Cunnington - 20
Dumont - 19

Goldstein - 19
Ziebell - 19
Mullett - 18
Garner - 18

Swallow - 16
Clarke - 15
Turner - 15
Macmillan - 13

Hansen - 13
Simpkin - 13
M. Williams - 13

Mountford - 12
Waite - 10
Wood - 10

Thomas - 9
Durdin - 8
Preuss - 8
Neilson - 7
Daw - 7
Vickers-Willis - 7
Anderson - 5
Hibberd - 4
Wagner - 4
Zurhaar - 4
J. Williams - 2
McKay - 1


Bold- injuries hurt us - need to get on the park in 2018
Underlined- good years- need to improve again in 2018
Red- form drop off cost us- trade, end of, unsure.
The rest- work in progress
We also had Wright and Jacobs miss every game.
 

Marstermind

Norm Smith Medallist
Oct 16, 2004
7,563
17,455
The Gasometer
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Kangaroos
Tough to pick a team out of 36 players when the 22nd player played only 13 games for the year.
How about just ranking the top 20 players for the year regardless of position. Y'know like that Fox Footy "Greatest" program except good and with hosts that are actually interesting/funny? Don't bag other responses - just post your own. Personally, the top 7 were all OK. The next 13 throw a blanket over differing shades of "meh"

20. Todd Goldstein
19. Jy Simpkin
18. Jarrad Waite
17. Aaron Mullett
16. Jamie Macmillan
15. Nathan Hrovat
14. Andrew Swallow
13. Kayne Turner
12. Taylor Garner
11. Shaun Atley
10. Sam Gibson
9. Trent Dumont
8. Scott Thompson
7. Marley Williams
6. Jack Ziebell
5. Luke McDonald
4. Robbie Tarrant
3. Ben Cunnington
2. Shaun Higgins
1. Ben Brown
 

Gasometer

Hall of Famer
Mar 14, 2002
49,873
58,631
Gasometer Wing
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Kangaroos
How about just ranking the top 20 players for the year regardless of position. Y'know like that Fox Footy "Greatest" program except good and with hosts that are actually interesting/funny? Don't bag other responses - just post your own. Personally, the top 7 were all OK. The next 13 throw a blanket over differing shades of "meh"

20. Todd Goldstein
19. Jy Simpkin
18. Jarrad Waite
17. Aaron Mullett
16. Jamie Macmillan
15. Nathan Hrovat
14. Andrew Swallow
13. Kayne Turner
12. Taylor Garner
11. Shaun Atley
10. Sam Gibson
9. Trent Dumont
8. Scott Thompson
7. Marley Williams
6. Jack Ziebell
5. Luke McDonald
4. Robbie Tarrant
3. Ben Cunnington
2. Shaun Higgins
1. Ben Brown
Meh as in lubbbb?

(Joke)
 

Top Bottom