Roast Team selections need a bake.

[panatha1908]

Team selection definitely needs to be best players and at to our strengths. With lynch out I think its just JR8 and cumbo forward with a mosquito fleet. Balta and Tarrant back, with grimes 3rd up, broad and vlastuin is competition best. Miller has to bide his time. Rumours of Broady heading to Perth this year so positions will open up, but we have to play players in their best positions for the rest of the year and I think that means we ruck with soldo only and give nank a rest.

This week is drop Miller to move balta back and drop nank for another forward, best available. Edwards to play his 300th and then he goes to sub and replaced by best available

 

[SunshineBoy]

Dimma has taken responsibility for a couple of our losses this season which is a good sign, better than someone like Hinkley who always blames the players.

That said, team selection doesn't cause dumb decision making from players who should know better.

When did he take responsibility

 

[TigerImposter]

The coach is responsible for every loss and not just a couple. That’s a bad attitude to blame the players for the rest of the losses. Selection, poor discipline and failing to adapt to the rule changes now implemented for two seasons starts at the coaches head. ATM it stinks like a dead fish one.

 

[living_in_syd]

Wtf are we doing?

We are going into too tall versus a marshall/georgiadis less port in wet.

If we dont drop a tall before the game we are truely stubborn.

Was also brought in costanga as an emergency who is almost guaranteed medi sub. Hes done nothing in the vfl.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Wtf are we doing?

We are going into too tall versus a marshall/georgiadis less port in wet.

If we dont drop a tall before the game we are truely stubborn.

Was also brought in costanga as an emergency who is almost guaranteed medi sub. Hes done nothing in the vfl.

There are a few factual things that may assist you in your anguish here LIS.


1. The team Richmond has named is 0.9 cm shorter on average than the team Port has named.


2. Port have made height neutral selections:

Out Marshall 198cm & Georgiades 192cm.

In Teakle 204cm & Houston 186cm.



3. Richmond have made a near neutral height change:

Out 194cm Grimes

In 196cm Gibcus


4. At the time of the team being selected the Adelaide forecast was for rain earlier in the day likely clearing by evening. Whilst this now seems to have changed, the selectors cannot be expected to know a weather forecast is going to be subsequently altered. Unless they are full time weather forecasters, in which case they would be part-time selectors, which we don’t want.


5. Richmond will have likely taken all 4 emergencies across with them for this crucial match. So with Edwards being removed from the emergencies, wet weather uber-expert chaos boss Castagna joins them - as insurance against the off chance the current forecast proves correct. So we are in the safest of hands.


6. The aforementioned Mr Castagna has been a veritable paragon of positive play in the VFL outfit, as reassuringly articulated by his VFL Coach Mr Steve Morris pursuant to the Smithy’s VFL Round 19 clash versus Brisbane Lions2 at the Swinburne Centre:





Beside those 6 small points I couldn’t see any further RFI’s in your post.

 

[living_in_syd]

We looked better when grimes went out and rioli in last game. Match up wise, dixon gets tarrant and balta for the finlayson/resting ruck.

Gibcus/broad/miller are the left overs with lynch/jack already up forward. We dont need 3rd tall clogging it up.

Seeing their team and weather, we better make a chnage otherwise we are just stupid or just stubborn.

Also, bringing back castanga after a few vfl games (mind you we have look way better without him). He cant kick and gets most of his goals out the back. I dont care if he kicks 10 of these in the vfl.

 

[Dunger]

If the match committee don't use wheelofnames.com already, they bloody well should be

 

[living_in_syd]

Lol they didnt name castanga on thursday now his medi sub

 

[Serenitylater]

Costanza comes in

 

[living_in_syd]

Are we tanking? Cos castanga is back in the 18 after doing nothing at vfl or afl level

 

[Karp3_dm]

Are we tanking? Cos castanga is back in the 18 after doing nothing at vfl or afl level

Really strange decision
Like wtf

 

[captain blood 17]

A cake or pasta bake? Happy with either.

 

[Lord of the Wings]

Disgusting by Dimma and co. Lost the plot. Talk about rewarding mediocrity and ignoring reserves form

 

[WATiger86]

Disgusting by Dimma and co. Lost the plot. Talk about rewarding mediocrity and ignoring reserves form

George literally played as the sub last week so was part of the squad - 3
In, none out (yet).

What changes would you have made?

 

[Lord of the Wings]

George literally played as the sub last week so was part of the squad - 3
In, none out (yet).

What changes would you have made?

Out: Graham, Miller & Cantstandya
In: Stack, Ryan & RCD as medi sub.

The 3 standout players from the 2nds come in and the 3 worst performed seniors go out.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

George literally played as the sub last week so was part of the squad - 3
In, none out (yet).

What changes would you have made?

His main change would be the disgraceful D Harwick omitted and the magnificent Lord of the Wings in.

 

[SleepingGiant]

Okay so if castagna is playing the club is literally cooked.

 

[Lord of the Wings]

His main change would be the disgraceful D Harwick omitted and the magnificent Lord of the Wings in.

Nah the pay is not enough and I'd be fined every last cent of it anyway when I call the umpires cheats in the post game press conference each week

 

[WATiger86]

Out: Graham, Miller & Cantstandya
In: Stack, Ryan & RCD as medi sub.

The 3 standout players from the 2nds come in and the 3 worst performed seniors go out.

So RCD comes into the mids for Graham?

Ryan plays back and chops out in the ruck

And stack plays forward for George?

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Castagna was last seen at the club riding off into the sunset, on one of Dimma’s two scooters, with Dimma on the other one.

Lord of the Wings on the 3rd scooter, the little pink one.

 

[Mr Unbelievable]

Castagna was last seen at the club riding off into the sunset, on one of Dimma’s two scooters, with Dimma on the other one.

 

[Lord of the Wings]

So RCD comes into the mids for Graham?

Ryan plays back and chops out in the ruck

And stack plays forward for George?

Ryan pinch hits in the ruck and forward.

Balta, Tarrant and Gibcus is more than enough height in the backline particularly given Mitch Lewis is out.

 

[Lord of the Wings]

Castagna was last seen at the club riding off into the sunset, on one of Dimma’s two scooters, with Dimma on the other one.

Lord of the Wings on the 3rd scooter, the little pink one.

I'd still be going faster than Cantstandya who'd be going around and around in circles

 

[WATiger86]

Ryan pinch hits in the ruck and forward.

Balta, Tarrant and Gibcus is more than enough height in the backline particularly given Mitch Lewis is out.

So what happens to Lynch and JR8 when Ryan’s resting forward? Does one head to the bench?

Picking a team is as much about positions, structures and rotations as it is about the players

 

[Lord of the Wings]

Just seen the umpires - FMD Mollison and Gianfagna. The 2 biggest Richmond haters going around. All players and supporters please bring a tub of lube to the game.