Remove this Banner Ad

Team vs. Carlton

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Chris25

Chris25

Premium Platinum
Veteran 10k Posts Draft Expert NFL Mock Draft Participant Armchair Endzone Participant
Oct 30, 2007
12,284
15,592
Adelaide
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
West End Redbacks, Cleveland Browns
Fremantle
B: Greg Broughton, Chris Tarrant, Nic Suban
HB: Matt de Boer, Luke McPharlin, Paul Duffield
C: Brett Peake, Paul Hasleby, Clayton Hinkley
HF: Stephen Hill, Scott Thornton, Andrew Foster
F: Hayden Ballantyne, Des Headland, Zac Clarke
Foll: Aaron Sandilands, Byron Schammer, David Mundy
I/C (from): Ryan Murphy, Antoni Grover, Kepler Bradley, Daniel Gilmore, Steven Dodd, Garrick Ibbotson, Adam Campbell
In: Murphy, Campbell, Bradley, Hinkley, Gilmore
Out: Matthew Pavlich (calf), Dean Solomon (club susp)

Big news...Clayton Hinkley is in!!!

Oh and it looks like all the kids will be staying in for another week. Pleased to see Clarke and Ballantyne getting another chance.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Re: Team v Carlton

Chris 25 will be happy ;) Hinkley is playing....

Would think the bench would be:
Gilmore, Ibbo, Dodd, Grover (if Grover pulls up lame due to that corky then Keplar)
 
Why are we persisiting with Hinkley.

He is horrible. Pearce or Walters would have been much better options, hell why not play Ruffles?
 
Re: Team v Carlton

samseenee said:
Chris 25 will be happy ;) Hinkley is playing...
Click to expand...

Happy is one way to describe it. :D

Expect Hinkley to come out firing and to feature in the votes this week. Will be given a job to show off his new found tagging skills, while will no doubt have an impact going forward too. Will have everyone asking where has been this year after this weekend. :)
 
Re: Team v Carlton

CARLTON
B: Mark Austin, Michael Jamison, Aaron Joseph
HB: Shaun Grigg, Bret Thornton, Jordan Russell
C: Bryce Gibbs, Eddie Betts, Marc Murphy
HF: Brad Fisher, Setanta O’hAilpin, Ryan Houlihan
F: Jeff Garlett, Brendan Fevola, Kade Simpson
Foll: Matthew Kreuzer, Andrew Carrazzo, Chris Judd
Int (from): Dennis Armfield , Joe Anderson, Greg Bentley, Cameron Cloke, Shaun Hampson, Chris Johnson, Chris Yarran

In Joe Anderson, Greg Bentley, Cameron Cloke, Jeff Garlett, Chris Johnson, Bret Thornton, Jordan Russell, Chris Yarran
Out: Paul Bower (injured), Jordan Bannister, Steven Browne, Nick Stevens, Heath Scotland (omitted)
 
Mundy said:
Why are we persisiting with Hinkley.

He is horrible. Pearce or Walters would have been much better options, hell why not play Ruffles?
Click to expand...

Ill give that a amen. Ruffles is being flat out robbed. Three times the player Hinkley is and ever will be
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Embers said:
Ill give that a amen. Ruffles is being flat out robbed. Three times the player Hinkley is and ever will be
Click to expand...

Except he weighs about 2 kgs, and they are both completely different players :rolleyes: I think Hinkley could still be something

Actually I'm all for giving the dregs a go in these dire needs, we might find that there is a player in 1 or 2 of them.... I hope :(
 
Looks like the selectors over at Carlton have had a bit of an over-reaction to last week in my opinion. Looking at there team though, Grover might be needed this week.

Fevola, O'hAilpin and Fisher will all play as permanent forwards. While Kreuzer will also spend some time up forward. So I'd imagine we will need Grover, the only other scenario would be to bring in Bradley to play on Kreuzer. But I can't see that happening.

Tarrant - Fevola
Grover - O'hAilpin (can just imagine the fights...)
McPharlin - Kreuzer
Broughton - Fisher
Suban - Garlett (speed might be the problem, but we should actually give Suban an opponent this week)
Duffield - Houlihan (expose his serious lack of defensive skills)

Could Dodd be one to miss out this week? I think Grover, Ibbo and Gilmore will all play this week. And I'd imagine we will go in with one of Murphy/Campbell/Bradley.
 
Chris25 said:
Looks like the selectors over at Carlton have had a bit of an over-reaction to last week in my opinion. Looking at there team though, Grover might be needed this week.

Fevola, O'hAilpin and Fisher will all play as permanent forwards. While Kreuzer will also spend some time up forward. So I'd imagine we will need Grover, the only other scenario would be to bring in Bradley to play on Kreuzer. But I can't see that happening.

Tarrant - Fevola
Grover - O'hAilpin (can just imagine the fights...)
McPharlin - Kreuzer
Broughton - Fisher
Suban - Garlett (speed might be the problem, but we should actually give Suban an opponent this week)
Duffield - Houlihan (expose his serious lack of defensive skills)

Could Dodd be one to miss out this week? I think Grover, Ibbo and Gilmore will all play this week. And I'd imagine we will go in with one of Murphy/Campbell/Bradley.
Click to expand...

He rooted your sister?
 
That wasn't supposed to sound negative towards Suban. I want him to have a job to do, he hasn't had that for the past few weeks. He seems like the type of guy who plays better when he has a certain role. I think we'll see the best of him, if he has a direct opponent. Plus it will give him someone to fight with. :thumbsu:

Maybe I should stop mentioning Suban though, whenever I do it seems to come off in a negative way. :confused:
 
Re: Team v Carlton

Chris25 said:
Happy is one way to describe it. :D

Expect Hinkley to come out firing and to feature in the votes this week. Will be given a job to show off his new found tagging skills, while will no doubt have an impact going forward too. Will have everyone asking where has been this year after this weekend. :)
Click to expand...

Thanks Mrs Hinkley:thumbsu:

I for one am puzzled by these selections. Thought Ruffles was a monty & we must give Drum a chance at some point unless he really is no longer required.
Walters I understand missing as he & Frodo are playing the same sort of role but I would have though Pearce would get another game, perhaps he's still sore and needs a light run in the WAFL.
But honestly Murphy?
Weird.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Harsh, harsh, harsh on Hinkley. He's 20 years old, and has played 11 games. Whaddya expect?

He's developing a bit of size and is bloody quick. We recruited him when we all and sundry were baying for more speed.

He just needs to get more football into him whether at WAFL or AFL level. By contrast, Matty de Boer is a year older, Broughton nearly 3 years older.

Good if Walters could come in but I reckon he just doesn't have the tank to play AFL at this point.
 
Chris25 said:
Looks like the selectors over at Carlton have had a bit of an over-reaction to last week in my opinion. Looking at there team though, Grover might be needed this week.

Fevola, O'hAilpin and Fisher will all play as permanent forwards. While Kreuzer will also spend some time up forward. So I'd imagine we will need Grover, the only other scenario would be to bring in Bradley to play on Kreuzer. But I can't see that happening.

Tarrant - Fevola
Grover - O'hAilpin (can just imagine the fights...)
McPharlin - Kreuzer
Broughton - Fisher
Suban - Garlett (speed might be the problem, but we should actually give Suban an opponent this week)
Duffield - Houlihan (expose his serious lack of defensive skills)

Could Dodd be one to miss out this week? I think Grover, Ibbo and Gilmore will all play this week. And I'd imagine we will go in with one of Murphy/Campbell/Bradley.
Click to expand...

garlett goes missing for at least 3 quarters every game. Suban will have a pretty good game if he's on garlett

The funny thing is. Houlihan has been playiing mainly as a defensive HFFer. beat Fisher when we played saints. will be a matchup to watch.
 
Dr Ralph Dagg said:
Harsh, harsh, harsh on Hinkley. He's 20 years old, and has played 11 games. Whaddya expect?

He's developing a bit of size and is bloody quick. We recruited him when we all and sundry were baying for more speed.

He just needs to get more football into him whether at WAFL or AFL level. By contrast, Matty de Boer is a year older, Broughton nearly 3 years older.

Good if Walters could come in but I reckon he just doesn't have the tank to play AFL at this point.
Click to expand...

De Boer is only 19 :)

Clancee may not be 100% aswell.
 
Lach72 said:
He rooted your sister?
Click to expand...

Chris25 said:
That wasn't supposed to sound negative towards Suban. I want him to have a job to do, he hasn't had that for the past few weeks. He seems like the type of guy who plays better when he has a certain role. I think we'll see the best of him, if he has a direct opponent. Plus it will give him someone to fight with. :thumbsu:

Maybe I should stop mentioning Suban though, whenever I do it seems to come off in a negative way. :confused:
Click to expand...


Nah dont Chris, its kinda funny the reactions you get. It just come accross as you are a Suban hater.
I have however pondered if Suban was your buddy would you give him as much love as Hinkers? Just a question.... :p

I think if Gilmore plays we wont need Bradley as we have Clarke as the back up ruckman, or Gilmore (who has been serviceable in that role b4) to fill that positon. And on a side note Gilmore gets both feet up off the ground when he jumps unlike Big Keps who struggles to get the knuckles up ;).

So does that mean Gimore plays of half back and Hinkers get's his tagging role?
Ibbo to Judd
Dodd to someone who wont K him TFO
Campbell up forward
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Team vs. Carlton

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top