team vs freo

[ant555]

IN: Ryder, Peverill, Lovett, Johns
OUT: Hird (inj), Solomon (inj), Cartledge (omitted), Heffernan (omitted)


Solomon, Heff and Slattery are the emergencies.


Im ****ing sick of these crap changes.

crap?? at least they are being picked on form in the VFL.
I know most of us see Pev as finished but in all fairness he is playing for his future and if you get 25 plus possessions in the ressies then you should be looked at.

 

[mcphee_is_a_gun]

crap?? at least they are being picked on form in the VFL.
I know most of us see Pev as finished but in all fairness he is playing for his future and if you get 25 plus possessions in the ressies then you should be looked at.

Obviously not or else Jolley would've got a game long ago

 

[ant555]

Obviously not or else Jolley would've got a game long ago

What are we going to turn Jolley into another star who doesnt get a go at Essendon?
His form has been pretty good for Bendigo but he hasnt exactly taken the game by the scruff of the neck every week. He isnt our saviour . He will get a go at some stage.

 

[mcphee_is_a_gun]

What are we going to turn Jolley into another star who doesnt get a go at Essendon?
His form has been pretty good for Bendigo but he hasnt exactly taken the game by the scruff of the neck every week. He isnt our saviour . He will get a go at some stage.

I never said that but he has been consistantly very good and should be getting a game ahead of at least Peveril easily.

 

[ant555]

I never said that but he has been consistantly very good and should be getting a game ahead of at least Peveril easily.

So basicly loyal clubmen who have given their all for us should just be given no shot at proving their worth when their careers are on the line even if their form in the VFL is better than some of the kids.I cant see Pev being around next year , in fact he shouldnt be but he also deserves a few chances to prove his worth.
I have seen 95% of the games Jolley has played for Bendigo and it has only been the last 6 or so games he has started to produce consistant form.

 

[mcphee_is_a_gun]

So basicly loyal clubmen who have given their all for us should just be given no shot at proving their worth when their careers are on the line even if their form in the VFL is better than some of the kids.I cant see Pev being around next year , in fact he shouldnt be but he also deserves a few chances to prove his worth.
I have seen 95% of the games Jolley has played for Bendigo and it has only been the last 6 or so games he has started to produce consistant form.

The same can be said for Jolley. He needs to prove his qorth at AFL level or else hes gone...

 

[ant555]

The same can be said for Jolley. He needs to prove his qorth at AFL level or else hes gone...

So what you are saying is 1 year on the rookie list gives him more credits than Perveril ?
Jolley only has to play well in the VFL for the rest of the year to get another shot.

 

[mcphee_is_a_gun]

So what you are saying is 1 year on the rookie list gives him more credits than Perveril ?
Jolley only has to play well in the VFL for the rest of the year to get another shot.

I thought Jolley couldnt be re rookied after this year?

Peveril has had his chances and has been proved not to be good enough.

 

[carn_the_dons]

any word on mcphee? if he doesn't play i reckon heffernan will come back in.

 

[Benno_900]

For all the speculation of us possibly beating Carlton, Kangas (prior to the result...) this game is beginning to look like a possible win. Freo dont look threatening n their only game breaker right now is Pavlich...perhaps Hedland also but Im not really sold on the rest of the side...might have to suss out some odds on us winning this one...anyone have this same niggling thought?

Sorry, but if you can't beat us...

 

[stander]

IN: Ryder, Peverill, Lovett, Johns
OUT: Hird (inj), Solomon (inj), Cartledge (omitted), Heffernan (omitted)


Solomon, Heff and Slattery are the emergencies.


Im ****ing sick of these crap changes.

You better get used to it Macca because Sheedy has plenty of crap to feed the supporters between now and the middle of next year in his quest to wring out another contract extension. The reconnaisance mission he spun out for the Perth trip was garbage. Supporters are getting sick of this type of line.

 

[ant555]

I thought Jolley couldnt be re rookied after this year?

Peveril has had his chances and has been proved not to be good enough.

He cant be rookied but if he plays out the year well for Bendigo there is a very strong chance he will be elevated onto the senior list.He is not in a position where he has to soley rely on playing senior footy to gain a spot on the senior list.

You and i both agree Pev is past it , my only point is there has to be a balance between giving the young blokes a chance and showing some loyalty and respect to those who have given the club plenty.

 

[mcphee_is_a_gun]

He cant be rookied but if he plays out the year well for Bendigo there is a very strong chance he will be elevated onto the senior list.He is not in a position where he has to soley rely on playing senior footy to gain a spot on the senior list.

You and i both agree Pev is past it , my only point is there has to be a balance between giving the young blokes a chance and showing some loyalty and respect to those who have given the club plenty.

I can see your point even if i don'y really agree with it.

 

[Longy413]

I'm not sure what all the fuss is about.

Three senior players have gone out and a kid that clearly isn't up to it.

Three kids have come in and a bloke who we'd presume would be on his last chance.

Yeah we all want to see the kids, we have two more playing than last week.

Call me crazy, but I have a sneaking suspision that the side might just line up as is.