Workshop Template Feedback Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

magpienato

The Swooping Magpie
Oct 27, 2016
4,830
6,751
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Packers, Raptors, Renegades
Just been working on a new realistic template using the Yellow Images one as a base. Made slight adjustments to the cuffs and collars and I reckon it's turned out quite well but open to a second opinion on here. The image of the template after has shotty quality but it's HD I assure you.

Before After
1590977202089.png
1590977185552.png
 

Log in to remove this ad.

fancyscum

I C O N
May 19, 2012
4,775
9,984
Melbourne
AFL Club
Adelaide
Just been working on a new realistic template using the Yellow Images one as a base. Made slight adjustments to the cuffs and collars and I reckon it's turned out quite well but open to a second opinion on here. The image of the template after has shotty quality but it's HD I assure you.

Before After
View attachment 884797 View attachment 884796
really like the adjustment to the neckline, what are you going to be doing in terms of shorts and socks?
 

magpienato

The Swooping Magpie
Oct 27, 2016
4,830
6,751
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Packers, Raptors, Renegades
really like the adjustment to the neckline, what are you going to be doing in terms of shorts and socks?
Thanks, I'm planning to use the Yellow images shorts I have (I think they're the Rugby Shorts) and try shorten the height of them to give them a ratio closer to footy shorts. As for the Sock I'll probably just use those soccer ones they have.
1590982053706.png


Edit: Just put this together in a short amount of time (mind the pun). Was a lot easier to do than I anticipated but I think they pass pretty good as footy shorts.
1590983916881.png
 
Last edited:

exile

Premium Platinum
Jul 21, 2010
6,989
9,278
Gold Coast
AFL Club
Gold Coast
Other Teams
Philadelphia 76ers
after working on a couple of realistic guernsey templates following el scorcho's guide, i found an image that was a bit simpler to work with (see original image in spoiler below) in regards to working up designs.

i've come up with the below as a presentation template (with a couple other templates for competitions to be used down the track), showing the whole set. i've tested this new template based on a previously created design for reference (see below in spoiler).

01_DISPLAY.png


02_DISPLAY.png


03_DISPLAY.png


PRESENTATION.png
FRONT GUERNSEY ORIGINAL.jpg

think i've got most of the shading fairly accurate, there are some tricky bits i'm not 100% on around the shorts.

also gave a new collar a go (didn't like the hawks one haha), based on the eagles castore set up. might play around with some other options too.

having not worked with designs on a 3d guernsey before, i still need to work on it a bit. not entirely sure how the sash should be positioned, looks like it's slightly off line a bit. i guess the best way to try and learn is to try recreate designs from existing teams and see how it best works.

any other feedback would be appreciated, cheers.
 

Andonis1997

All-Round Good Guy
Jun 24, 2011
24,952
14,451
Adelaide
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
ΠΓΣΣ Reds Sturt Steelers Nix
after working on a couple of realistic guernsey templates following el scorcho's guide, i found an image that was a bit simpler to work with (see original image in spoiler below) in regards to working up designs.

i've come up with the below as a presentation template (with a couple other templates for competitions to be used down the track), showing the whole set. i've tested this new template based on a previously created design for reference (see below in spoiler).

View attachment 1037068

View attachment 1037069

View attachment 1037070


think i've got most of the shading fairly accurate, there are some tricky bits i'm not 100% on around the shorts.

also gave a new collar a go (didn't like the hawks one haha), based on the eagles castore set up. might play around with some other options too.

having not worked with designs on a 3d guernsey before, i still need to work on it a bit. not entirely sure how the sash should be positioned, looks like it's slightly off line a bit. i guess the best way to try and learn is to try recreate designs from existing teams and see how it best works.

any other feedback would be appreciated, cheers.
God that looks clean. And with unconvenional designs they're always going to look better than the standard stripes/sashes/hoops on a realistic template at first.

With the smart guides have you tried replicating Mitchell's guernsey? Because that would be a great start, and then go your hoops and everything else should fall in line! The sash does look like it gets wider on the left but try finding a reference image and slightly adjust your guides accordingly until it looks pretty similar 😊
 

BringBackTheAnchor

#Flagmantle2021
Apr 27, 2019
202
693
Westralia
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
Swan Dist, OKC, Dragons FFC
after working on a couple of realistic guernsey templates following el scorcho's guide, i found an image that was a bit simpler to work with (see original image in spoiler below) in regards to working up designs.

i've come up with the below as a presentation template (with a couple other templates for competitions to be used down the track), showing the whole set. i've tested this new template based on a previously created design for reference (see below in spoiler).

View attachment 1037068

View attachment 1037069

View attachment 1037070


think i've got most of the shading fairly accurate, there are some tricky bits i'm not 100% on around the shorts.

also gave a new collar a go (didn't like the hawks one haha), based on the eagles castore set up. might play around with some other options too.

having not worked with designs on a 3d guernsey before, i still need to work on it a bit. not entirely sure how the sash should be positioned, looks like it's slightly off line a bit. i guess the best way to try and learn is to try recreate designs from existing teams and see how it best works.

any other feedback would be appreciated, cheers.
1610005536648.png
 

exile

Premium Platinum
Jul 21, 2010
6,989
9,278
Gold Coast
AFL Club
Gold Coast
Other Teams
Philadelphia 76ers
God that looks clean. And with unconvenional designs they're always going to look better than the standard stripes/sashes/hoops on a realistic template at first.

With the smart guides have you tried replicating Mitchell's guernsey? Because that would be a great start, and then go your hoops and everything else should fall in line! The sash does look like it gets wider on the left but try finding a reference image and slightly adjust your guides accordingly until it looks pretty similar 😊
true that, i guess i'm lucky i found a decent image of one with a traditional design too.

comparison below. i did try to simplify the creases & shadows a bit in some areas, haven't added in the little tag at the bottom right either yet. wasn't too keen on replicating the exact same one, so i'll probably try add one in next. will give the hoops a go as well! from the below i can see a bit of variance in the shading of the shorts, so i might try fix that as well with the blending options.

front-guernsey-comparison.png
 

Rioli8217

Premiership Player
Jul 11, 2019
3,902
3,879
Sydney
AFL Club
Richmond
(MOVED from scorcho's thread to here since it probs wasn't the right thread)

This might sound stupid but have any of you just tried clone stamping the guernsey features out then tracing that part of the guernsey (say body/torso), Then using a solid colour fill followed by a messing with whatever it's called where you find screen and also messing with opacity?
This is what I'm doing for my ABA template. It keeps shadowing and all texture features say like the little dot cooler things on an NBA jersey.
Here's how it's going just to show you the difference I haven't completed it but left a line between red and orange.
ABAtemp.png

EDIT: I really f’ed up the terminology lol.
EDIT 2: I know I screwed some clone stamps up no need to tell me ;)
 
Last edited:

El_Scorcho

Brownlow Medallist
Aug 21, 2007
27,254
69,384
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Aston Villa, San Antonio Spurs
(MOVED from scorcho's thread to here since it probs wasn't the right thread)

This might sound stupid but have any of you just tried clone stamping the guernsey features out then tracing that part of the guernsey (say body/torso), Then using a solid colour fill followed by a messing with whatever it's called where you find screen and also messing with opacity?
This is what I'm doing for my ABA template. It keeps shadowing and all texture features say like the little dot cooler things on an NBA jersey.
I don't mean to discredit anything and I feel like the other one is more of a flex since it takes more work but this might be easier for beginners.
Here's how it's going just to show you the difference I haven't completed it but left a line between red and orange.
View attachment 1040400
EDIT: I really f’ed up the terminology lol.
EDIT 2: I know I screwed some clone stamps up no need to tell me ;)
I use Photoshop CS6's content aware fill a lot for this sort of thing, removing logos etc

Basically, trace around the item you want to remove, then edit > fill and make sure it's set to content aware.

You might need to have a couple of goes at it and use the healing brush or clone stamp tool to tidy it up, but I find that the most efficient way. It won't keep things like the perforation dots properly though.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Fizzler

BBTB
Dec 26, 2013
10,578
11,376
Melbourne
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
BOLTS, REN, OKC, WFC, LVB, STORM
Been a bit quiet because I've lost access to adobe products however I've been working on making some templates in keynote. This is one that I've made up and quite happy with it- Thoights?

View attachment 1061390
Keynote is the Apple version of powerpoint right? If so, this is really cool and it looks great. Some tips though:
- Maybe bring the cuffs in to make them look less like they stick off the sides of the jumper and more like a part of the jumper.
- Also on the cuffs the bottom looks a bit thinner than the top, I like the thickness of the cuffs at the top so that thickness for the whole length would work.
- I think the NB logo looks a little bit big, I'd shrink that and bring the 3 breast logos down a little bit.
Besides that, really good stuff :thumbsu:
 

Rubber Arm

The Milkman
Oct 10, 2018
840
1,567
Geelong
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Geelong, Chelsea, Miami
Been a bit quiet because I've lost access to adobe products however I've been working on making some templates in keynote. This is one that I've made up and quite happy with it- Thoights?

View attachment 1061390
Looks good you've done well. Fizzler is right with the cuffs and I'd say bring the hem stitching up a tad and also use the AFL number font. Keep up the good work

On SM-G991B using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

The Victorian

Premiership Player
Oct 23, 2018
3,330
2,924
Victoria
AFL Club
Gold Coast
Other Teams
Storm, Western Utd
Keynote is the Apple version of powerpoint right? If so, this is really cool and it looks great. Some tips though:
- Maybe bring the cuffs in to make them look less like they stick off the sides of the jumper and more like a part of the jumper.
- Also on the cuffs the bottom looks a bit thinner than the top, I like the thickness of the cuffs at the top so that thickness for the whole length would work.
- I think the NB logo looks a little bit big, I'd shrink that and bring the 3 breast logos down a little bit.
Besides that, really good stuff :thumbsu:
Is this better?
1613790470059.png
 

Remove this Banner Ad