My summary of the Bucks situation is this:
After 5 years I am still not sold on him as our senior coach. There are definitely things i have liked, and our best football under him, even with the current young list, has shown to be good enough to beat/compete with the best. There have also been a lot of things out of his hands that have gone against him. (Injuries, the "rat pack", Keefe/Thomas and Robbos "report" this year to name a few).
But our worst has been deplorable, and on show far too often.
Right now we sitting right at the bottom (or just below) of the range I expected us to be in this year.
Pre-Bye I was convinced he was done.
Right now, i have seen enough (just) to give it one more year... But how many times can we give "one more year"?
Also comes down to who else might be available.