Mega Thread The Adam Goodes Megathread - Now with Added Poll!

Why are crowds booing Goodes?

  • Racism

    Votes: 565 29.9%
  • He's perceived as a dirty player

    Votes: 563 29.8%
  • He's perceived as making a team game all about himself

    Votes: 758 40.1%
  • Because everyone else is booing, I thought I'd join in - like a Mexican wave thing

    Votes: 268 14.2%
  • Because Gillon doesnt want them to

    Votes: 135 7.2%
  • I have no idea

    Votes: 74 3.9%
  • Other

    Votes: 183 9.7%
  • His onfield message is at odds with his off field one

    Votes: 233 12.3%
  • He can do no wrong with the MRP

    Votes: 164 8.7%
  • I was saying Boo-Urns?

    Votes: 61 3.2%
  • Jack Watts

    Votes: 56 3.0%

  • Total voters
    1,888
Status
Not open for further replies.

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Joined
May 22, 2015
Posts
2,345
Likes
4,736
Location
Baltimore
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Other Teams
Seattle Seahawks
I made the point earlier.

Booing is herd behaviour. It's fuelled by negativity, which in this case has turned plain nasty. It's simplistic, unintelligent and has little basis in consistency or considered reasoning. "He's a flog, I don't like him". (Forget you have flogs in your own team you don't boo). "He's dirty" (never mind all the other dirty players running around). "He says/does things I don't like". Or the doozy - "I've been told I can't boo him, so I'm gonna boo him". And so on.

The booing in the Goodes case is coming from the most unsophisticated, uneducated and unpleasant part of the supporters in question.

I think my statement is pretty spot on.
In WA on the weekend, absolutely it was herd behavior. But then it was when Watson and Selwood copped it over there too. Where the media outrage?

Of course we defend/ignore the behavior of our own flogs. Like the Swans fans that use to call Buddy a "one season wonder" or drug user. Now he plays for them, he's a star and he is a better human because of the Bloods culture. That's tribalism, thats sport. Do I boo Puopolo or Lewis for staging? No. Do I boo Selwood and Monfries for the same thing? Yes. Internally do I like any of the 4 doing it? Absolutely not!

Booing Goodes is now a sport, but this would've all went away earlier if the media didn't stir the pot, the Swans didn't play the race card and if they simply went to the AFL before Indigenous Round, discussed the spear dance, did it pre-game with the school children and made it into some about the round. Instead, it was done in a manner that had the potential to cause issue and hate and now people are surprised it did. And if you call him, the AFL or Sydney out on it, you're racist and don't get it. It's been a PR disaster and could've been stopped months ago. Now, it's a run away freight train.

I just don't like the name calling and finger point from one side, when both really are to blame and just being tribal about their POV.
 

Balony_pony16

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Sep 18, 2009
Posts
11,952
Likes
5,321
Location
Brisbane
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
I was originally on the fence on this, I've boo'd lots of footballers before. Ryan Griffen comes to mind in the GWS game. Seen it this year directed at my team, when the SCG Sydney crowd got sooky at the Bulldogs winning and boo'd the winning team off the field.

Have never personally booed Goodes, as he's done nothing to a Bulldogs player or staged for a free kick against us that would deserve it. If anything he's talked up the dogs due to his brother playing for us. So he is just another oppositon player who I hope doesn't do well against us.

So originally with the Hawks I was thinking ok so what they're booing him, players get boos all the time. Then it went on again and again, after weeks of it and different supporter bases picking it up, it makes you uncomfortable and question, so why is Goodes singled out like this?

He is not constantly whacking blokes on the field? Doesn't stage for free kicks like a lot of other players. He hasn't walked out on a club in bad circumstances Why this constant vitriol?

Had no issue with him pointing out the racist comments by the girl or the spear dance. Even if I did take issue with it, it wouldn't be enough to want to boo him the next time I saw the Bulldogs line up to play Sydney because again it didn't effect my team. Isn't that the reason you boo at the football? To voice your displeasure at actions by a footballer or umpire that effects your team?

Even if you think you're doing without any racist undertones, ask yourself why do you still need to boo him this week. (if he was playing) What has he done to you or your team to deserve it?
Agree... Although I see clearly how this has all gotten out of control, I do still struggle understanding the ruthless negative behavior AFL crowds in general as it is not something I subscribe too at games. Crowds do love to boo though and you can watch a team that is up by 100 pts still have his supporters go nuts against an umpire for a speculative free kick against when it clearly has nothing to do with the result, and it should be beer up time and getting ready to sing the team song.

Point is booing for the most simple reasons is ingrained into AFL supporters. The Goodes issue is pretty complex but it shouldn't surprise people how & why it how it has got out of control.

Me personally I hate the AFL being used as a vehicle to drive social agendas, and disliked Goodes clear pre-retirement campaigning on the field. But I wouldnt be the type to be booing him the way he has been as I would just feel stupid doing it and I find relentless booing annoying at games generally.
 
Joined
May 29, 2008
Posts
7,515
Likes
5,522
Location
Australia
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
SS Lazio
Have I missed something. What has this got to do with freedom of speach? Do you even know what that is? Freedom of speach is the right to express yourself, your thoughts, your ideas etc. How is the AFL preventing anyone from doing that? You can go to the football next weekend and boo Adam Goodes and all the aboriginal player you see fit. You won't be sent to prison, you won't be charged, hell, you won't even get thrown out of the game. Just that everyone around you will know that you are racist. That is not a breach of freedom of speach that is the fundemental tenant of freedom of speach. You will be judged by what you say, but you won't be breaking the law by saying it.
*Speech.

In the hypothetical scenario you have concocted where I am booing Adam Goodes this week:

No, those around me won't know that I am racist.

The reasons this is wrong are:
  1. Because I am not a racist.
  2. If I choose to boo Adam Goodes I can choose to do so for any reason except if it relates to his race.
  3. I would not boo Lewis Jetta who happens to be of the same race as Adam.
  4. Most people around me will also be booing some might be booing as racists but perhaps they are all not booing because of race.
  5. It is not possible to conclude that I, or anyone else booing, is racist if I, or they, choose to boo Adam Goodes without knowing why I, or they, chose to boo him.
 

bird_man

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Jan 14, 2012
Posts
18,418
Likes
31,602
Location
The River Murray
AFL Club
St Kilda
To me, I don't think what you answer in the poll makes any difference. If you continue to boo Adam Goodes, you are a flog, what ever the reason.

Their have been lot of worse people involved in our great game that did not receive the same crap as this bloke. And I don't even like the fella. Grow up and move on, you are an embarrassment to our great game!
 
Joined
Feb 24, 2013
Posts
35,162
Likes
28,985
Location
The GoldenBrown Heart of Victoria
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Other Teams
Man Utd Green Bay Melb Storm
Who said that? I don't think anyone on here is talking about banning all booing.

Opposition fans have always booed and heckled players taking set shots, or in-game villains. By all means those that want to do that can.
Then they should feel relieved that you have given them permission to do so.
 

Toump Ass

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Jun 14, 2015
Posts
5,815
Likes
11,499
Location
TOUMPASSO LAND
AFL Club
Melbourne
Milne was never booed?
You mean like how nobody ever called Steve Milne RAPIST every single game for ten years?
Adam Goodes' reception gets is worse than anything Milne received. And what Milne was accused of is infinitely worse.

Your post was giving the impression that all indiginous players get boo'ed which isn't true.
You're right, it's not all indigenous players who are booed. Just the one that happens to be most vocal about indigenous issues. Funny that; we only boo the aboriginal who refuses to be silent.

You can guarantee that people will find an excuse to boo Franklin the moment he starts talking about his race. ("Ahhh he's too big for his boots now he does cocaine and he has money, he's a mercenary/dirty player, I've always hated him" :rolleyes:)
 

mcgarnacle

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Dec 2, 2003
Posts
8,250
Likes
2,326
Location
Inner West - Sydney
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
NFL; Sydney FC
If you want to know why people dont like Adam you can just go and read the hundreds of posts of people telling you why. It continues because its now a game with him and it puts him off his game. Pretty simple even a left wing uni student should be able to understand it.
Bullshit.

it's average plebs with insignificant little lives filling empowered by the mob.
 

BlueTouchPaper

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Feb 18, 2009
Posts
5,009
Likes
452
AFL Club
Carlton
Personally I wouldn't be holding to much weight onto Waleeds opinions.

I've read some of his work and he seems to enjoy lumping together different groups, simplifying complex issues by making blanketing statements. To form only two sides of an argument.

In this case, its fine as it only polarising footy fans.
In the case of middle eastern politics, frankly ignorant and quiet dangerous.
Agreed. A man that laments the impact of discrimination, yet practices so much of it in his journalism.

Still have great respect for the guy, and think he's a brilliant commentator on contemporary issues, but needs to be careful of allowing bias creep into his commentary.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

DrEvil_

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Sep 21, 2014
Posts
9,701
Likes
21,087
AFL Club
Hawthorn
I’ve been going back and forth on this issue a fair bit. I know that as a Swans fan I am biased in my judgement, and if I remove that I can see how his reaction to being called an ‘ape’ could be perceived as an over-reaction. I agree that it could have been handled better, and I don’t have an issue with people who think that. In regards to his war dance against Carlton, I can also see how that can be seen as designed to deliberately taunt and tease the crowd to only intensify the booing. Based off that, some people might think that him being a ‘flog’ is justification enough for their booing. I don’t want to get into whether that is right or wrong. I also don’t think that it’s fair to label entire supporter groups as racist because of it.

However all of that being said, I don’t think the booing is really acceptable even if it’s beyond anyone’s control. It would be naïve to think that the booing isn’t race-related given how much it has intensified not only post Collingwood game, but post-AOTY, or post-Carlton war dance. I don’t pretend to know why every single person boos, but I think it’s clear that it has gained traction as a response to the media and because of the sheep mentality. As with a lot of schoolyard bullying, it’s perceived by the perpetrator as harmless and mindless entertainment. It’s funny because everyone else is doing it.

I don’t really think the whole concept of ‘they deserve to be booed because they are a flog’ comes into – that to me just seems like an afterthought as justification for their actions. I don’t think anyone prior to booing would make the conscious thought process of ‘Adam Goodes is a flog so I will just boo him.’ It’s more that you hear the noise and decide to join in, whether because of humour or because everyone else is doing it. I personally believe that is harmful because it is no different to the bullying you see in the playground or on the net – people who aren’t intending to hurt others but moreso doing it to prevent it being done to them or thinking it’s funny and harmless.

I think that the level of criticism he has received is unfair. People wish to label him as a sook but fail to see how manipulated they are by the media. It’s clear as day in the post-game press conferences how many questions are poised to Longmire regarding the boo-ing, whether it is racial vilification, how Adam Goodes feels about it and so on and so forth. What bothers me more than the actual booing itself is the media seeing this as a profitable opportunity and the vast majority lapping it up. Even in light of the other personal scandals that we have seen erupt over the years, I don’t think that any have received the same level of scrutiny and judgement.

The media want to portray him as the saviour for the minority, whilst knowingly pushing him under the bus to be hated. It’s clear as hell that they’ve made a mountain out of a molehill to sell a story, and it’s sad to see someone who is merely just a footballer on the end of it. He could have done things differently, but at the end of the day he didn’t. Maybe he privately regrets publically highlighting the girl at the football game, maybe he doesn’t. I don’t think people can say that they’ve never made a mistake, but they’ve never had to deal with the consequences as publically as Adam has.

As for the people who want to say that life isn’t easy, racism exists, stop being a sook etc. all I can say is I hope you never have a child grow up in an environment where it’s okay to be bullied because of differences you cannot change.

As a Swans fan, it will be a very sad day if he retires. From a pure footballing sense, hate him all you like but he is a legend of the game. Dual premiership player, brownlow medallist, multiple AAs, etc. Off the field, I have met Adam and he is beyond polite and easy-going. He is someone who I personally respect for his ability to bring light to controversial issues, and it is a shame that his exit may potentially be forced because of this. I don’t ever want to see someone forced out of doing something they love because of the actions of others – and I hope that doesn’t happen.
Pretty much this. Also interesting to note that Goodes never said the boos were racist. In fact last year he said he wasn't affected by it. Robbo, Pridham, and the rest of the media gang are the ones calling the boos racist.
 

Balony_pony16

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Sep 18, 2009
Posts
11,952
Likes
5,321
Location
Brisbane
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
25 % boo him because he is a dirty player? Pleeeeease!

If you boo him at least be honest about it people. Why wasn't Barry Hall booed every time he got the football? The great Leigh Matthews?
Seems pointless trying to argue what % of the crowd boos for what % like we can put it in a pie chart
 

mcgarnacle

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Dec 2, 2003
Posts
8,250
Likes
2,326
Location
Inner West - Sydney
AFL Club
Sydney
Other Teams
NFL; Sydney FC
25 % boo him because he is a dirty player? Pleeeeease!

If you boo him at least be honest about it people. Why wasn't Barry Hall booed every time he got the football? The great Leigh Matthews?
they kept their mouth shut about their black heritage.
 

greennick

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Oct 1, 2006
Posts
17,516
Likes
3,066
Location
Boom town
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Steelers & Penguins
It's certainly closer than the one given and perhaps yours is closer again. That said, it's not quite right either when drifting to the "refuse to help" and "every 2-3 years" part. I don't think that's a fair assessment. It might be shoddy workmanship, but there is definitely some effort there.

Regardless, I don't feel any need to apologise to anyone for things I didn't do. The history of mankind is that of expansion, invasion, subjugation, displacement, slavery, so on and so forth. Where Australia fits into that would be but a footnote, not a chapter. I'd spend my whole life running around the world saying sorry if indeed I was somehow responsible for the ills of human history.
After 200 years of oppression, which they still feel is ongoing, we need more than to say sorry to right the wrongs of the past. They need real recognition and to feel in control of their own destiny. And most of all they need to feel accepted.

You shouldn't feel the need to be sorry for what your ancestors did, however it is good and just to try and right those wrongs in a reasonable manner.
 

JohnnyFontane90

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Feb 14, 2014
Posts
5,596
Likes
7,585
AFL Club
Carlton
Pretty much this. Also interesting to note that Goodes never said the boos were racist. In fact last year he said he wasn't affected by it. Robbo, Pridham, and the rest of the media gang are the ones calling the boos racist.
yes the media is throwing this racist label around. which is pissing everyone off because most people are not racist and that the outlet of expression for that is adam goodes because it seemed to all start with him.
 
Joined
Jun 9, 2004
Posts
5,984
Likes
6,801
Location
NSW
AFL Club
Richmond
My opinion is that the boos started from (as Dermie has suggested) the way Goodes stages for free kicks.

Just like when a player - say Vickery clocks someone he receives boo's very time he goes near the ball after the incident.

The reason for this is that an AFL crowd is like theatre, the audience is seeking the 'bad guy' to single out.

That player, just as in Goodes case, isn't really a bad guy. They've just been selected to play that role and there is a mob mentality with the crowd and people just bandwagon and join in.

I believe that most people aren't booing for racism reasons. I think there is a very small minority that possibly turned it into that, and some that are booing just because everyone else is and have no idea why and it seems like fun.

In any case, it's snowballed and definitely needs to cease immediately. It is undeserved.

It's possible that this issue will become so big that it initially has a very damaging effect, but will ultimately have a positive effect.
 

Balony_pony16

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Sep 18, 2009
Posts
11,952
Likes
5,321
Location
Brisbane
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
the greatest example of targeted booing in Australian sport was that of Wally Lewis whenever he came down to Sydney.

the undertones are clearly different here.
Being a lions supporter in SA I have watched many games live down here. AKA seemed to get relentlessly booed every time by the crowd back in the day. Being new to AFL back then after moving down and previously being a rugby supporter I was surprised how aggressive mass sections of the crowd would behave relentlessly towards a player. Kinda used to it now
 

bird_man

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Jan 14, 2012
Posts
18,418
Likes
31,602
Location
The River Murray
AFL Club
St Kilda
Seems pointless trying to argue what % of the crowd boos for what % like we can put it in a pie chart
I was just going off what people answered in the poll above. As I said in my earlier post, I don't care what reason people like to choose for booing him. If you do it, you're a flog.
 

Hydrurga

Spitta or Swallow?
Joined
Jan 14, 2015
Posts
994
Likes
2,622
Location
Tasmania
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
The Exers
In WA on the weekend, absolutely it was herd behavior. But then it was when Watson and Selwood copped it over there too. Where the media outrage?

Of course we defend/ignore the behavior of our own flogs. Like the Swans fans that use to call Buddy a "one season wonder" or drug user. Now he plays for them, he's a star and he is a better human because of the Bloods culture. That's tribalism, thats sport. Do I boo Puopolo or Lewis for staging? No. Do I boo Selwood and Monfries for the same thing? Yes. Internally do I like any of the 4 doing it? Absolutely not!

Booing Goodes is now a sport, but this would've all went away earlier if the media didn't stir the pot, the Swans didn't play the race card and if they simply went to the AFL before Indigenous Round, discussed the spear dance, did it pre-game with the school children and made it into some about the round. Instead, it was done in a manner that had the potential to cause issue and hate and now people are surprised it did. And if you call him, the AFL or Sydney out on it, you're racist and don't get it. It's been a PR disaster and could've been stopped months ago. Now, it's a run away freight train.

I just don't like the name calling and finger point from one side, when both really are to blame and just being tribal about their POV.
Absolutely spot on Habitual. Couldn't have said it any better myself.
 

Heeney2Franklin

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Nov 20, 2007
Posts
24,881
Likes
14,484
Location
Sydney
AFL Club
Sydney
How much change in the behaviour can you expect when you have people like Miranda Devine, Rita Panahi pandering articles to their racist audience.

Miranda Devine articles especially have been utterly sickening not sure how she has a job in writing.
 

Mr Magic

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Mar 1, 2010
Posts
16,001
Likes
7,608
AFL Club
Richmond
Bullshit.

it's average plebs with insignificant little lives filling empowered by the mob.

Rather elitist to be calling members of the crowd average plebs with insignificant lives don't you think?

Frankly I do not attend Swans games. No atmosphere and the fact the big guy has to rev up the chant for the Swans is kinda embarrassing
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom