The AFL wants 22 teams. Name your next four.

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Ronnie Baby

Specified
Oct 19, 2011
5,133
6,923
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Other Teams
Brisbane Heat
Where is North-South Melbourne located?
North of Melbourne? Or South of Melbourne?
Isn’t it less confusing to call them Central Melbourne?
It is the Northern part of South Melbourne

It won't be called Central Melbourne because the Central Melbourne bid was unsuccessful
 

Dirty Bird

Pokémon Master
Aug 1, 2010
30,426
17,099
Adelaide
AFL Club
Adelaide
Other Teams
#BostonStrong #RiseUp
1) Tasmania
2) Canberra
3) Liverpool (Sydney)
4) NQ (8 games Cairns, 2 Townsville, 1 Mackay)

I dont see any benefit in Adelaide or Perth. There's next to no growth potential.

Adelaide is more logical (2nd team draws ~80% capacity) but there's no realistic alternative. If you bring in Norwood (next largest team in Adelaide) you'd be lucky to see 20k outside of games vs Adelaide and Port. While gaining what? Probably nothing. Perth seemed the logical option for YEARS while at Subiaco as Freo started selling out about 10 years into their existence. Thing is. You can see today that they're tiny in comparison to West Coast. For every reason one has to suggest supporting a 3rd team, you could easily point them the way of the Dockers at the very same time. Quite a few empty seats at their games.....

- I went Tasmania due to it having substantial local support which will mean it's viable.
- I went Canberra as it has a large expat population there. It'd be similar to Gold Coast where it mightn't get alot of people going all in on them, but they'd get enough buying tickets and make them their second team
- I went Liverpool because Sydney will need a #3 team going forward, and Liverpool is about the right location for it. Sydney is covering the East (and North East) while GWS is getting the West (and North West) - Sooooooooooooooo much room for growth in the Southern Suburbs of Sydney. Problem with the true south is there's national parks there. So it needs to be South-West imo, I dont like going as far out as Campbelltown, so Liverpool/Glenside area is where it's at. But you gotta go Liverpool to hook any Liverpool soccer fans ;)
- This was the hard one, Very hard to choose between NT, NQ and SEQ3. As much as Brisbane 2/Sunshine Coast felt the greatest opportunity LONG term. I fear it'd be an unmitigated disaster short term. Certainly not worth the risk. And I do believe NT and NQ should both have a team. But I feel that NT would be more likely to take a relocated team than NQ (converting rugby fans over to a relocated team ALOT harder than converting them to a new team. Who'd want Melbourne's scraps?) So Even though NT is the safer short term option. I feel long term when we need to move a St Kilda or a North Melbourne or a Melbourne, it'd be easier to send them to NT. So NQ gets it for me.
 

Our Game

Club Legend
Sep 30, 2014
2,586
1,477
Sandringham
AFL Club
Geelong
Lets hope the AFL are got stupid enough to go to 22 teams!
The comp is still coming to terms with GWS and GC to add any more new teams!
Even if a Tasmanian team were admitted it the AFL they should just take over struggling North Melbourne club and be done with it! Tassie Kangaroos a has a nice ring to it.
 

madmug

Brownlow Medallist
Mar 17, 2009
17,226
11,429
Hobart
AFL Club
Collingwood
Lets hope the AFL are got stupid enough to go to 22 teams!
The comp is still coming to terms with GWS and GC to add any more new teams!
Even if a Tasmanian team were admitted it the AFL they should just take over struggling North Melbourne club and be done with it! Tassie Kangaroos a has a nice ring to it.
It might have a nice ring for you.

Interesting on BF seeing how many Victorians want to export someone elses club.
 

madmug

Brownlow Medallist
Mar 17, 2009
17,226
11,429
Hobart
AFL Club
Collingwood
Especially when the club being 'exported' is stronger than what they want to replace it with.
After 100 years or so, they & some others should be a lot better than they are.

Anyway, the first step is to get kicked out of Tasmania & learn to stand on their own. Hawks too.
 

terrybull

Team Captain
Feb 1, 2004
476
401
Sweden
Other Teams
Helsingborg Australian FC
It is the Northern part of South Melbourne

It won't be called Central Melbourne because the Central Melbourne bid was unsuccessful
so South Melbourne North :p
But hold on! Swans could not get enough support in South Melbourne. Now you want to halve the suburb for a new team? That will go well...
 

Ronnie Baby

Specified
Oct 19, 2011
5,133
6,923
AFL Club
Brisbane Lions
Other Teams
Brisbane Heat
so South Melbourne North :p
But hold on! Swans could not get enough support in South Melbourne. Now you want to halve the suburb for a new team? That will go well...
Swans can't get anybody to support them in a city of millions

Why? Same problem they had in Melbourne, they cast a too wide a net

I believe a targeted area of a few square kilometres is grounds for success
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

FootyJunkie

Brownlow Medallist
Mar 5, 2005
19,368
9,699
Between the Big Sticks
AFL Club
West Coast
20 teams is enough

Add Tas + Canberra

Gold Coast to rebrand as the Northern Suns and play home games out of Nth QLD and Darwin
Agree. I think 20 is the nice round number to strive for in the near/medium term.
Tasmania and Canberra sides would make the league truly national.

We are still far off from sides in NT, North QLD or NZ - decades away.

Final 8 is still fine with 9 finals, but $$$ to be had with a Final 10 if the AFL want to make it go 5 weeks for 13 finals.

Week 1
1st Qualifying Final - 3rd v 6th
1st Elimination Final - 7th v 10th
2nd Qualifying Final - 4th v 5th
2nd Elimination Final - 8th v 9th

Week 2
1st Quarter Final - 1st v Winner 1st Qualifying Final (ex. 1st v 3rd)
3rd Quarter Final - Loser 1st Qualifying Final v Winner 1st Elimination Final (ex. 6th v 7th)
2nd Quarter Final - 2nd v Winner 2nd Qualifying Final (ex. 2nd v 4th)
4th Quarter Final - Loser 2nd Qualifying Final v Winner 2nd Elimination Final (ex. 5th v 8th)

Week 3 (Crossover between opposite sides of the draw)
1st Semi Final - Loser 1st Quarter Final v Winner 4th Quarter Final (ex. 3rd v 5th)
2nd Semi Final - Loser 2nd Quarter Final v Winner 3rd Quarter Final (ex. 4th v 6th)

Week 4 (Another crossover between opposite sides of the draw, possible repeat match ups from Week 1 if there were upsets)
1st Preliminary Final - Winner 1st Quarter Final v Winner 2nd Semi Final (ex. 1st v 4th)
2nd Preliminary Final - Winner 2nd Quarter Final v Winner 1st Semi Final (ex. 2nd v 3rd)

Week 5
Grand Final (ex. 1st v 2nd)
 
Last edited:

Remove this Banner Ad